Page: 6 of 6
Cooktops: Ratings of Sources
Total of 16 Sources
1. ConsumerReports.org
Nov. 2008
Cooktops and Wall Ovens
by Editors of ConsumerReports.org
Our Assessment

In this roundup, ConsumerReports.org tests almost three dozen gas and electric cooktops, including nine induction cooktops. Cooktops are rated on how well they melt, simmer and boil. Owner surveys indicate that some high-end cooktops are more repair-prone than less expensive models. Editors say induction cooktops outperform regular cooktops, but at double the price (or more). A discussion of the technology is included, along with ratings and recommendations. There is also a section on how to choose between gas, electric and induction cooktops.

expand

collapse

2. ConsumerReports.org
May 2006
Induction Cooktops are Promising, but Not Perfect
by Editors of ConsumerReports.org
Our Assessment

This article discusses induction cooktops and how they work. Induction cooktops are faster than both gas and electric cooktops. They also shut off automatically when the pan is removed, thereby reducing the chance of house fires. Overall, editors say induction cooktops are impressive but expensive. The editors suggest waiting for their reliability to be proven. This article is dated, but the general information is still useful.

expand

collapse

3. Sears.com
As of July 2009
Gas and Electric Cooktops
by Contributors to Sears.com
Our Assessment

Sears.com is one of the few websites we found with a decent number of consumer reviews of cooktops. The retailer carries more than 400 models on its website. Many models, however, have just one review, and the reviews themselves are often very brief. There just isn't enough review volume here to tell which cooktops are highest rated overall, but Sears is an excellent place to crosscheck picks at ConsumerReports.org.

expand

collapse

4. Buzzillions.com
As of July 2009
Cooktop Reviews
by Contributors to Buzzillions.com
Our Assessment Buzzillions.com is an online review site that compiles ratings from several online retailers. Product owners can also post reviews directly to Buzzillions.com. Because owner reviews for cooktops are generally scarce, the compiled reviews here make it easier to get an idea of which cooktops owners seem to like best.
5. Choice magazine
March 2009
Gas Cooktops
by Editors of Choice magazine
Our Assessment Choice magazine is the Australian equivalent to Consumer Reports. Their testing methods are nearly as rigorous, although they don't test as many models. This report covers 10 gas cooktops in a wide range of prices, and while the testing is extremely useful for Australian consumers, none of the tested models are available in the U.S.
6. Choice magazine
Feb. 2008
Ceramic Cooktops
by Editors of Choice magazine
Our Assessment A separate report from Choice magazine covers a dozen different ceramic (smoothtop electric) cooktops in a range of prices. While the testing is rigorous and the notes on each model are detailed, none of the cooktops are sold in the U.S.
2008 Kitchen Appliances Study: Built-In Cooktops and Ovens
by Editors of J.D. Power and Associates
Our Assessment

Almost 15,000 consumers participated in a survey about kitchen appliances. Brands (but not individual models) are rated in six categories: style and feel, performance, price, features, ease of use and warranty. LG won in overall satisfaction, with KitchenAid, Kenmore Elite, Frigidaire and Jenn-Air following in the rankings. Although the ratings are interesting, there's no distinction between built-in ovens or cooktops, making this survey less helpful than it could be.

expand

collapse

8. Consumer magazine
March 2008
Ceramic (Electric Smoothtop) Cooktops
by Editors of Consumer magazine
Our Assessment

This New Zealand publication scrutinizes seven models of electric smoothtop cooktops for use/cleaning, durability, quality of controls, and cooking factors such as simmering, high heat and "turn down" ability. Fisher & Paykel and Bosch are the two top-performing brands. As with Choice magazine, this test is really only helpful for New Zealand readers, but some of the general information is applicable to U.S. readers.

expand

collapse

9. CNNMoney.com
June 9, 2008
The Ultimate Kitchen Upgrade
by Sally Schultheiss
Our Assessment This buyer's guide to induction cooktops covers all the bases -- except for testing and rating cooktops. Sally Schultheiss delves into the history and technology of induction cooking, and includes information on costs, installation and adjustments you'll need to make to incorporate this technology into your kitchen.
10. AJMadison.com
As of July 2009
Cooktops: Customer Ratings and Reviews
by Contributors to AJMadison.com
Our Assessment

This appliance retail site features a limited number of consumer reviews of the cooktops sold here. Of the few gas cooktops that have received user ratings, most are limited to just one or two comments. The reviews are even sparser for electric cooktops, but two coil-burner Frigidaire cooktops receive the best ratings. About 15 induction cooktops are rated; a few have two or three reviews each, and the rest have one review. Without more feedback on models, it's hard to draw conclusions from the limited reviews here, but AJMadison.com is worth a look.

expand

collapse

11. ConsumerGuide.com
As of July 2009
Cooktops
by Editors of ConsumerGuide.com
Our Assessment ConsumerGuide.com lists many cooktops, giving some of them a Best Buy rating. However, reviews describe features with no evidence of testing. Three gas cooktops and three electric cooktops get "spotlight reviews," but without any testing, this doesn't inspire much confidence in ConsumerGuide.com's picks.
12. Dulley.com
Not Dated
New Easy-to-Clean Electric Cooktops Cook Like Gas and Are Safe
by James Dulley
Our Assessment James Dulley is a mechanical engineer and nationally syndicated newspaper columnist. He has hundreds of home-related bulletins on his website, including this article on electric cooktops. No product testing is done, nor are ratings given, but the report does provide some general information on induction cooking, as well as limited model specifications from 15 cooktop manufacturers.
13. 3Luxe.com
Not Dated
Cooktops
by Editors of 3LUXE.com
Our Assessment 3LUXE.com's motto is "Simply find the best of everything." In this article, the editors have chosen their top three picks for the best cooktops: Thermador, Viking and Gaggenau, respectively. Two of three are induction cooktops. Each cooktop's features are detailed, but there is no explanation as to how the reviewers chose these models as their top picks, or if any testing was performed.
14. Epinions.com
As of July 2009
Kitchen Cooktops
by Contributors to Epinions.com
Our Assessment If you're looking for a review of a specific model, Epinions.com is worth a try, although cooktops don't receive as many owner-written ratings as ranges or ovens. This site is worthwhile to check once you've narrowed down your choices.
15. The Induction Site
As of July 2009
Induction Cooking
by Editors of TheInductionSite.com
Our Assessment

This site is for enthusiasts of induction cooking. There is a lot of information about how induction cooktops work, as well as installation suggestions and the pros and cons of induction cooktops. There is also a large database of brands and models, along with detailed information about each model. While there are no reviews or recommendations, this site is helpful. It even offers information about the types of cookware needed for induction cooking. Though the site does sell cooktops, the sales push isn't over the top.

expand

collapse

16. ConsumerDemocracy.com
As of July 2009
Cooktops
by Contributors to ConsumerDemocracy.com
Our Assessment Similar to the forum offered by Epinions.com, owners of cooktops offer reviews on this site. Unfortunately, most reviews are only a line or two, and the model numbers are not listed. The reviews cover a wide variety of brands, but there seems to be no clear favorite, and you must register for the site to view negative reviews.

Back to top