Topical and oral flea control treatments are most
Fleas are more than an
annoyance -- they can affect the health of their host dog or cat. A flea's saliva
could trigger allergies, and the itching and scratching that ensues can lead to
a more serious skin infection. Infected fleas can also transmit tapeworms and
bacteria -- including bacteria that are harmful to humans. A large enough
number of fleas can even cause life-threatening blood loss.
Unfortunately, fleas are not
a problem that will go away on its own. In fact, ignoring a few fleas can
quickly lead to an infestation. Female fleas can lay up to 50 eggs a day, many
of which fall off and land in carpets, bedding and furniture. Once the larvae
hatch, they remain inactive in cocoons for weeks or even months. Unsuspecting
pet owners might think the problem is resolved after killing the adult fleas,
but the life cycle will repeat weeks later unless eggs and larvae are prevented
from maturing into adult fleas. Experts say the most effective way to keep
fleas off a dog or cat is with a topical or oral medication.
Types of Flea Control
Also known as spot-on products, topical treatments are squeezed out of a tube and applied to the pet's neck or back. One advantage of these products is that they generally contain insect growth regulators (IGRs), which prevent eggs from hatching and larvae from maturing into adult fleas. This means that a single application can completely eliminate fleas for up to a month. However, these products have drawbacks as well. Although they're generally safe for pets if applied correctly, they can irritate the skin or eyes of humans; should you come in contact with the product, it must be rinsed off promptly. Once applied, the product may take several hours to dry. During this time, it may rinse off in water, and the residue may transfer to other pets, furniture or humans. Moreover, some pet owners find the smell or feel of the spot-on treatments unpleasant.
Until recently, experts have said that flea collars are generally ineffective; some are toxic to pets and people as well. There is one exception, however, Seresto, which uses the same active ingredient as a well-rated topical treatment, Advantage, but in a slow-release formulation. Seresto also has a tick killing ingredient. Seresto is pricey, so other options are more cost effective if you pet is indoors most or all of the time, but for pets that spend lots of time out of doors, it can make sense. No other flea collar receives much, if any, positive feedback from pet experts.
Flea control medications pose no risk to humans, and they don't leave any messy residue. Oral flea treatments tend to kill adult fleas very quickly, but most of them don't contain an IGR to deal with the eggs and larvae. This means that pet owners must either combine the tablet with a second treatment that contains an IGR, such as a spot-on product, or keep repeating the dose until no new fleas are hatching. Another problem is getting a pet to take the pill. While some users say their pets will gobble them happily if they're tucked inside a treat, others -- especially cat owners -- find it very difficult to get them down their pets' throats. Also, some oral medications are available only with a prescription from a vet.
Do other remedies work?
Flea shampoos can provide
immediate relief by killing adult fleas on the pet, but they don't leave enough
residue behind to kill new fleas as they hatch. As for flea dips, bombs,
powders and sprays, many of them contain chemicals called pyrethroids, such as
permethrin. Experts warn that these chemicals are highly toxic, especially to
cats. Some vets say that products containing permethrin can be safe if you only
have dogs in your household, but all warn to not use such products on cats or
even on dogs if one is likely to come in contact with a cat. Permethrin comes
in for the sternest cautions, but some experts also warn against the use of
other pyrethroids as well.
Natural remedies are more
controversial. We see lots of recommendations for them around the Internet, and
receive plenty of questions about them from our readers. However, there's
little scientific evidence that they are effective in most cases. In a recent
blog post, Nancy Kearns of The Whole Dog Journal says that she's "never
had much luck with the plethora of natural remedies out there." And some
natural remedies are rated to be just as toxic according the GreenPaws
Flea and Tick Products Directory published by the Natural Resources Defense
Council, and in some cases more so,
than many of the topical and oral treatments recommended in this report
Finding The Best Flea Control
"On Fleas and Ticks - The 2016 Update"
"Flea Product Comparison"
Because comparative, unbiased
testing is hard to find when it comes to flea control products, we looked first
at feedback from veterinarians and other recognized pet experts who have
extensive experience with the options, their relative effectiveness, and their
safety. One scientific journal, Parasites & Vectors, provides testing based
information and is also helpful, but is written for a professional audience,
rather than pet owners, and some of the research is paid for by flea control
makers, so though peer-reviewed, bias can't be ruled out. The Natural
Resources Defense Council provides feedback on
relative safety of many products, but doesn't weigh in at all on effectiveness.
The rest of the feedback is
supplied by pet owners. We scoured thousands of user reviews at sites like
Amazon.com, Petco.com, and 1800PetMeds.com to find flea control
treatments that pet owners say are effective and safe. We looked at both
positive and negative feedback -- assessing the latter to weed out instances
where supplier issues or incorrect usage might be factors -- to find those
options that work successfully to rid pets of fleas and, in some instances,
other parasites. The result of that research is our recommendation for the best
topical and oral flea control products.
Advantage II stands out for safety and effectiveness
The top two
topical flea treatments for both dogs and cats are Advantage II and Frontline
Plus. They use different active ingredients, imidacloprid and fipronil,
respectively, to eradicate infestations. The two insecticides work differently,
but experts say that when used correctly, they are both safe and effective.
receive mostly positive reviews from veterinarians and pet owners, but we found
somewhat stronger recommendations for Advantage II. Cat owners, in particular,
tend to give (Est. $45 and up for a four-month supply) high marks for its
effectiveness, safety and ease of use. While it does not work for every cat, it's
more consistently effective than any other topical treatment. Most owners also
find it easy to apply and are not bothered by the odor.
Advantage II is a reformulated version of an older
product called Advantage, first released in 1996, which killed only adult
fleas. The current version includes an insect growth regulator (IGR) to kill
flea eggs and larvae as well. Both the original Advantage and Advantage II get
positive reviews from veterinarians, including those who specialize in cat
care. Vets at the All Feline Hospital in Lincoln, Neb., describe Advantage II
as "very safe and effective on
cats." However, reviews from cat owners indicate that in very rare cases,
cats may have dangerous reactions to this treatment, so it's probably wise to
consult a vet before use.
(Est. $40 and up for a four-month supply) is sold in several different dosages, for small,
medium, large and extra-large dogs; as you might expect, versions for larger
dogs cost a little more than those for smaller ones. Dog owners are not quite
as enthusiastic about Advantage II as cat owners. Although most owners find it
effective, dog owners were more likely than cat owners to complain that Advantage
II either didn't work or stopped working before the one-month treatment period
was up. Veterinarian dermatologist Jon Plant, writing at the Itchy Dog Blog,
notes a study, albeit in cats, that shows some drop in effectiveness toward the
end of a month. He adds that "the Advantage line of products are generally
very effective for flea control in most situations, when used as directed
Bayer (the maker of Advantage
II) also offers Advantage Multi (Est. $85 for a 6 month supply).
Advantage Multi, offered by prescription only and in formulations for dogs and
cats, adds additional protections against hookworms, round worms and other
parasites (depending on the species). However, it is not an all life cycle flea
killer and is only effective on adult fleas, not flea eggs and larvae. The cat
version is the only product that's also FDA approved for use on ferrets
(minimum weight of 2 pounds). One disadvantage to products in the Advantage line
is that they don't protect against ticks. If that's a concern, a different
product could be a better choice.
like Advantage II, is a reformulated version of an older product. The original
Frontline killed adult fleas, as well as lice and ticks. The new version,
Frontline Plus, also contains an IGR to kill fleas at every stage of their life
cycle. It continues to protect against ticks and chewing lice as well,
something that Advantage II can't do. (Est. $40 for a three month supply) comes in a
single formulation. (Est. $35 and up for a three month supply), like Advantage II
for Dogs, comes in four dosage versions for dogs of different sizes.
gets high marks for safety from both vets and pet owners. Frontline
works by over-stimulating a flea's nervous system, making them hyperactive
before they die. That can make it look like your pet's flea infestation is
actually getting worse as fleas that were previously unseen rise to the top of
its coat, and that results in some negative feedback in user reviews, but vets
have few reservations. Dr. Plant notes that Frontline Plus is "100%
effective at 12 and 24 hours from 1 day to 28 days post treatment."
There have been some reports, such as this article in The New York Times, indicating that, while fleas in a few parts of the country
have become more resistant to fipronil (the active ingredient in Frontline), it
and other treatments are still largely still effective in most regions. That's
echoed in comments by Dr. Thomas B. McMillen at the Mercy Animal Hospital in
Cranston, R.I., who says "There have apparently been some resistance
problems in Florida, but there is no evidence of that around here." In a
study published in Parasites & Vectors, a scientific journal, researchers
Tad Coles and Michael Dryden find that reports of resistance to flea treatments
is more likely to be caused by improper or insufficient application rather than
resistance to the product by the fleas or other pests themselves.
ConsumerReports.org notes that, because the patent for
fipronil has expired, generic versions of Frontline Plus are now available. Examples
include (Est. $16 and up for a three month supply) and (Est. $15 and up for a three month supply). Formulations for cats
are also available, as are generic versions of the original Frontline, designed
to kill adult fleas but not eggs or larvae.
Experts do sound some cautions, however. While the active
ingredients are the same, inactive ingredients can differ. ConsumerReports.org
says that the least expensive generic substitutes can have lower dosages,
requiring you to treat more often. The Whole Dog Journal specifically recommends
against using low-budget spot on treatments as they can be more toxic and less
effective than those "made by the most reputable and responsible
manufacturers." Still, some vets and other experts consider generic
versions of Frontline to be a reasonable alternative where budgets are a
concern. If you are considering a generic version of Frontline or Frontline
Plus, the best guidance would be to ask your vet. Finally, choose your vendor
wisely as counterfeit versions of Frontline Plus have also been reported.
For dog owners
who want to control both fleas and ticks, another option is (Est. $45 and up for a 4-month supply). Made by the same company
that makes Advantage II, K9
Advantix II contains the same ingredients, plus an additional
ingredient called permethrin that kills ticks and mosquitoes. Permethrin is
highly toxic to cats, so K9 Advantix II is for use on dogs only. While
permethrin is not generally considered harmful to dogs, reviews from dog owners
suggest that K9 Advantix II is more likely to cause side effects than either
Advantage II or Frontline Plus. Skin irritation is the most common problem, but
a few owners describe more serious reactions. Still, K9 Advantix II appears to
be an effective product for treating both fleas and ticks in dogs.
collar to consider
In general, flea collars get a thumbs down from
experts as being both ineffective and often toxic. One that breaks from the
pack, however, is the (Est. $55). This is another
product that uses the same active ingredient as Advantage, and is made by the
same company, but in a gradual release format that keeps pets pest free for
eight months. There's no IGR, but one's not needed as the active ingredient is
constantly killing fleas as they emerge. Seresto collars also have a
tick-killing component, flumethrin, so they are a great choice for animals that
spend a lot of time outdoors.
Vet feedback thus far has been largely positive, and
the Seresto flea collar receives lots of user feedback at sites like
Amazon.com, most of which has been very good. In a blog post, Nancy Kearns of
The Whole Dog Journal reports using Seresto to keep her dogs flea free after an
outbreak had been eradicated. "So far, so good; I haven't spotted any
fleas, and you can believe I've been looking," she writes. Dr. Plant notes
that it kills 100 percent of existing fleas on dogs within 24 hours, and
re-infesting fleas in two hours. It's also 98 percent effective on cats within
6 hours. One caution that he shares is that while the collar is rated to be
effective for eight months, frequent swimming or bathing can reduce that
Adverse reactions seem to be relatively rare.
However, since this flea collar uses the same active ingredient as Advantage,
if your pet has not done well with Advantage, Seresto also won't be a good
choice. Some complaints are seen about the cost, a concern that Kearns echoes
as well, especially for those with multiple pets, but keep in mind that a
single collar is the equivalent of eight monthly does of Advantage. Versions
are available for both dogs and cats.