Page: 5 of 5
Deep Fryers: Ratings of Sources
Total of 16 Sources
1. Fine Cooking
April 1, 2005
Is this Deep Fryer Right for You?
by Susie Middleton
Our Assessment

Susie Middleton of Fine Cooking magazine tests the DeLonghi D895UX Roto Electric Fryer and finds it quick to heat and easy to use. The Roto has a rotating fry basket, so it uses less oil than other deep fryers, and oil drains through a hidden rubber hose. Foods with a thick, crusty batter (chicken nuggets, for example) fried up beautifully, but food with a wet batter (such as onion rings) stuck to the fry basket and made a mess. We'd give this report higher marks if Middleton had tested other fryers in addition to the Roto.

expand

collapse

2. Amazon.com
As of Mar. 2009
Deep Fryers
by Contributors to Amazon.com
Our Assessment

Amazon.com encourages customers to review the products they own. Such reviews are particularly helpful because only owners can comment on a fryer's performance over time. Among those electric deep fryers garnering 10 or more reviews, the Presto 05466 Stainless Steel Dual Basket ProFry Deep Fryer, the Presto 05411 GranPappy, the Aroma ADF-212 and the Presto 05450 DualDaddy all earn well above average ratings. The Euro-Pro 4L Triple Deep Fryer earns below-average ratings from several users who say their fryers stopped working, as does the Chef Pepin CH48275 3-Liter Deep Fryer and Multiple Cooker, which one user says burst into flames.

expand

collapse

3. ConsumerReports.org
Nov. 2004
Turkey Fryers
by Editors of Consumer Reports
Our Assessment Consumer Reports tests an electric turkey fryer available through QVC. The safety features (including a temperature sensor that turns the fryer off if a maximum temperature is reached, as well as six legs for stability) work. Editors add that safety experts consider propane turkey fryers dangerous.
4. Los Angeles Times
Jan. 9, 2008
Putting Deep Fryers to the Test
by Editors of the Los Angeles Times
Our Assessment

Editors test six deep fryers that range in price from $20 to $130. Editors assessed their performance, value, ease of use and cleanup, safety and the usefulness of their features. Unfortunately, editors tested a single food -- zucchini sticks -- in each fryer. The Presto CoolDaddy outperformed all other fryers, and editors deemed it a cinch to clean. The professional-style Euro-Pro 4L and Waring Pro DF250B did a good job with large quantities of food, but editors disliked the fact that the heating elements aren't removable for cleaning.

expand

collapse

5. Cook's Illustrated Magazine
April 1, 2005
Deep Fryers
by Editors of Cook's Illustrated
Our Assessment

The Cook's Illustrated team tests seven deep fryers by checking how long they take to heat oil to 375 degrees, by measuring how much the temperature declines when they drop in frozen fries, and by measuring how much time elapses until the oil is hot enough for a fresh batch of fries. In the end, they prefer smaller fryers that use less oil, which saves money and reduces waste. They found see-through lids useless (they steam over and become opaque) and built-in timers troublesome (they can turn off the fryer before frying is complete). This is an excellent article, but it's outdated and most of the tested fryers are no longer available.

expand

collapse

6. Cooking.com
As of Mar. 2009
Deep Fryer Reviews
by Contributors to Cooking.com
Our Assessment

Customers are invited to post reviews of the products they own. Most fryers receive only a handful of reviews, but some have accumulated dozens. The Emerilware FR7009001 from T-Fal is named the top-rated model. The Nesco DF-1241 Deluxe Deep Fryer is named a bestseller. The DeLonghi D895UX Roto Deep Fryer and the Waring Pro DF250B also receive many good reviews. No fryers receive fewer than a four-star rating (out of five), so satisfaction seems good across the board.

expand

collapse

7. Epinions.com
As of Mar. 2009
Deep Fryer Reviews
by Contributors to Epinions.com
Our Assessment

Epinions.com lets users post reviews of products they own. There are a lot of deep fryers listed here, but only a few have any reviews. Sorting the results by rating may help you. Some deep fryers, including the Presto 05420 FryDaddy, have garnered as many as three dozen reviews. The FryDaddy and DeLonghi D895UX Roto are among the best-reviewed deep fryers here. The Euro-Pro EP564 Deep Fryer earns a below-average rating, as do the T-Fal FR7008002 Ultimate EZ Clean Pro Deep Fryer and the Rival Cool Touch/Cool Zone CZF530 Deep Fryer.

expand

collapse

8. About.com
Not Dated
Emerilware Deep Fryer
by Peggy Trowbridge Filippone
Our Assessment

Peggy Trowbridge Filippone, About.com's guide to home cooking, prepares frozen food and her own recipes in the Emerilware FR7009001 Deep Fryer and recommends it. This fryer has a filter that removes food particles from oil, so that you can reuse it "up to 15 times," according to Filippone. As she notes, oil filtration can take as long as three hours. We would give this review a higher rating if Filippone compared the Emerilware fryer to others, and if she discussed the fryer's performance in greater detail. (Note: ConsumerSearch is owned by About.com, but the two don't share an editorial affiliation.)

expand

collapse

9. UmamiMart.com
Feb. 1, 2009
Appliance Review: George Foreman Lean, Mean Spin-Frying Machine
by "Sonja"
Our Assessment "Sonja," a Umami Mart editor, test-fries dumplings, mozzarella sticks and frozen French fries in the George Foreman Lean Mean Fryer. According to the manufacturer's claims, its spin cycle can lower fat content by up to 55 percent. This reviewer finds the foods crisp, with a "baked" taste and the look of fried food.
10. ReviewStream.com
Not Dated
Review of the Bayou Classic 30-Quart Turkey Fryer
by "Keeper of the Chaos"
Our Assessment

Reviewstream.com allows consumers to post lengthy reviews of the products they own. Anonymous reviewer "Keeper of the Chaos" says that it took a long time for the cooking oil to come up to the appropriate temperature for frying a large turkey, but the 14-pound turkey took less than an hour to cook. The turkey emerged moist and very flavorful, but the reviewer does say that the device will not be used very often, due to the "expense and hassle." However, the reviewer praises the included "sturdy" fry accessory basket, which can be used for steaming seafood. Overall, this fryer is "worth the price," the reviewer concludes.

expand

collapse

11. Walmart.com
As of Mar. 2009
Deep Fryers
by Contributors to Walmart.com
Our Assessment At Walmart.com, consumers are encouraged to post reviews of the products they use. Star ratings are shown, but it's impossible to tell how many customers reviewed a particular product unless you click through to another screen. Top-rated fryers here include a professional-style model from Kalorik, the Presto 05411 GranPappy and the pro-style Presto 05466 Dual Basket ProFry.
12. Buzzillions.com
As of Mar. 2009
Fryer and Electric Skillets
by Contributors to Buzzillions.com
Our Assessment

Buzzillions.com groups electric skillets and deep fryers together, and there's no way to separate them. These reviews are culled from other websites, so it's a good place to view collected reviews on products. Owners like the fact that they can fry two foods simultaneously in the Presto 05466 Stainless Steel Dual Basket ProFry, which is the top-rated fryer here. Owners like the DeLonghi D895UX Roto's rotating basket, which lets you use less oil, but report that wet batters stick to the basket.

expand

collapse

13. Sears.com
As of Mar. 2009
Deep Fryers
by Contributors to Sears.com
Our Assessment Sears.com allows customers to post reviews of the products they own. Some fryers have accumulated as many as 30 reviews, but others get just one. The Presto 05466 ProFry earns the top slot here. Owners say it can turn out a large quantity of food in a short time. The Presto CoolDaddy earns an above-average rating. Owners say it heats up quickly, and the housing stays cool.
14. Viewpoints.com
As of Mar. 2009
Deep Fryers
by Contributors to Viewpoints.com
Our Assessment

Viewpoints invites customers to review the products they own on a five-point scale. Owners can identify themselves as "practical," "budget conscious," "messy" and so forth. The top-rated scale here is the Bayou Classic Turkey Fryer, which is said to be easy to use and durable. Owners like the fact that the Presto 05466 Stainless Steel Dual Basket ProFry allows them to cook different types of food at the same time, and it's easy to clean.

expand

collapse

15. Chowhound.com
As of Mar. 2009
Deep Fryer
by Contributors to Chowhound.com
Our Assessment Chowhound.com is an online community for foodies. A contributor to the message boards asks for advice choosing among three deep fryers from T-Fal, DeLonghi and Waring. Contributors report that many models don't reach a high enough temperature to fry certain foods, such as french fries, properly.
16. CNET
Jan. 13, 2009
Out of the Frying Pan and into the Deep Fryer
by Abbi Perets
Our Assessment Abbi Perets offers a cursory look at the Hamilton Beach 35020 Cool Touch Deep Fryer. She likes the lid, which can be removed for cleaning. We're not sure, however, that Perets actually tested this fryer. She does not describe the foods she prepared in this fryer or her testing process, if any.

Back to top