Ultimately, to parents, the most important consideration in a baby swing is whether their child likes it -- and admittedly, it's pretty hard to figure that out prior to buying one. Swings generally have three types of movement; the cheapest models generally move backward and forward. So-called cradle swings add a side-to-side movement. The fanciest swings add up-and-down and vibration options. In general, some parents say the basic front-back movement can get boring, which might be why we found better reviews for cradle swings overall. The multi-directional swings also get good reviews, but these swings are expensive.

In addition to full-size floor-model swings, you can also find travel swings, which sit closer to the ground and are light enough to toss in the trunk. We found mixed coverage of portable swings, however. A lot of parents say bouncers are a cheaper and more reliable choice if you need something portable.

The bottom line: Your baby will ultimately decide whether a particular swing is a good buy. Some babies respond better to different features, while other children don't enjoy a lot of bells and whistles. To avoid buyer's remorse, experts recommend borrowing a friend's baby swing or trying one out in a store prior to purchase to see whether your child likes it. Here are some other things to keep in mind when shopping for a baby swing:

  • Look for smooth edges. You want a swing with no sharp edges, no small parts and no hinges or pinch points that are in reach of the baby.
  • Look for baby swings with wide bases to prevent tipping.
  • Decide whether you want a three- or five-point harness. Parents report some problems with three-point harnesses, saying they can allow an active baby to lean over the edge or shift around. The full-size Fisher-Price swings have three-point belts. The Graco Lovin' Hug swing has a five-point belt.
  • A reclining seat can be convenient for a younger infant. Newborns do not have good head control and should lie flat. Most models have an adjustable seat, and a few offer three reclining positions.
  • Removable and washable padding is important for easy cleanup.
  • Plentiful and varied activity trays can provide added entertainment for your baby.
  • Be mindful of musical models. Music can be soothing to a baby but annoying to parents. Look for baby swings with adjustable volume. Additionally, many units offer eight to 12 musical options as well as nature sounds for extra variety.
  • Swings with multiple swing motions (back and forth or side to side) may be preferable if your child likes variety.
  • Look for a baby swing that will fit. Some full-size swings can take up a significant amount of floor space. Additionally, you should make sure that there is room for the swing's base to be fully extended and for the model to move back and forth and, if it's a cradle swing, side to side.
  • Always be near during operation. According to the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, parents shouldn't leave babies unsupervised in a swing. Young babies should be propped up so their heads can't slump over -- a rolled-up towel can do the trick. Safety experts also say you should always use the seat's safety belt to avoid potential accidents or injuries.

Back to top