Page: 6 of 6
Dishwashers: Ratings of Sources
Total of 19 Sources

For an explanation of how we rank reviews, see our ratings criteria page.

1. ConsumerReports.org
Aug. 2008
Dishwashers: Ratings, How to Choose
by Editors of Consumer Reports
Our Assessment

Consumer Reports updates its dishwasher ratings approximately every six months. Forty-seven dishwashers are included in the latest roundup. Editors measure cleaning ability, energy efficiency and noise level. Most machines are similar in cleaning ability, with larger differences in noise level, energy efficiency and convenience. One of the article's most valuable assets is a sidebar about overall brand reliability -- the results from a survey of more than 100,000 Consumer Reports subscribers. This is by far the most informative review we read. Consumer Reports also invites subscribers to write reviews for products, which can be helpful.

expand

collapse

2. Choice magazine
Nov. 2008
Dishwashers: Compare and Review Products
by Editors of Choice magazine
Our Assessment

Choice magazine is the Australian equivalent of Consumer Reports, with testing that is just as complete and thorough. Most of the brands rated here are available in the U.S., though model numbers and specifications often differ. Thirty-six dishwashers are tested. Four models are recommended, including one each from Miele and Asko. Bosch rounds out the last two recommended dishwashers with models not available in the U.S., but both are comparable to the Bosch SHX98M09UC. Fisher & Paykel dishwashers receive some of the lowest overall scores.

expand

collapse

3. Which? magazine
Feb. 2009
Dishwashers
by Editors of Which? magazine
Our Assessment

Like Choice magazine above, this British magazine is similar to Consumer Reports and continually tests dishwashers. In this latest report, 126 dishwashers are rated, with 22 models recommended. Three Bosch models are first, second and third, but one is a tabletop model, and one is freestanding. An Electrolux dishwasher comes in fourth, but it is also a freestanding unit. Bosch and Miele models are said to be among the most reliable overall.

expand

collapse

4. Consumer magazine
Jan. 27, 2009
Dishwashers
by Editors of Consumer magazine
Our Assessment Consumer magazine is a New Zealand publication that performs extensive tests of dishwashers, much like Consumer Reports. Editors test 22 models in the most recent report, and four are recommended. Results of a brand reliability survey are also included. Bosch and Miele are the most reliable, while Fisher & Paykel DishDrawers rank at the bottom of the list.
5. ENERGYSTAR.gov
Not Dated
Dishwashers
by Editors of EnergyStar.gov
Our Assessment

Energy Star is a joint project of the Department of Energy and the EPA. This site has an extensive list of Energy Star-compliant dishwashers that are more efficient than non-Energy Star products. In addition to listing brands and model numbers, the energy factor (EF) rating is also available. The federal standard EF is now greater than or equal to 0.46. Energy Star dishwashers have an EF factor of at least 0.65. This site also offers information on purchasing a dishwasher and on efficient use, but specific dishwashers are neither tested nor rated.

expand

collapse

6. TheGreenGuide.com
Not Dated
Dishwashers Buying Guide
by Editors of TheGreenGuide.com
Our Assessment

TheGreenGuide.com, run by the National Geographic Society, is devoted to helping people live in an environmentally aware way. This buying guide ranks dishwashers based on their energy efficiency and water usage. Tips on choosing dishwashers are included. Although some products at TheGreenGuide.com are tested, there's no indication the dishwashers have been. The KitchenAid KUDD03STWH is chosen as the best value, while the Asko D5893 is the most eco-friendly dishwasher rated. Green Guide also recommends the Viking DFUD042.

expand

collapse

2008 Kitchen Appliance Study: Dishwashers
by Editors of J.D. Power and Associates
Our Assessment

Nearly 15,000 people participate in this customer satisfaction survey about major home appliances, including dishwashers. Brands are rated in six categories including performance, price, features, ease of use, style and warranty. Bosch wins for overall satisfaction, followed by Kenmore Elite. Other well-liked brands are LG, KitchenAid and Whirlpool Gold. Bosch receives a good or perfect score in all categories except price. However, this article does not recommend or rate specific models.

expand

collapse

8. Sears.com
Not Dated
Dishwashers
by Contributors to Sears.com
Our Assessment Sears is the only site, other than Epinions.com and Consumer Reports, where you'll find some user ratings for Kenmore dishwashers. Most of the reviews are from new or fairly recent owners of Kenmore dishwashers, so keep that in mind when considering reliability and long-term performance, but this site is still worth a check if you're considering a Kenmore dishwasher in particular.
9. Dulley.com
2008
Dishwashers: Update Bulletin No. 578
by James Dulley
Our Assessment

James Dulley is an engineer and columnist who writes about household appliances and other house and home products. This buyer's guide covers quieter dishwashers. Dulley says the best dishwashers feature two pumps -- one for spray cleaning and one for draining the water. Although Dulley favors Miele dishwashers, he discusses in detail a wide range of models and brands that are also good choices. None appear to have been subjected to formal testing, however.

expand

collapse

Luxury Appliances for Less
by Editors of Good Housekeeping
Our Assessment

This brief article discusses the best low-cost luxury household appliances, according to Good Housekeeping editors. The Bosch Integra SHX36L, which is made of stainless steel both inside and out, is the top choice for dishwashers. This model does a great cleaning job while using less water than other machines. The LG LDS5811ST (now discontinued) is recommended for loading flexibility. While it's clear these dishwashers were tested, editors don't disclose the extent of the testing, nor do they tell us which models failed to make the cut.

expand

collapse

11. Buzzillions.com
Not Dated
Dishwashers
by Contributors to Buzzillions.com
Our Assessment Buzzillions.com compiles consumer reviews from several retailers, including ABT.com, AJMadison.com and the Best Buy website. Dishwashers are ranked based on both average rating and the number of reviews they have. The top pick is the portable Danby DDW1805W, which has nearly 25 ratings and an overall above-average score.
12. Viewpoints.com
Not Dated
Dishwasher Reviews
by Contributors to Viewpoints.com
Our Assessment Like Epinions.com, Viewpoints has user reviews of a few hundred dishwashers. Unfortunately, most of the listed dishwashers have only a handful of reviews and no particular model stands out here. In some cases, reviews are for an entire brand or series rather than a specific model. Most reviews are brief -- only a sentence or two -- but some go into more detail.
13. GardenWeb.com
Not Dated
Appliances Forum
by Contributors to GardenWeb.com
Our Assessment You can find individual opinions about dishwashers in these forums, but it is hit or miss whether you'll take away any useful information. There is information here on specific issues, including customer-service problems, repair issues and a lengthy discussion on why some dishwashers have a foul interior odor. Solutions are suggested.
14. Abby'sGuide.com
Not Dated
Getting the Dirt on Dishwashers
by Editors of AbbysGuide.com
Our Assessment

Abby's Guide offers detailed information on how to buy a dishwasher, what to look for and how to save on energy bills. There are no reviews, ratings or recommendations, but there's still some useful information provided. Dishwasher features are discussed, including GE's SmartDispense, which allows you to fill the soap dispenser with 48 ounces of detergent to cover numerous washes. The SmartDispense system uses the detergent as needed. Other features include sensors that determine how dirty your dishes are and then choose the appropriate wash cycle. Finally, Abby's Guide lists the four major dishwasher manufacturers in the U.S. and which brand names they sell.

expand

collapse

15. Building Products magazine
Sept. 15, 2008
Dishwashers Combine Energy Efficiency, Water Conservation and Premium Cleaning
by Chris Wood
Our Assessment This article from Building Products magazine (a trade publication for contractors) discusses what to look for when buying an efficient dishwasher. Although no specific models are chosen, several are featured.
16. RateItAll.com
Not Dated
Dishwashers
by Contributors to RateItAll.com
Our Assessment Of the 114 dishwashers listed here, only a few receive actual reviews from owners. Not surprisingly, the longer reviews are from consumers describing in detail what is wrong with their dishwashers. It is helpful, however, to see the number of ratings right on the main page. Note that RateItAll.com includes some reviews from Amazon.com.
17. Amazon.com
Not Dated
Dishwashers
by Contributors to Amazon.com
Our Assessment Hundreds of dishwashers are listed at Amazon.com, but only a handful receives user reviews, and those that do get reviews have only a few. The reviews, however, tend to be thoughtful and detailed. This site will work best if you have already narrowed your choices down to a few models. The Bosch Integra 800 Series 24" (SHX98M09UC) receives perfect ratings, but from only two reviewers.
18. Epinions.com
Not Dated
Dishwashers
by Contributors to Epinions.com
Our Assessment

Epinions.com lets users rate their own dishwashers and serves as an excellent forum for complaints. At the time of our visit, owners were disappointed with quite a few Maytag and GE models, most of which warrant only a one- or two-star rating. One of the Fisher & Paykel Dish Drawer models receives more than 75 comments, but only an average score. The top reviewed models are a portable dishwasher from Danby and the Whirlpool GU2700XTS (now discontinued).

expand

collapse

19. ConsumerGuide.com
Not Dated
Built-In Dishwashers
by Editors of ConsumerGuide.com
Our Assessment Although several dishwashers receive a rating for "performance," there is no evidence that any testing was conducted or that these models were even seen in person. Altogether, 20 dishwashers are recommended as Best Buys, but we're unsure why these models may have been chosen over others. Although some dishwashers get a "performance" rating, nothing seems to have been tested.

Back to top