Baking Chocolate: Reviews

Updated December 2007
The proliferation of gourmet, specialty, and single-source chocolate has let to a lot more choice when it comes to choosing baking chocolate or chips for cookies. Fortunately, we found no shortage of culinary experts weighing in with chocolate taste tests (tough job, huh?). We compared the opinions of pastry chefs, chocolate connoisseurs and home bakers to find the best chocolate brands for cakes, cookies, brownies, candymaking and more.
 

Best baking chocolate overall

Callebaut Intense Dark Chocolate L-60-40NV *Est. $8.75 for 17.5 ounces Learn More

Cook's Illustrated Magazine: Cook's Illustrated staffers sample 12 dark chocolate bars, each of which contains about 60 percent cacao.

Cook's Illustrated Magazine: Though rendered outdated by Cook's Illustrated's most recent test of dark chocolate, this older report, in which 20 editors taste nine chocolate bars raw, in chocolate sauce and baked into a cake, is still of some value.

Gourmet: Lear, a longtime food editor, discusses the Gourmet test kitchen's favorite chocolates.

Best supermarket chocolate

Ghirardelli Bittersweet Chocolate Baking Bar *Est. $3 for 4 ounces Compare Prices

Cook's Illustrated Magazine: Cook's Illustrated staffers sample 12 dark chocolate bars, each of which contain about 60 percent cacao.

Cook's Illustrated Magazine: This older report, in which 20 editors taste nine chocolate bars raw, in chocolate sauce and baked into a cake, is still useful for shoppers.

San Francisco Chronicle: Testers sample 14 widely available dark chocolate bars and taste each one raw.

Chocolate in Context: Emily Stone interviews Elizabeth Falkner, owner of San Francisco restaurant Citizen Cake, about her favorite chocolates.

Best gourmet dark chocolate

Valrhona Manjari *Est. $4 for 2.6 ounces Compare Prices

Los Angeles Times: Six panelists sample 23 chocolate bars with 70-75 percent cacao content.

San Francisco Chronicle: Testers sample 14 widely available dark chocolate bars and taste each one raw.

Cook's Illustrated Magazine: Though rendered outdated by Cook's Illustrated's most recent test of dark chocolate, this older report, in which 20 editors taste nine chocolate bars raw, in chocolate sauce and baked into a cake, is still of some value.

SeriousEats.com: Dorie Greenspan, one of the world's foremost baking experts, provides a brownie recipe and tips.

Food & Wine Magazine: Food & Wine polled 100 chefs on their favorite ingredients and essential tools.

Gourmet: Jane Daniels Lear, a longtime food editor, discusses the Gourmet test kitchen's favorite chocolate.

Seventypercent.com: SeventyPercent.com is an enthusiast website.

Best unsweetened chocolate

Scharffen Berger Unsweetened Pure Dark Chocolate *Est. $9 for 9.7 ounces Compare Prices

Cook's Illustrated Magazine: Unsweetened chocolate is not eaten raw, so editors, with the help of four pastry chefs, bake it into brownies and prepare a chocolate sauce with it for this article.

SeriousEats.com: Dorie Greenspan, one of the world's foremost baking experts, provides a brownie recipe and tips.

NPR: Melody Joy Kramer and a panel of NPR employees conduct a blind test of 30 chocolate brands.

Chocolate in Context: Emily Stone interviews Elizabeth Falkner, owner of San Francisco restaurant Citizen Cake, about her favorite chocolates.

Best chocolate chips

Guittard Classic Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chips *Est. $2.80 for 12 ounces Learn More

Cook's Country: Editors taste nine brands of chocolate chips, which contain less cocoa butter and more sugar than bar chocolate.

Cook's Illustrated Magazine: Twenty-two tasters, including several Boston-area pastry chefs, sampled seven semisweet chocolate chips plain and in chocolate-chip cookies.

SeriousEats.com: Dorie Greenspan, one of the world's foremost baking experts, provides a brownie recipe and tips.

Food & Wine Magazine: Food & Wine polled 100 chefs on their favorite ingredients and essential tools.

Chocolate in Context: Emily Stone interviews Elizabeth Falkner, owner of San Francisco restaurant Citizen Cake, about her favorite chocolates.

Baking Chocolate Runners Up:

Back to top