Page: 6 of 6
Auto GPS: Ratings of Sources
Total of 25 Sources
1. GPSMagazine.com
As of Nov. 2009
GPSMagazine Buyer's Guide -- Editor's Picks
by Editors of GPSMagazine.com
Our Assessment

This site publishes a plethora of incredibly comprehensive reviews. Every feature is tested, and the lavishly illustrated reviews conclude with long lists of pros and cons. Testing methodology is fully explained. The editor lists his top picks here and in a handy, Consumer Reports-style chart -- but neither includes the very latest devices he has reviewed (click the "Reviews" link to find these). By a wide margin, this is the best review source for auto GPS receivers we found.

expand

collapse

2. ConsumerReports.org
As of Nov. 2009
GPS Ratings
by Editors of ConsumerReports.org
Our Assessment

ConsumerReports.org buys products anonymously to ensure unbiased, objective tests. Editors rate and rank 96 portable GPS navigation systems in the most recent update, with results summarized in a detailed ratings chart. A one-page summary for each model includes pros, cons and user ratings, though discussion itself isn't especially detailed. ConsumerReports.org covers a wide range of models from both major and minor brands.

expand

collapse

3. GPS Tracklog
Sept. 18, 2009
Auto GPS Buyers Guide
by Rich Owings
Our Assessment This blog is operated by Rich Owings, who posts information about most major-brand GPS devices, personally reviews some of them and links to reviews and ratings by others. Site users add opinions and occasionally contribute reviews. A buyer's guide lists Owings' picks in budget, midrange and high-end auto GPS.
4. PCMag.com
As of Nov. 2009
GPS Navigation
by Editors of PCMag.com
Our Assessment

PCMag.com regularly reviews new GPS units, identifying each product's place in the market and assigning an overall rating. Reviews are easy to read, even though they aren't as exhaustively detailed as those at dedicated GPS-review websites. Review quality is consistent. Lists of pros and cons are also helpful, but some would only matter to a small percentage of users. Some Editors' Choice picks are older models.

expand

collapse

5. GPSLodge.com
As of Nov. 2009
GPS Reviews
by Scott Martin
Our Assessment

GPSLodge.com identifies itself as a blog dedicated to GPS navigation system news and reviews. This site has original reviews and links to other reviews on the Internet. Site owner Scott Martin reviews inexpensive, entry-level products as well as those with bigger screens and added features, giving clear buying advice in his reviews. He also makes specific recommendations in each price category in his holiday gift guides.

expand

collapse

6. About.com
As of Nov. 2009
About.com: GPS
by Fred Zahradnik
Our Assessment

Fred Zahradnik, About.com's guide to GPS, writes detailed reviews of GPS units with notes on features, pros and cons, and details of some performance testing. Zahradnik seems sensitive to issues sometimes missed in other reviews, such as whether the screen is hard to read in bright sunlight. He hasn't reviewed many new GPS models recently, but a dozen reviews of GPS apps have been added. (Note: ConsumerSearch is owned by About.com, but the two don't share an editorial affiliation.)

expand

collapse

7. PC World
As of Nov. 2009
Latest GPS Reviews
by Editors of PC World
Our Assessment PC World's reviews of auto GPS receivers offer clear buying advice, but editors don't test as many units as other publications. There's a "Top 5 GPS" list, but it's dated. This page rates the most recent GPS models, each with a brief written review and a succinct list of pros and cons.
8. GPSReview.net
As of Nov. 2009
Best GPS Picks
by Editors of GPSReview.net
Our Assessment This site doesn't test a lot of GPS units, but it does a good job reporting the latest trends and pointing out the most important new GPS models and apps. Recently, GPSReview.net posted its first "Best GPS Picks" list, including the TomTom Go 740 Live and Garmin nuvi 265WT.
9. Choice magazine
March 12, 2009
GPS: Car Navigation Reviews
by Editors of Choice magazine
Our Assessment Choice, an Australian consumer-testing organization, is similar to ConsumerReports.org. It doesn't accept freebies to test, and it accepts no advertising. Choice tests 17 auto GPS systems in and around Sydney, through tunnels, tolls, city and country roads, assessing the units' accuracy and usability. Several of the recommended models are widely available in the U.S.
10. Which? magazine
As of Nov. 2009
Sat Nav Reviews
by Editors of Which? magazine
Our Assessment Which? is the U.K.'s answer to ConsumerReports.org. It tests 97 GPS (or sat nav) units in the crowded urban canyons of central London, picking 23 Best Buys. Several are popular U.S. models.
11. CNET
April 24, 2009
Best 5 GPS Systems
by Antuan Goodwin
Our Assessment

CNET has slowed down its reviews of new auto GPS units. This list of top picks includes a couple of discontinued models and none of the latest models. The reviews devote more attention to features than performance. Testing is typically limited to a couple of test drives around San Francisco. However, CNET's reviews are critical, often recommending good alternatives to poor-performing auto GPS units.

expand

collapse

12. TrustedReviews.com
As of Nov. 2009
Car Tech
by Editors of TrustedReviews.com
Our Assessment

This U.K. website provides overly generous ratings in some product categories, but its GPS reviews and ratings are well balanced. Reviewers drive many miles in England and France to test units. The only disadvantage to the reviews here is that not all products are sold in the U.S., and maps and navigation are obviously different in Europe. The TomTom Go 930 Traffic and Garmin nuvi 1490T are the only Recommended picks that are current U.S. models. Also recommended are several U.K. and Australian models.

expand

collapse

13. TechRadar.com
As of Nov. 2009
TomTom, GPS and Sat Nav
by Editors of TechRadar.com
Our Assessment This extensive British site conducts its own expert reviews of consumer tech products. The GPS reviews are well done and easy to read. Although many of the models reviewed aren't available in the U.S., one of the best-rated units is: the TomTom Go 930T.
14. YourNAV.com
As of Nov. 2009
Reviews
by Editors of YourNav.com
Our Assessment

YourNav.com is a British enthusiast website dedicated to personal navigation devices. For a specialty site, it does not offer many reviews. Reviews are not easy to read, either -- they're a bit technical, poorly organized and not focused enough on performance. However, objectivity is terrific, and editors painstakingly cover nitpicky considerations, each of which may be a make-or-break issue for some percentage of consumers. Only one thumbs-up-rated GPS -- the TomTom Go 740 Live -- is available in the U.S.

expand

collapse

15. Pocket-lint.com
As of Nov. 2009
Car and GPS
by Editors of Pocket-Lint.com
Our Assessment Pocket-Lint.com is a British gadget news and reviews site. The auto GPS reviews are good and include some product comparison, but all of the ratings are high, making distinctions difficult. Site navigation is also a nuisance, since GPS systems are mixed with other automotive products, most notably cars. One of the top-ranked current models -- the TomTom Go 740 Live -- is available in the U.S.
16. PocketGPSWorld.com
As of Nov. 2009
GPS Hardware/Personal Navigation Devices Menu
by Editors of PocketGPSWorld.com
Our Assessment This U.K. site has detailed reviews, but auto GPS units are neither rated nor ranked, and the reviews don't adequately distinguish between products. Testers praise the TomTom Go 930T and Nextar I4-BC, both available in the U.S.
17. Wired.com
As of Nov. 2009
Reviews and First Looks
by Editors of Wired
Our Assessment Wired reviews all kinds of gadgets, but its occasional GPS reviews are hard to find on the site. Lately, the TomTom XL 340S and TomTom Go 740 Live have impressed the reviewers.
18. Amazon.com
As of Nov. 2009
Vehicle GPS Units
by Contributors to Amazon.com
Our Assessment

Amazon.com sells all the major brands of auto GPS units and encourages customers to submit ratings of products they've used. Garmin models dominate Amazon's bestseller list, and they earn the highest average ratings. The reviews don't offer the depth of those written by professional reviewers, but this is a good place to learn how auto GPS units work in everyday use. The website is easy to navigate, but discontinued models are mixed in with current ones.

expand

collapse

19. NewEgg.com
As of Nov. 2009
GPS Navigation
by Contributors to Newegg.com
Our Assessment Newegg.com encourages users to post reviews, but it doesn't attract as many consumer ratings as Amazon.com. One advantage over Amazon.com is that Newegg.com asks reviewers to rank their level of technical knowledge.
20. Gizmodo
As of Nov. 2009
GPS Reviews
by Wilson Rothman
Our Assessment

Gizmodo reviews all kinds of gadgets, and it has occasionally reviewed GPS units. But editor Wilson Rothman says the category has peaked with the affordable and very functional Garmin nuvi 1350T, "possibly the last [personal navigation device] we'll ever review." The smartphone will eventually take over car navigation, he says -- but not the Garmin nuvifone; he titles his review of that product "Do Not Buy."

expand

collapse

21. The New York Times
Oct. 7, 2009
As a Phone, It Makes a Good GPS
by David Pogue
Our Assessment The Garmin nuvifone is a great GPS device, but a lousy smartphone, says The New York Times' technology critic David Pogue. He demonstrates why in an amusing video that accompanies this thorough written review.
22. Laptop Magazine
As of Nov. 2009
GPS Reviews
by Troy Dreier
Our Assessment Laptop Magazine has slowed down on its GPS reviews, publishing write-ups on only a few auto GPS models in 2009. However, reviews are critical, with a clear verdict about each model. Laptop Magazine isn't shy about pointing out poor performers, but some of its Editors' Choice picks are outdated.
23. Technical-Itch.co.uk
As of Nov. 2009
Sat Nav Reviews
by Dean Taplin
Our Assessment British blogger Dean Taplin reviews GPS units (called sat-nav units in England). The reviews are critical and well illustrated with photos and screen shots. However, products aren't rated or ranked, which makes it hard for readers to see which auto GPS unit is considered best.
24. GPSInformation.net
As of Nov. 2009
Auto GPS Reviews
by Contributors to GPSInformation.net
Our Assessment

Owned by retired engineers who operate it as a hobby, GPSInformation.net offers detailed reviews of handheld GPS, auto GPS and GPS software. The site delivers what its name says -- it covers all of the information you would ever want about GPS models, with tons of photos of each unit, what comes in the box, screen shots and a rundown of every physical and technical feature. However, the site layout makes reviews difficult to find, and the site operators haven't reviewed many auto GPS units in recent months.

expand

collapse

25. ConsumerGuide.com
As of Nov. 2009
GPS Devices Reviews and Prices
by Editors of ConsumerGuide.com
Our Assessment ConsumerGuide.com occasionally reviews auto GPS units. The reviews are short, noncomparative and unduly favorable. Editors assign each unit an overall rating and subcategory ratings, but they do not reference any product testing. Both of the Best Buy models shown here are outdated. Overall, the reviews do not demonstrate enough expertise or distinctions to provide meaningful consumer guidance.

Back to top