Fisher-Price Starlight Papasan Cradle Swing Review

Updated April 30, 2014
cs-product-header
Fisher-Price Starlight Papasan Cradle Swing
Bottom Line

The Fisher-Price Starlight Papasan Cradle Swing soothes baby with a two-position reclining seat and six swing speeds. The variety of songs and fascinating light show win particular praise, as does the plush star mobile. However, the swing is plagued by reports of faulty motors and some reviewers feel the three-point harness is unsafe.

Safety

Is a three-point harness secure enough? Recommended for use from birth until baby reaches 25 pounds, the Fisher-Price Starlight Papasan Cradle Swing features a three-point harness and tray, although many reviewers wish for a five-point harness to secure baby better. Easy to assemble, a few users say the legs wobble, making the frame seem unstable. The swing offers comfortable, nest-like cushioning for infant head support, as well as two seat-recline positions, but the attached canopy worries some parents when their baby begins to grasp and pull on the fabric.

ProsMultiple swing positions, Electric or battery power, Entertaining featuresConsMotor may be unreliable, Lacks five-point harness, May be too slow for some babies

Performance

Mesmerizing light show. The Fisher-Price Starlight Papasan Cradle Swing is one of the more versatile models available, with six speeds and the ability to swing side to side or front to back. The mobile features visually appealing plush hanging stars and a teddy bear, but it is the light show, which casts stars onto the swing's canopy that parents feel entertains baby more. The swing plays 16 soothing songs, offers a morning and evening music mode, and features adjustable volume control. Some owners complain that the swing, which runs on four D batteries or electric power, is simply too slow, while others say that it is not very portable.

Durability

Potential motor issues. Fisher-Price says the Starlight Papasan Cradle Swing's padding is machine washable, but a few reviewers note that the head cushion is not removable and can get dirty. As with most baby swings, parents say their babies outgrew the swing before reaching the upper weight limit of 25 pounds. Additionally, many feel that their baby lost interest once he or she began sitting up, as the swing doesn't offer an upright seat position. Owners consistently report that the motor stopped working shortly after purchase, and while Fisher-Price sent a replacement for the motor, in some cases owners had to wait for the arrival of a back-ordered part.

Our Sources

1. Baby Bargains

Around the House: Monitors, Diaper Pails, Safety & More, Denise and Alan Fields, 10th Edition, 2013

"Baby Bargains," a comprehensive book by Denise and Alan Fields, reviews baby gear and common baby brands. The authors recommend a handful of swings based on expert testing and parents' reviews, as well as information from manufacturers and retailers. Their website offers up-to-date information, additional reviews, recall information and forums for parents to discuss baby products.

2. Amazon.com

Fisher-Price Cradle 'n Swing, Contributors to Amazon.com, As of May 2014

The Fisher-Price Starlight Papasan Cradle Swing earns 4 out of 5 stars in more than 900 reviews on Amazon.com. Reviewers like the comfy material, easy assembly, AC power option and soothing features. Some reviewers report issues with faulty motors or find there is little difference between swing speeds. Others dislike the lack of a five-point harness.

3. Buzzillions.com

Fisher-Price Papasan Cradle Swing (Starlight), Contributors to Buzzillions.com, As of May 2014

The Fisher-Price Papasan Cradle Swing earns 4.1 out of 5 stars in more than 4,800 reviews on Buzzillions.com. Reviewers agree the swing is comfy and fun for their babies, easy to set up and soothing. However, many find it too bulky, hard to store and noisy. Others say the motor quit after limited use.

4. HomegrownBabies.com

Baby Swing Reviews, Editors of HomegrownBabies.com, Not Dated

In this roundup of a few of the best baby swings, the Fisher-Price Papasan Cradle Swing is named the best choice for parents on a budget. The review highlights the swing's easy assembly, neutral color scheme, lights, different swinging directions and incline for reflux babies. They say it's not the best choice for older babies, though.

5. PopSugar.com

Top Swings, Bouncers and Exersaucers, Editors of PopSugar.com, April 29, 2011

Editors feature quotes from parents they've surveyed who like the Fisher-Price Papasan Cradle Swing for its superior soothing capabilities. The short review neither notes any cons nor compares the swing to others.