Page: 6 of 6
Deodorant: Ratings of Sources
Total of 27 Sources
1. ConsumerReports.org
Oct. 2007
Do Antiperspirants Leave Unsightly White?
by Editors of ConsumerReports.org
Our Assessment

Consumer Reports tests four antiperspirants' claims of leaving no white residue on clothes by comparing them with similar products that make no such claim. After exercising for an hour in black T-shirts, eight men and 12 women report the amount of residue left behind. One brand is a clear winner, but editors say antiperspirants promising no residue perform only slightly better than those that do not.

expand

collapse

2. Allure
Oct. 2008
Best of Beauty Awards 2008 - Body
by Editors of Allure
Our Assessment Editors of Allure magazine test thousands of beauty products, both old and new, for their annual beauty awards. More than 180 products are listed in several categories and each is given a brief description. Testing criteria, however, is not explained and the non-winning products are not listed. Only one deodorant, Secret Flawless Antiperspirant/Deodorant, makes the list.
3. Shape
Sept. 2008
The Year's Best Beauty Products: Shape of Beauty 2008 Awards
by Sally Wadyka
Our Assessment Shape staff, readers and beauty experts test beauty products in 23 categories for their fifth consecutive annual beauty awards. A drugstore and department store winner is chosen for most categories, but only one deodorant, Secret Clinical Strength Antiperspirant/Deodorant, makes the list. Non-winning products are not mentioned.
4. Better Nutrition
April 2009
Best of Beauty Awards 2009
by Editors of Better Nutrition
Our Assessment For their second annual beauty awards, editors of Better Nutrition list 85 winning beauty and personal care products in 13 categories. All products are made of natural ingredients and are tested for efficacy. Non-winning products, however, are not discussed. Five natural deodorants from Hugo Naturals, Kiss My Face, Tom's of Maine, TCCD and Crystal make the list.
5. Slate.com
Dec. 28, 2000
No Sweat
by Eliza Truitt
Our Assessment

In this dated but thorough article, Eliza Truitt tests eight antiperspirants and deodorants against three different types of odors -- "old stink", "stress sweat" and "workout sweat". Secret Platinum Protection deodorant performs the best in all three tests, although Lady Mitchum Clear Gel and Crystal Stick Deodorant come close. Truitt suggests that clear or gel formulas perform better than standard formulas.

expand

collapse

6. TruthInAging.com
As of May 2009
Deodorant
by Editors of TruthInAging.com
Our Assessment

Editors of TruthInAging.com analyze ingredients of beauty products in order to determine whether they are safe to use. Those that pass the ingredient test are tested to determine if they live up to their claims or cause any harm. Several products are reviewed and recommended in various categories and the website is regularly updated with new recommendations. There are three deodorant brands recommended on the site, as of press time, including Pristine Recovery Take a Whiff Natural Deodorant, Dermalogica Environmental Control Deodorant and Desert Essence Aluminum Free Dry By Nature Deodorant. Editors warn, however, that natural and aluminum-free deodorant does a better job of keeping odor away than keeping you dry.

expand

collapse

Road Test Antiperspirants
by Bora Chang
Our Assessment

Testers at Real Simple test 50 antiperspirant deodorants and choose winners and runners-up in each of four categories. A brief description of each product is given but non-winning products are not mentioned. Winning deodorants include Secret Clinical Strength Antiperspirant/Deodorant (best solid antiperspirant), Mitchum for Women Dry Roll-On (best roll-on), Dry Idea Clear Gel Anti-Perspirant & Deodorant (best gel or cream), and Arrid XX Ultra Clear Antiperspirant Deodorant spray.

expand

collapse

Smell Fresh, Naturally
by Olessa Pindak
Our Assessment Editors of Natural Health test 37 aluminum-free deodorants in the dead of summer in order to find the best. Twelve products are listed as the best, though some categories are a bit redundant. Natural deodorant from Dr. Hauschka, Dermalogica, and Kiss My Face, among others, make the list. Non-winning products, however, are not mentioned.
Kiss of Approval Beauty Awards 2008
by Editors of CosmoGirl
Our Assessment

Readers, editors and celebrities vote on favorite beauty products for CosmoGirl's annual beauty awards. 55 products are listed under face, body and hair categories with tester comments for each. Products that don't make the list aren't mentioned nor are any comparisons to comparable products given. Secret Clinical Strength Anti-Perspirant/Deodorant is the only deodorant listed. (It's No. 28 in the slide show.)

expand

collapse

10. TheGreenGuide.com
Not Dated
Deodorants Buying Guide
by Editors of TheGreenGuide.com
Our Assessment Editors of TheGreenGuide.com give tips for choosing safe and natural deodorant brands. They recommend avoiding products with parabens, fragrance and antibacterials among other things. Top natural deodorants are chosen based on their ingredient list, third-party certification, and recyclable packaging. The efficacy of products is not considered, however.
11. Brides
May/June 2009
2009 Brides' Beauty Awards
by Editors of Brides magazine
Our Assessment Editors of Brides magazine list top beauty products in makeup, face, body, hair and tools categories. 75 products in total are listed, but it's not clear how many were tested or what the judging criteria were. Products are not rated or compared to others and only brief descriptions are given. Dove Clinical Protection Anti-Perspirant/Deodorant is listed as the Best Deodorant.
12. Redbook
Dec. 2008
Beauty's Top 40 of 2008 -- Monthly MVPs
by Cheryl Kramer Kaye, Krista Bennett DeMaio, Crystal Martin, Nadeska Alexis
Our Assessment Editors of Redbook spotlight 40 of the year's most "innovative" beauty products for their annual beauty awards. Products are not categorized, ranked or compared and judging criteria are not very clear. Secret Flawless deodorant is noted in a list of monthly MVPs for using the same technology as Febreeze odor eliminator.
Expert Advice
by Editors of Men's Health
Our Assessment

Experts for Men's Health magazine recommend using Certain Dri at night to relieve excessive daytime sweating. Underarms should be washed in the morning to remove excess antiperspirant, though, in order to avoid skin irritation. A standard antiperspirant with deodorant, such as Mitchum Clear Gel Antiperspirant, can then be applied in the morning for extra protection. Products mentioned in the article are not rated.

expand

collapse

Pit Stop
by Editors of Men's Fitness
Our Assessment Editors of Men's Fitness list six recommended deodorant for men based on personality types and activity levels. Products from Mitchum, Axe, Burt's Bees, Old Spice, Gillette and ClarinsMen make the list. Some of the deodorants listed are suggested for their scent, while others are recommended for their effectiveness. It's not clear, however, if any of these products were actually tested.
15. Chatelaine Magazine
Aug. 2008
(Don't) Get Funky
by Editors of Chatelaine
Our Assessment Editors of Chatelaine list their favorite deodorants, which include Secret Clinical Strength, Home Health Herbal Magic Roll-On and Crystal Body Deodorant. Although the benefits of each are briefly discussed, the criteria behind their choices are not clear and no other products are mentioned or compared.
16. MSNBC
Oct. 17, 2007
Want a Fresh, Green Deodorant? Don't Sweat It!
by Marisa Belger
Our Assessment

In this article, Marisa Belger discusses what she has learned through personal experience with natural deodorant. She provides application tips, ingredients to avoid and suggestions of products that have worked well for her and her husband. Belger's all-time favorite natural deodorant is Dr. Hauschka Deodorant, which she admits is expensive. She also recommends Weleda Deodorant Spray and Burt's Bees Herbal Deodorant. Crystal Body Deodorant, however, is best used as paperweight, she says.

expand

collapse

17. MakeupAlley.com
As of May 2009
Deodorants
by Contributors to MakeupAlley.com
Our Assessment Contributors to MakeupAlley.com rate and review more than 200 deodorants. Top products, including deodorants from Certain Dri, Kiss My Face, Fresh and Kiehl's are reviewed numerous times and receive high ratings overall.
18. Buzzillions.com
As of May 2009
Deodorant Reviews
by Contributors to Buzzillions.com
Our Assessment

Buzzillions.com posts user reviews from various consumer websites, including Drugstore.com and Walgreens. Each product receives at least one review and several are also given a "review snapshot" in which the pros and cons are summarized. Buzzillions.com also ranks products according to the number of reviews, overall rating and strength of the reviews. Some products in their top ten, however, only receive a few reviews, while others that are ranked lower receive hundreds. Certain Dri Antiperspirant Roll-On, Crystal Body Deodorant and Secret Clinical Strength Antiperspirant/Deodorant each receive high ratings with more than 100 reviews.

expand

collapse

19. TotalBeauty.com
As of May 2009
Antiperspirants and Deodorant
by Contributors to TotalBeauty.com
Our Assessment More than 200 antiperspirants and deodorants are posted for review at TotalBeauty.com but Secret and Dove products are reviewed more often than any other brand. Dove Antiperspirant Deodorant Ultimate Clear in Smooth Cashmere, Secret Clinical Strength Antiperspirant/Deodorant, Secret Original Solid and Secret Scent Expressions get the highest ratings of those that are reviewed more than 100 times.
20. Amazon.com
As of May 2009
Deodorants and Antiperspirants
by Contributors to Amazon.com
Our Assessment

Hundreds of deodorants and antiperspirants are listed for sale at Amazon.com, but most only receive a handful, if any, reviews. Certain Dri Roll-On Antiperspirant, Dove Clinical Protection and Degree Clinical Protection, both the women's and men's version, are all reviewed more than 100 times with high overall ratings. Gillette Clinical Strength Advanced Solid Anti-Perspirant is not reviewed quite as often, but does well in reviews.

expand

collapse

No Sweat
by Editors of Prevention
Our Assessment In this brief article, three deodorants are recommended for different needs. Secret Clinical Strength is suggested for those who sweat excessively. Dove Ultimate Clear Deodorant is recommended for sensitive skin and Avalon Organics Wild Yam Roll-On Deodorant is advocated as a good all-natural deodorant. Products are not rated or compared and testing methods are not clear.
22. Shape
May 2007
Sweat Stoppers
by Editors of Shape
Our Assessment

Editors don't say much about deodorant in this brief article, but they do recommend four products for extra protection, all day protection, clear application and soothing properties. They don't mention any judging criteria, though, or whether products were tested and compared to others. Secret Clinical Strength Antiperspirant/Deodorant, Degree Women, Mitchum Smart Solid and Aubrey Organics E Plus High C all make the list.

expand

collapse

23. About.com
Not Dated
Top 10 Deodorants/Anti-Perspirants
by Shirley Bragg
Our Assessment

This list of top deodorants is rudimentary at best. The products are not listed in any particular order and many of the choices appear to be based on the claims of the manufacturers. It's not clear if any of the products were actually tested. Author, Shirley Bragg suggests Mitchum deodorant, available in several varieties, for those who have tried everything to no avail. (Note: ConsumerSearch is owned by About.com, but the two don't share an editorial affiliation.)

expand

collapse

24. Shape
Not Dated
Easy Ways to Stay Dry
by Editors of Shape
Our Assessment

Editors of Shape magazine discuss tips for controlling excessive sweat, including wearing light-colored, loose fitting cotton clothing and using an antiperspirant that contains aluminum chloride. Editors recommend consulting a physician if sweat is excessive even with low activity level and cool weather. Various physician-prescribed treatments, including Drysol and Botox injections are discussed but over-the-counter brands are not mentioned.

expand

collapse

25. New Scientist
Feb. 28, 2009
Smells Fine to Me
by Toshi Knell
Our Assessment Toshi Knell of New Scientist claims that there are only three differences between men's and women's deodorant: advertising, packaging and fragrance. What's more, both types contain similar fragrance notes and are as suitable for either gender as personal preference allows. Specific products are not rated or discussed.
26. Cosmetics Database.com
As of May 2009
Antiperspirant/Deodorant
by Editors of CosmeticsDatabase.com
Our Assessment

This website, sponsored by the Environmental Working Group, hosts a cosmetic safety database known as Skin Deep. The database lists thousands of beauty products and gives them a hazard score. Products with a score of 0-2 are considered a low hazard, while a score of 3-6 is moderate and a score of 7-10 is a high hazard. Each product has its own page with a listing of the hazards that its ingredients are linked to, such as cancer, reproductive problems and allergies. In addition to listing hazardous ingredients, the website also states whether or not a company engages in animal testing. There are nearly 900 deodorants listed, most of which have low to moderate hazard scores. While this site is very informative, it does not consider the effectiveness of any products that it rates, nor does it consider the likelihood of skin irritations. But this is an interesting reference source.

expand

collapse

27. Men's Health
Jan./Feb. 2009
Ask Men's Health
by Editors of Men's Health
Our Assessment Editors of Men's Health explain why yellow stains in the armpit area occur and how to remove them. Editors recommend waiting for antiperspirant to dry completely before getting dressed in order to prevent stains from occurring. No specific products are discussed in this article.

Back to top