Makita BDF451 LXT

*Est. $300
Reviewed
November 2010
Email
Makita LXT BDF451

Pros
  • Professional quality
  • Three speeds
  • Efficient four-pole motor
  • Lithium-ion batteries with long runtime
Cons
  • Speed switch can get stuck in the middle position
  • Heavier than compact Li-ion drills

Reviewers give top ranking to the Makita BDF451 18-volt LXT drill/driver for professional use. It has three speeds for excellent control, and testers praise the efficient four-pole motor and overall comfort and balance. The entire Makita LXT series of 18-volt lithium-ion (Li-ion) tools gets good reviews, so it's also a good choice if you want to assemble a larger array of tools that include a cordless circular saw. The full-size 3.0-amp-hour batteries provide a runtime twice as long as that of the compact Makita BDF452HW (*Est. $185). However, the less expensive Makita weighs about a pound less and reviewers recommend it for most homeowner construction tasks.

ConsumerReports.org tested the Makita BDF451 LXT in 2007, and the publication's 2010 report compares it with 54 other cordless drills. Makita as a brand is also included in two surveys: the 2010 customer survey conducted by J.D. Power and Associates, and a 2007 survey of builders at Builders Online. More recent comparison tests at Fine Homebuilding and at Popular Mechanics cover the similar hammer drill in the LXT series, the Makita BHP454 (*Est. $280). A Tools of the Trade review in 2007 compares the Makita BDF451 LXT with the full range of Li-ion cordless tools available at the time, including 13 other drills, but with less detail about the testing process. A 2006 blog review at The Power Tool Geek evaluates cordless drills for ergonomics. We found the best owner-written reviews of the Makita BDF451 LXT at NorthernTool.com and Amazon.com. Earlier reviews at the Journal of Light Construction test the hammer drill version.

     
   
 
 
 
Where To Buy
 
 
Makita BDF451 18-Volt LXT Lithium-Ion Cordless 1/2-Inch Driver-Drill Kit

 (18 reviews)
Buy new: $538.00 $280.09   19 Used & new from $224.54

In Stock. Eligible for FREE Super Saver Shipping

 
 
 
 
 
Featured StoresStore RatingNotesTotal Price
GraingerGrainger has not yet been reviewed0 store reviewsIn Stock. $112.00
eBayeBay rated 3.89 (1219 reviews)1,219 store reviewsIn Stock. Earn 2% eBay Bucks on qualifying purchases! Backed by eBay Buyer Protection Program. Terms and Conditions apply.$89.99
 
 
 

Our Sources

1. ConsumerReports.org

This review at ConsumerReports.org compares the Makita BDF451 LXT Li-ion cordless drill with 54 other models, including 16 that are judged similar in power. Ratings are at least partly on earlier tests published in December 2007. All the drills are ranked based on objective tests of speed, power, battery life and other factors.

Review: Cordless Drill Ratings, May 2010

2. J.D. Power and Associates

Makita maintains its ranking as fifth in this third annual J.D. Power and Associates' customer-satisfaction survey of 13 cordless drill brands, earning a 5-star "among the best" rating and ranked well above the industry average. The rankings are based on six factors, with drill performance most important, followed by ease of use, battery performance, price, versatility of battery system and warranty.

Review: 2010 Cordless Drill/Driver Satisfaction Study, Editors of J.D. Power and Associates, June 2, 2010

3. BuilderOnline.org

This 2007 survey of over 3,400 builders and contractors places Makita in the middle of the pack, ranked eighth out of 15 brands that make cordless drills.

Review: 2008 Builder Brand Study, Hanley Wood, 2008

4. Fine Homebuilding

The corresponding hammerdrill in the 18-volt LXT series, the Makita BHP454, gets mixed reviews for speed and power in this review comparing seven cordless hammerdrills. The three experienced tool reviewers like some of the conveniences shared by the BDF451 -- the light, belt hook and overall comfort -- but note that the mode selector often sticks, and the chuck on one unit was off center.

Review: Tool Test: 18v Li-Ion Hammer Drills, Justin Fink, Andy Beasley and Kit Camp, Nov. 2009

5. PopularMechanics.com

The corresponding Makita LXT hammer drill, the BHP454, earns top ranking at Popular Mechanics in comparison tests of 10 full-powered Li-ion cordless drills. Testers find the Makita motor and drivetrain superior, and praise the drill's balance and comfortable handle.

Review: Cordless Drill Reviews: We Work 10 Drills to the Limit, Roy Berendsohn, Dec. 2008

6. Tools of the Trade

This Tools of the Trade review doesn't rank or rate the Li-ion cordless tools reviewed here, but the brief summaries of each model make it easy to tell which ones perform best with the most comfort, and any drawbacks are noted. The Makita BDF451 gets one of the best reviews here, praised for its compact size and good balance.

Review: Lithium-Ion Hands On, Rick Schwolsky and Michael Springer, Jan. 17, 2007

7. The Power Tool Geek

This informal comparison review at The Power Tool Geek covers cordless drills with good ergonomics for those with smaller hands and less upper-body strength. Based on informal field tests, three female employees agreed unanimously that the most comfortable cordless drills are the Hitachi DS14DVF3 14.4-volt and the lithium-powered Makita BDF451 18-volt.

Review: Buying Advice - Cordless Drills for Women, Brian Mark, Feb. 20, 2006

8. Northerntool.com

Retailer site NorthernTool.com is a good place to see user ratings and reviews of pro-level cordless drills and impact drivers. At the time of our report, over a dozen owners give the Makita BDF451 a near-perfect 5-star rating here, but a few durability problems have cropped up.

Review: Untitled, Contributors to NorthernTool.com

9. Amazon.com

At the time of this report, about a dozen owners review the Makita LXT BDF451 at Amazon.com. Most are pleased with it, reporting that it performs well and is very comfortable to use. In some cases, though, the speed switch doesn't move easily, sticking in the middle position.

Review: Makita BDF451 LXT 18-Volt Lithium-Ion Driver-Drill Kit, Contributors to Amazon.com

10. Tools of the Trade

This Tools of the Trade review tests and compares 15 half-inch cordless drill/drivers, mostly 18-volt models, including the Makita BHP451 LXT -- the Makita LXT hammer drill that's mechanically similar to the Makita BDF451 LXT driver-drill. In addition to objective tests of both drilling and driving, testers use the cordless drills at actual jobsites, installing millwork.

Review: Cordless Drill/Drivers, Brent Hull, March 2007

11. Journal of Light Construction

This review at the Journal of Light Construction also covers the hammer drill in the same Makita LXT pro series as the Makita BDF451 drill/driver, as part of a comparison review of five Li-ion cordless tool kits. The Makita gets top ranking for ergonomics.

Review: Lithium-Ion Cordless Kits, Andy Beasley, April 2007

Cordless Drills Runners Up:

Milwaukee M18 2601-22 *Est. $180

6 picks by top review sites.

Bosch Impactor PS40-2A *Est. $140

3 picks by top review sites.

Milwaukee 2602-22 *Est. $250

3 picks by top review sites.

Ridgid R86007 *Est. $200

3 picks by top review sites.

Panasonic EY7540LN2L *Est. $310

2 picks including: Amazon.com, Tools of the Trade…

Panasonic EY7202GQW *Est. $290

2 picks by top review sites.

Hitachi DS10DFL *Est. $90

2 picks by top review sites.

Ryobi HJP002K *Est. $70

2 picks including: HomeDepot.com, Woodworker's Journal…

     
 
image
Milwaukee 2601-22 18-Volt Li-ion Compact Drill Kit
In Stock.
Average Customer Review:  
 
 
 
 
     
 
image
Bosch PS40-2A 12-Volt Max Lithium-Ion Impact Driver
In Stock.
Average Customer Review:  
 
 
 
 
     
   
 
 
 
     
 
image
Ridgid R86007 18V Compact Lithium Ion Drill
In Stock.
Average Customer Review:  
 
 
 
 
     
   
 
 
 
     
   
 
 
 
     
 
image
Hitachi DS10DFL 12-Volt Peak Li-Ion 2-Speed Drill/Driver
In Stock.
Average Customer Review:  
 
 
 
 

Back to top