Dermatologists often recommend pairing moisturizing with exfoliation in order to achieve the healthiest and softest skin possible. AmLactin 12% Moisturizing Body Lotion promises to accomplish both processes in one step. Dermatologists in WebMD and Allure articles recommend AmLactin particularly for its exfoliation. In the Allure article, experts recommend AmLactin as an alternative to prescription medications for banishing keratosis pilaris, the tiny red bumps that crop up on many people's legs and thighs. At WebMD, the lotion is recommended as a summer lotion -- a lighter alternative to glycerin and petrolatum-laden formulas that are too heavy for warm weather.
Interestingly, beauty expert Paul Beguon, on her site, Beautypedia.com, specifically states that AmLactin 12% is not an effective exfoliator. She says that the ammonium hydroxide, which neutralizes the pH of the lactic acid, prevents the lactic acid from functioning as an exfoliator. It is important to note, though, that Beguon bases her conclusions on ingredient lists, not necessarily testing.
To clarify matters, we look to real-world use as expressed by the reviewers at Drugstore.com who say that the product does work -- both for softening dry skin and for keratosis pilaris. Users note that the product has an unpleasant smell and is somewhat pricey, but most would recommend it regardless, which is evidence of its effectiveness. Though Beguon's conclusions conflict with those of other dermatologists and users, we are convinced by the corroborating recommendations of our other reviewers: AmLactin 12% Moisturizing Body Lotion makes the ConsumerSearch Best Reviewed list as the Best Exfoliating Lotion.
In this article, dermatologists discuss the need for lightweight moisturizers during the summer months. New York City-based dermatologist David A. Colbert, MD, recommends AmLactin 12% Moistruzing Body Lotion as an exfoliator and moisturizer, specifically for dry legs. He also recommends Cetaphil Moisturizing Lotion, which is less expensive. It's not clear what differentiates the two.
Review: You Asked! Expert A's to Your Beauty Q's About Summer Moisturizers, Liesa Goins, May 2010
Beguon states in this brief review that the 12 percent concentration of lactic acid, an alpha hydroxy acid or AHA, found in AmLactin 12% would be an effective exfoliator, were it not for the ammonium hydroxide, which balances the pH of the product and prevents effective exfoliation. The lotion does soften and moisturize dry skin, but not as effectively as it could if it were a better exfoliator.
Review: AmLactin Moisturizing Lotion, Paula Beguon, June 22, 2011
Editors and dermatologists discuss common skin problems, including keratosis pilaris. These innocuous bumps, which appear on many peoples' arms and thighs, are not acne. The experts recommend applying a lotion such as AmLactin 12% twice daily as an over-the-counter solution, but say that a stronger prescription product like Carmol 10 or Lac-Hydrin may be necessary.
Review: Cellulite, Bacne, Veins, and More: Your Top Embarrassments Solved, Kayleigh Donahue, 2010
With dozens of user reviews on Drugstore.com, AmLactin does remarkably well. Users say the product has effectively alleviated keratosis pilaris, dry and rough skin. Many users say the product smells bad and is somewhat expensive, but neither is enough to keep them from using it. Users recommend applying the product before bed when it has time to absorb and the smell isn't as bothersome.
Review: AmLactin Moisturizing Lotion 12%, Fragrance Free, Contributors to Drugstore.com