Nikon D5000

1. PopPhoto.com

Though Philip Ryan and Dan Richards give top ranking to the Canon T1i, the Nikon D5000 also wins kudos here for its moveable LCD and fast autofocus. However, the Canon T1i provides better video, a bigger LCD, sharper resolution and better image quality in dim lighting.

Review: Canon EOS Rebel T1i vs. Nikon D5000, Philip Ryan and Dan Richards, June 2009

2. ConsumerReports.org

ConsumerReports.org compares the Nikon D5000 with 23 other digital SLR cameras, including close competitors, based on ratings for image quality, dynamic range, versatility and ease of use. Editors also compare camera brands for reliability.

Review: Digital SLRs, Editors of ConsumerReports.org

3. CNET

CNET's review of the Nikon D5000 is more critical than most, noting a small, dim viewfinder, autofocus points that are hard to see, plus limited video capabilities. However, kudos go to the flip-down LCD, 4 fps speed, good kit lens and overall image quality; thus the Nikon D5000 slightly edges out the competing Canon T1i here.

Review: Nikon D5000, Lori Grunin, Dec. 2009

4. DPReview.com

This detailed single-product review of the Nikon D5000 compares it with its major competitors, giving it the same overall rating (highly recommended) as the Canon T1i and Olympus E-620. The Nikon's advantages and disadvantages are noted in detail, including the fact that the articulating LCD can make tripod-mounting tedious.

Review: Nikon D5000 Review, Richard Butler, June 2009

5. DXOMark.com

Lab tests here evaluate digital-camera sensors, only one factor that affects image quality. The Nikon D5000 sensor ranks 18th here, higher than any other sensor in its price range. The Canon T1i, in contrast, ranks 55th.

Review: Tests and Reviews for Nikon D5000, Editors of DxOMark.com