We haven't updated our report on the best peanut butter in more than two years, so we decided to take another look at what the critics have to say. The top sources we consulted for our report in 2007-- Cook's Illustrated, Food and Wine magazine, ConsumerReports.org and SeriousEats.com -- haven't updated their reviews. But we found a couple of newer peanut butter reviews, among them Cooking Light and Real Simple magazines, Slashfood.com and the enthusiast website PeanutButterBoy.com. None of these sources are overly critical (although Slashfood.com does nominate a worst peanut butter), nor do they discuss testing methodology in detail. Instead, results seem to be based primarily on taste tests, which are highly subjective.
We haven't updated our report on the best peanut butter in more than two years, so we decided to take another look at what the critics have to say. The top sources we consulted for our report in 2007-- Cook's Illustrated, Food and Wine magazine, ConsumerReports.org and SeriousEats.com -- haven't updated their reviews. But we found a couple of newer peanut butter reviews, among them Cooking Light and Real Simple magazines, Slashfood.com and the enthusiast website PeanutButterBoy.com. None of these sources are overly critical (although Slashfood.com does nominate a worst peanut butter), nor do they discuss testing methodology in detail. Instead, results seem to be based primarily on taste tests, which are highly subjective.
Read more