Convertibles: Reviews

Updated February 2011
While convertibles excel at proviging summer driving fun, there's really no reason to park them for the winter, either. Current soft tops are well-insulated, not to mention space efficient, and the mainstreaming of the retractable hard top means that cars so equipped are as buttoned up during winter as any fixed-roof counterpart. We rate the best convertibles based on an analysis of expert reviews.
 

Best premium four-seat convertible

2011 BMW 3 Series Convertible Base MSRP: $45,500 to $58,700 Learn More

Edmunds.com: The addition of the twin-turbocharged BMW 335is for 2011 brings a sportier and more powerful range-topping BMW 3 Series convertible.

FuelEconomy.gov: Interestingly, the new single turbo engine in the BMW 335i convertible delivers substantially more power than the base 328i but is also more fuel efficient.

Insurance Institute for Highway Safety: The 2010 model year receives high marks in the frontal-offset crash test but receives slightly lower ratings for side and rear impacts.

ConsumerSearch.com: Because the current model is largely a carryover, our comprehensive report on the 2009 BMW 3 Series convertible is still the best source for detailed information on this BMW convertible.

Best premium roadster

2011 Porsche Boxster Base MSRP: $47,600 to $61,200 Learn More

AOL Autos: AOL Autos provides a brief overview of the 2011 Boxster, covering the model-year changes as well as providing prices, fuel-economy info and useful specs.

Jalopnik.com: Sam Smith falls in love with the Boxster Spyder, saying the concessions it makes in the name of weight savings and improved performance pay off.

MotorMouths.com: An invaluable review resource, MotorMouths.com editors read and score reviews for just about every car from every imaginable publication and website.

FuelEconomy.gov: No matter which Porsche Boxster model you select, expect to see 17 to 19 mpg in city driving, and 26 to 29 mpg on the highway -- admirable numbers for a sports car.

ConsumerSearch.com: With the exception of the addition of the new Boxster Spyder, the 2011 Porsche Boxster differs very little from the 2009 version, so this comprehensive analysis remains valid.

Bargain four-seat convertible

2011 Ford Mustang Convertible Base MSRP: $27,145 to $37,845 Learn More

ConsumerReports.org: ConsumerReports.org purchases and reviews the 2011 Ford Mustang V6 coupe with the manual transmission.

ConsumerReports.org: This press release from ConsumerReports.org summarizes their findings in a comparison between the 2011 Ford Mustang and the 2011 Chevrolet Camaro.

FuelEconomy.gov: Fuel economy for the Mustang convertible with the base V6 engine is an EPA estimated 19 mpg city/30 mpg highway/23 mpg combined with the automatic.

SaferCar.gov: The most recently tested version of the 2010 Mustang convertible, which is structurally the same as the 2011 model, receives the highest 5-star rating for driver and passenger protection in frontal impacts and for side impacts for rear passengers.

Insurance Institute for Highway Safety: The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety gives the 2011 Mustang convertible the highest possible rating of "Good" for frontal-, side- and rear-impact protection following an independent battery of tests.

Car and Driver: Car and Driver finds the Mustang GT convertible at odds with itself, with this particular trim being geared toward performance while the convertible body style adds a little weight and compromises handling to some extent.

Edmunds.com: This Edmunds.com review of the 2011 Ford Mustang covers the entire range including coupe and convertible.

InsideLine.com: The most powerful version of the Ford Mustang, the GT with the 5-liter V8, is tested here in coupe form.

InsideLine.com: In this initial drive of the 2011 Mustang V6, the reviewer comes away impressed, citing that "the recipe remains the same, but the ingredients have just gotten a whole lot better." The Mustang's new V6 engine is praised for being quick but not necessarily blazingly fast.

Autoblog.com: In one of the few reviews that specifically covers the new Mustang convertible, writer Dan Roth praises the 2011 Ford Mustang GT convertible, calling it "no parade float." The design is described as "fully realized" except for the lack of manual-shift options on the test car's automatic transmission.

Automobile Magazine: A collection of four short-take opinions, this article gives a few different perspectives, though all view the Mustang in a positive light.

Motor Trend: Certainly an uncommon comparison, the 2011 Mustang GT coupe is compared against the far more expensive BMW M3.

Motor Trend: Pitting the 2011 Ford Mustang V6 coupe against its closest competitors, the Mustang comes in second behind the Hyundai Genesis.

Motor Trend: The coupe version of the 2011 Mustang GT with the V8 engine is tested here against V8 coupe competitors, and the Mustang is declared the winner.

Motor Trend: The subtitle of this article poses the question "Could've had a V-8, but why?," and comes away with the impression that the 2011 Ford Mustang's new V6 is the best of all worlds, offering decent power and good fuel economy.

Motor Trend: Ron Kiino tests the GT coupe version of the Mustang, loving the new V8 and revised six-speed transmission combination.

New York Times: The Mustang convertible, in V6 trim here, is complimented on its thoroughly modern engine that delivers good fuel economy when driven lightly but is also powerful when driven hard.

MotorWeek.com: This article covers all variants of the 2011 Mustang.

MSNBC: Similar to other reviews, the author here praises the modern powertrains for delivering good performance and impressive fuel economy.

Road & Track: Road & Track magazine samples the Mustang GT convertible, and like other sources, is smitten with the increase in power and efficiency of the new V8 engine.

Road & Track: The conclusion here is that you'll "hardly miss the V-8's extra cylinders" because of the V-6's new-found power.

Best roadster value

2011 Mazda MX-5 Miata Base MSRP: $23,110 to $28,550 Learn More

Edmunds.com: Edmunds.com provides a good overview of the 2011 Mazda Miata, noting that the small convertible is carried over completely unchanged from the 2010 model year.

FuelEconomy.gov: Fun and frugality live harmoniously in the 2011 Mazda MX-5 Miata.

ConsumerSearch.com: The 2011 Mazda MX-5 is one of the best-reviewed convertibles overall, just as its 2009 counterpart was.

Convertibles Runners Up:

2011 Mini Cooper Convertible Base MSRP: $24,850 to $34,300

8 picks including: FuelEconomy.gov, Edmunds.com…

2011 Volvo C70 Base MSRP: $39,950

5 picks including: FuelEconomy.gov, Car and Driver…

2011 Volkswagen Eos Base MSRP: $32,940 to $36,100

4 picks including: FuelEconomy.gov, Car and Driver…

2011 Chevrolet Corvette Convertible Base MSRP: $53,600 to $58,600

4 picks including: FuelEconomy.gov, Edmunds.com…

2011 BMW Z4 Base MSRP: $46,500 to $61,550

4 picks including: FuelEconomy.gov, Edmunds.com…

2011 Audi A5 Cabriolet Base MSRP: $42,450 to $44,650

3 picks including: FuelEconomy.gov, Edmunds.com…

Back to top