See All Deep Fryers

Presto 05442 CoolDaddy Cool-touch Deep Fryer Review

Est. $40
Reviewed
November 2014
by ConsumerSearch

Best deep fryer

Pros
  • Cool-touch exterior
  • Basket lowers with lid closed
  • Intuitive controls
  • Reliable temperature indicator
Cons
  • Not suitable for large quantities

Bottom line

Ideal for about two servings, the Presto 05442 CoolDaddy Cool-touch Deep Fryer packs a big punch in a small footprint. Praised for its rapid heat-up and recovery times, the Presto 05442 also boasts built-in safety features to prevent grease splatters, including an external, basket-lowering handle. A charcoal filter for reducing odors, a nonstick removable pot, and simple knob controls also add convenience.

Breaking it down

Performance

Versatile settings. The 1,600 watt Presto CoolDaddy 05442 Cool-touch Deep Fryer's adjustable temperature settings range from 250 to 375 degrees Fahrenheit, and most owners say it quickly reaches the temperature it's set for and then returns quickly to that temperature after foods are added. A few disagree, noting that it takes too long to heat up (Presto says the unit requires a 12-minute preheat) or it simply never gets hot enough for really crispy fried results. Although the CoolDaddy claims a six-cup capacity, most reviewers say it really only makes enough for about two people, unless you're okay with fairly small serving sizes. Many note that it's important to read the instruction manual for best results as it has a guide to preparing food for frying and how long to immerse the food.

Ease of use

Simple functionality; easy cleaning. Reviewer say the Presto CoolDaddy 05442 Cool-touch Deep Fryer is simple to operate thanks to the adjustable temperature control knob. A large viewing window allows you to monitor foods as they cook. The nonstick bowl removes for easy cleaning, but is not dishwasher-safe. Owners love the convenient indicator light that signals when the oil reaches the desired temperature. A few users advise paying close attention to the max fill line to avoid overflows. The lid of the Presto 05442 has an exterior handle for lowering the basket with the lid closed to prevent messy splatters and burns. A charcoal air filter reduces the unpleasant grease smell created by many deep fryers -- owners say it works well and they appreciate being able to fry foods at home without sniffing fried food odors for hours.

Durability/appearance

Only a few concerns. We saw very few complaints about durability with the Presto CoolDaddy 05442 over the hundreds of user reviews we examined, although reports of problems with the basket-lowering mechanism are seen. Some describe the CoolDaddy's construction as "flimsy," but most are very pleased. It has a small footprint, which makes it easy to store, owners say. We review the black model here, but the CoolDaddy also comes in white (05443); however, the white finish is said to stain easily and be harder to clean. This deep fryer is backed by a one-year warranty.

Where To Buy
Presto 05442 CoolDaddy Cool-touch Deep Fryer - Black

 (787 reviews)
Buy new: $99.99 $60.75   26 Used & new from $49.24

In Stock.

 
Featured StoresStore RatingNotesTotal Price
SearsSears rated 3.15 (1347 reviews)1,347 store reviewsIn Stock. $84.83
TargetTarget rated 2.21 (298 reviews)298 store reviewsIn Stock. Free Shipping On Orders $50+$43.99
HayneedleHayneedle rated 4.24 (919 reviews)919 store reviewsIn Stock. Now Accepting PayPal! Marked down 32% off regular price.$49.98
 

Presto 05442 Reviews

1. Amazon.com

The Presto CoolDaddy gets an average rating of 4.2 stars out of 5 after more than 725 owner reviews. Users say this small deep fryer is ideal for cooking about two servings of food, and most find it easy to clean. However, a few wish it were more user-friendly. The white version (05443) is reviewed separately and gets a slightly lower rating, but with also with many fewer reviews.

Review: Presto 05442 CoolDaddy Cool-touch Deep Fryer - Black, Contributors to Amazon.com, As of November 2014

2. Walmart.com

More than 130 owners review the Presto CoolDaddy at Walmart.com, where it gets 4.3 stars out of 5. Customers like that the basket can be moved up or down even after the lid is closed, and most agree that it's easy to clean. There are scattered complaints of flimsy construction and a lower-than-expected oil temperature.

Review: Presto Professional CoolDaddy Cool Touch 6-Cup Deep Fryer, Contributors to Walmart.com, As of November 2014

3. Macys.com

The Presto CoolDaddy maintains an overall score of 4.6 stars out of 5 after feedback from more than 70 owners. They say this deep fryer is safe, easy to use and easy to clean. The few negatives are from older reviews.

Review: Presto 5442 Deep Fryer, CoolDaddy, Contributors to Macys.com, As of November 2014

4. Kmart.com

More than 35 users give the Presto CoolDaddy 4 stars out of 5 at Kmart.com, saying the temperature is spot on and fried food comes out perfectly. Several owners point out how easy this fryer is to clean.

Review: Presto CoolDaddy Cool-Touch Electric Deep Fryer, Contributors to Kmart.com, As of November 2014

5. Viewpoints.com

About 25 owners share feedback on the Presto CoolDaddy 05442 here, giving it an average rating of 83 out of 100. Users like the locking lid and safe basket-lowering feature to avoid splatters. Some say the white model stains easily and is hard to clean.

Review: Presto CoolDaddy 05442 Deep Fryer Reviews, Contributors to Viewpoints.com, As of November 2014

Back to top