The Casio G'zOne (pronounced "geez-one") Boulder (*Est. $80 with new contract; $160 with renewal) is a rugged clamshell cell phone built to withstand military tests -- and reviewers abuse it in various ways without wrecking it: freezing, drowning in saltwater and jello, throwing it, dropping it and running it over with a car. Professional reviews are divided, however, on whether it makes good phone calls, and there are plenty of owner reviews that say it doesn't. One owner review on Amazon.com says it's "like you are listening to someone talk from inside a cargo container sunk to the bottom of a lake." The addition of a compass sounds outdoorsy enough. Some reviews mention that function in passing, others say it's practically useless in a GPS era unless it's integrated with a map-inclusive navigation system. In other words, it's sort of like giving people an abacus when they are accustomed to a calculator. Owner reviews also frequently criticize battery life, promised at about 3.5 hours of talk time. InfoSync and CNET got about a half-hour more than promised, and PCMag.com and PhoneArena.com got a bit less than expected.
Reviews say the Casio G'zOne Boulder isn't especially good at anything except for having a tough exterior. One review says the "tiny, slippery keys align at a weird angle to make dialing and typing tough." Another says the 1.3-megapixel camera produces pretty good stills, but video options are "quite limited." One reviewer praises the speedy web browser via the EVDO network, but another says that despite being fast, it's very, very basic. On the plus side, the G'zOne Boulder has a microSD memory card slot (up to 8 GB) for music storage, support for instant messaging and email, Bluetooth, plus a 2-inch internal screen with pretty good (320 pixel by 240 pixel) resolution. InfoSync has a rankings list of rugged cell phones, with the Casio G'zOne Boulder rating fifth. The Motorola Adventure V750 (Discontinued) and Samsung Rugby (Discontinued) tie for the highest score there. If you don't need an especially rugged phone, PCMag.com's Sascha Segan recommends the LG Chocolate (Discontinued) or LG VX8350 for better call quality. The Motorola Adventure is also thought to have better call quality by some reviewers.
There's no shortage of credible, thorough reviews of the Casio G'zOne Boulder. InfoSync, CNET, PCMag.com, MobileBurn.com and DigitalTrends.com all offer complete coverage. ConsumerReports.org doesn't cover the Casio G'zOne Boulder. We also found helpful criticism in owner reviews at CNET, Amazon.com and PhoneDog.com.
|
Motorola Adventure V750 Phone, Silver/Black (Verizon Wireless)
Average Customer Review: |
||
|
|
|
Samsung Rugby a837 Phone, Black (AT&T)
Average Customer Review: |
||
|
|
Our Sources
This review is credible and thorough, ranking the Casio G'zOne as "good" overall and rating a slew of features. But what makes this coverage so helpful is the ratings chart of nine rugged cell phones in which the Boulder ranks smack in the middle (at this writing).
Review: G'zOne Boulder review (Verizon Wireless), Philip Berne, Aug. 25, 2008
2. CNET
CNET's Nicole Lee scores the Casio G'zOne Boulder "very good" despite disappointing call quality. She tests durability by dunking it in water and repeatedly throwing it against a wall. About 60 owner reviews combine for a mediocre average score, with most complaints concerning sound quality and battery life. The review is accompanied by a video in which Lee demonstrates the phone's durability.
Review: Verizon G'zOne Boulder (Black & Silver), Nicole Lee, Aug. 11, 2008
3. PCMag.com
Reviewer Sascha Segan rates the Casio G'zOne Boulder as "good" and calls it "indestructible" but disses the call quality and battery life (tested at 197 minutes of talk time). Segan threw the Boulder at a wall and froze it in a dish of slush without killing it.
Review: Verizon G'zOne Boulder Review, Sascha Segan, Aug. 14, 2008
Reviewer Ricky Cadden disagrees with the knocks about battery life, although it doesn't appear talk time is tested (he "easily" got two days of standby time). Ultimately, he says the limited web browser, confusing menus and poor speakerphone merit nothing higher than a Recommended designation.
Review: Casio G'zOne Boulder Review -- CComplete With Jello bath, Ricky Cadden, Aug. 29, 2008
Reviewer Nick Mokey gives the Boulder a seven out of 10 and says it passed physical-abuse tests, including a full day of surfing (in the ocean, not the web). But the compass is "useless" in a GPS/maps age, and aside from ruggedness, there's no reason to buy one.
Review: Casio G'zOne Boulder, Nick Mokey, Nov. 5, 2008
While this review says the Boulder is rugged enough even after being run over by a car, "unfortunately it's not very good at anything else." The review says battery talk time is rated at 3.5 hours, but "we just barely managed to get three hours in multiple tests."
Review: Casio G'zOne Boulder Review, PhoneArena Team, Aug. 22, 2008
7. Amazon.com
About 20 owner reviews combine to give the Casio G'zOne Boulder a mediocre average score. Most complaints concern sound quality, which sounds "like you are listening to someone talk from inside a cargo container sunk to the bottom of a lake."
Review: Casio G'zOne Boulder Phone, Black/Silver (Verizon Wireless), Contributors to Amazon.com
|
Sponsored Links are keyword-targeted advertisements provided through the Google AdWords™ program. These listings are administered, sorted and maintained by Google. For information about these Google ads, go to adwords.google.com. Google may place or recognize a unique "cookie" on your Web browser. Information from this cookie may be used by Google to help provide advertisers with more targeted advertising opportunities. For more information about Google's privacy policy, including how to opt out, go to www.google.com/ads/preferences. By clicking on Sponsored Links you will leave ConsumerSearch.com. The web site you will go to is not endorsed by ConsumerSearch. |