Page: 6 of 6
Computer Speakers: Ratings of Sources
Total of 18 Sources
1. PCMag.com
As of June 2009
Computer Speakers
by Editors of PCMag.com
Our Assessment

Most of the reviews at PCMag.com are detailed, though some older ones are be disappointingly short. Ratings make it easier to compare speakers, and reviewers give useful pros, cons and bottom-line assessments. Editor's Choice awards go to Hercules XPS 2.1 Lounge speakers for their value and to the Razer Mako for clear sound across all ranges. The oddly shaped Harman/Kardon SoundSticks II also gets a perfect score for strong highs and bass.

expand

collapse

2. GoodGearGuide.com
As of June 2009
PC Speakers
by Editors of GoodGearGuide.com
Our Assessment

Australia's GoodGearGuide.com covers 18 speakers that are available in the U.S. There are no Editor's Choice awards, but there are ratings, a pros-and-cons list and a summary assessment. Axiom's Audiobyte is praised for clarity and detail, though the subwoofer (at an additional cost) is "tight rather than booming." The Creative GigaWorks T40 provides clear sound for a reasonable price. The Logitech LS21s are a real bargain, if you have a small room and don't mind losing low bass ranges.

expand

collapse

3. CNET
June 2, 2009
Best Computer Speakers
by Editors of CNET
Our Assessment

CNET lists its top choices in PC speakers on this page. All get a rating and are compared to similar models. The Logitech Z-2300 gets top billing for its stellar sound quality at a great price. The Harman Kardon SoundSticks II and M-Audio Studiophile AV 40 also score well, both delivering clear sound, though the AV 40s are large and a little pricey. Additional single-product reviews can be found elsewhere on the site.

expand

collapse

4. MaximumPC.com
As of June 2009
Speakers
by Editors of Maximum PC magazine
Our Assessment

This high-adrenaline and often irreverent computer magazine periodically publishes single-product reviews. Ratings, along with pluses and minuses, make it possible to compare systems. Three speaker systems are graced with Maximum PC magazine's "Kick Ass" award. The Logitech Z-5500 gets a perfect score for powerful, clear sound in all ranges. Axiom Audio's Audiobyte is praised for the detail it gives, and the reviewer is impressed with the Focal XS system for its detailed sound and subtle bass.

expand

collapse

5. Choice magazine
May 2008
PC Speakers
by Editors of Choice magazine
Our Assessment

This Australian consumer magazine tests products extensively, somewhat like the U.S.-based ConsumerReports.org. Sixteen speakers are reviewed, though only nine are available in the United States. Each model gets a profile, which includes both good and bad points. Editors are impressed with the Harman-Kardon SoundSticks II system for a powerful, natural sound with good definition. Altec Lansing's VS4121 is a good value for games and movies, though music performance doesn't fare so well.

expand

collapse

6. DigitalTrends.com
As of June 2009
PC Speaker System Reviews
by Editors of DigitalTrends.com
Our Assessment

Not all PC speakers on this site have actually been reviewed by editors, but those that have receive detailed coverage with a rating (including Editors' Choice awards), highs and lows and overall assessment. Newer models include video reviews as well. A large number of older, long discontinued speakers remain listed, which bogs down navigation somewhat. Among current speakers, the Logitech Z-4 and Logitech G51 are both great values with clear sound, though bass suffers somewhat on these lower-priced models. Logitech's Z-5500, however, delivers near-perfect sound quality even after a year of daily use.

expand

collapse

7. Which? magazine
As of June 2009
Computer Speakers
by Editors of Which? magazine
Our Assessment

This British consumer magazine conducts product testing similar to ConsumerReports.org in the U.S. Of the 16 speakers reviewed here, only six are available on this side of the pond. Reviews are short, though it's clear the magazine uses a listening panel to come to its conclusions. The Logitech Z-5500 PC speakers get a Best Buy award for being well balanced and detailed, though testers heard distortion in the high ranges.

expand

collapse

8. Techtree.com
As of June 2009
Speakers: Reviews
by Frazier Barretto
Our Assessment

This Indian website provides a rating, pros and cons for each speaker system, as well as some comparisons to competitors, though not all are sold in the U.S. Reviewer Frazier Barretto rates the Cyber Acoustics CA3090 highly for being a good budget choice, and the Altec Lansing VS2421 is also an excellent value. He grudgingly admits the expensive Bose Companion 5 system delivers quality sound across all ranges.

expand

collapse

9. Techgage.com
As of June 2009
Latest Speakers/Headphones Articles
by Editors of Techgage.com
Our Assessment

Although Techgage.com doesn't test as many PC speakers as some other sites, the reviews are detailed, including information about the testing process. Ratings are provided with a pros and cons list, but there's no easy way to compare them. Two models receive an Editor's Choice award. Reviewer Jen McPherson gushes over the sound quality of the affordable Logitech Z-4, while Rory Buszka is equally blown away by the Razer Mako, though he admits it's expensive.

expand

collapse

10. Tech2.in.com
Feb. 28, 2009
Top Three 2.0 PC speakers
by Siddharth Bhatia
Our Assessment

This India-based site features individual reviews as well as a number of roundups. In this article, Siddharth Bhatia examines the Creative GigaWorks T40 Series II, the Logitech Z-10 (now discontinued) and the Audioengine 2, which he prefers for its natural, open sound. Elsewhere on the site, the Bose Computer MusicMonitor is honored as the best speakers of 2008. Logitech's AudioHub is the runner up for that award, while Altec Lansing's VS2521 is named as best value.

expand

collapse

11. Pocket-lint.com
As of June 2009
Speakers Reviews
by Editors of Pocket-lint.com
Our Assessment

Reviews at this U.K.-base website include a rating, pros and cons and a verdict, but aren't very detailed and no comparisons are made. Additionally, not all of the speakers covered are available in the U.S. The site's Hot Product awards go to three computer speaker systems. Creative GigaWorks T40 is praised for reaching high volume levels with no distortion. Creative's Inspire T10 gives excellent detail while the expensive Creative GigaWorks T3 system gives a nice balance across all ranges.

expand

collapse

12. PC World India
Dec. 11, 2008
Some Sound Advice
by Laldinfela Pachuau
Our Assessment

India's version of PC World tests the Altec Lansing VS2521, Creative Inspire T3100 and Logitech X-240 at their labs to see which 2.1 speaker system is the best. They're most impressed by the VS2521 from Altec Lansing, which has strong bass response. Mids and highs fare well too, though Laldinfela Pachuau feels sound can be too bright at times. Creative's Inspire T3100 comes close, but the VS2521 has a better soundstage.

expand

collapse

13. About.com
As of June 2009
Speakers and Headphones
by Mark Casey
Our Assessment

Though reviews are on the short side, a number of popular computer speaker systems are covered here. Each gets a rating, pros and cons list and assessment of features and performance. The Logitech Z-5500 PC speaker system gets the highest rating for premium sound quality and true surround sound, though reviewer Mark Casey warns it's expensive. (Note: ConsumerSearch is owned by About.com, but the two don't share an editorial affiliation.)

expand

collapse

14. Amazon.com
As of June 2009
Computer Speakers
by Contributors to Amazon.com
Our Assessment

Amazon.com lets users post reviews of computer speakers that they own. Some speakers get hundreds of reviews, and it's easy to spot top choices. Many score similarly, though, so separating out the very best can be challenging. On the other hand, losers tend to stick out like a sore thumb. User-review sites like Amazon.com are particularly useful in identifying cheap computer speakers that perform well, which aren't always covered in professional reviews.

expand

collapse

15. NewEgg.com
As of June 2009
Speakers
by Contributors to Newegg.com
Our Assessment Newegg.com is another retailer site that allows owners to write reviews. Posters here tend to have more technical savvy than at Amazon.com because the site caters to computer and electronics enthusiasts. In addition, reviewers are required to include information on their level of technical knowledge and how long they've owned/used a product. There are fewer models reviewed here, though.
16. PC World
As of June 2009
Reviews
by Editors of PC World
Our Assessment Finding PC speaker reviews at PC World can be a challenge, and one that's not always worth pursuing. Coverage isn't great, and some is borrowed from sister sites and publications, but each reviewed product gets a rating, pros and cons lists and a detailed assessment. The Logitech Z-5500 scores highly for features and clear, detailed sound, though bass response can be heavy at times.
17. TheTechLounge.com
As of June 2009
Speakers
by Editors of TheTechLoung.com
Our Assessment

Unfortunately, this technology site doesn't give ratings, though some are marked Editor's Choice or Recommended. This isn't obvious from the listings, however, making it impossible to compare products without pulling up each review. Still, each PC speaker system undergoes hands-on testing and pros and cons are noted. The Audioengine 2 (A2) gets an Editor's Choice award for quality sound, though scratching is reported at high volumes. The site also recommends the Logitech X-540, which delivers great sound for a reasonable price.

expand

collapse

18. TomsGuide.com
May 3, 2009
Stereo PC Speakers, Compared
by Editors of TomsGuide.com
Our Assessment

This article is reprinted from the French site DigitalVersus.com. It's supposed to compare the Creative GigaWorks T20 Series II, Creative GigaWorks T40 Series II and Logitech Z-5, but the reviewer really only compares the T20 and T40. The T20 and Z-5 receive the same rating and which is preferred is never made clear. The T20 is praised for strong bass, though mids and highs leave much to be desired. Logitech's Z-5 gives genuine omnidirectional sound with a small footprint, but bass response is weak.

expand

collapse

Back to top