
Best call quality
- Best call quality in many areas
- High customer satisfaction
- Fewest dropped calls
- Most phones can't be used in Europe
- Plans are expensive
The most effective way to judge cell phone service is via large-scale surveys that poll users on best network coverage, fewest circuit overloads, least number of dropped calls and most effective customer service. Consumer Reports collects responses from nearly 52,000 subscribers in 23 major cities; J.D. Power and Associates polls about 21,000 users; and PC Magazine receives feedback from more than 20,000 readers. Rounding out our list of reviews is TopTenReviews.com, which compares various cell phone plans according to their features, as well as a list of user reviews on PhoneDog.com, though the individual comments here are more anecdotal than scientific.
Reviewers agree that Verizon Wireless, which works on the works on the CDMA network, has the best call quality and service, particularly in the Northeast, Mid-Atlantic and Western states; Verizon customers say they experience fewer dropped calls and circuit overloads than with other carriers. Be aware that in certain parts of the country -- such as the Southwest -- T-Mobile (*est. $30 per month and up), which works on the GSM network, is rated slightly ahead of Verizon, according to one major survey. Most Verizon handsets don't work in Europe, though you can use Verizon phones in many North and Latin American countries, as well as Japan and China.
Our Sources
J.D. Power and Associates, which polls about 21,000 users, measures customer satisfaction based on service-related measures, grouped into key factors that affect overall wireless-carrier performance. Verizon Wireless wins for call quality in four regions (one tie with Sprint Nextel in the Southwest) and is overwhelmingly best-rated for customer satisfaction nationwide.
Review: Wireless Service Ratings, Editors of J.D. Power and Associates, Oct. 2008
2. ConsumerReports.orgDetails/Subscribe
Consumer Reports polls nearly 52,000 magazine subscribers in 23 metro areas, asking them to rate their cell service for call quality, handling of calls, complaints and billing problems. Results are grouped according to urban areas, including New York City, Dallas, Atlanta, Chicago and Miami.
Review: Best Cell Service, Editors of Consumer Reports, Jan. 2009
Based on responses from more than 20,000 readers, PC Magazine gives its Readers' Choice awards to Verizon Wireless and U.S. Cellular among regular cell phone plans despite the former's high prices and the latter's regional limitations.
Review: The Best (and Worst) Tech Support in America: Cellular Services, Eric Griffith, July 29, 2008
Cell Phone Plans Runners Up:
3 picks including: J.D. Power & Associates, Phonedog.com…
