Page: 5 of 5
Handheld Vacuums: Ratings of Sources
Total of 20 Sources
1. ConsumerReports.org
Mar. 2009
Small Vacuums
by Editors of Consumer Reports
Our Assessment Consumer Reports recently updated the small vacuums ratings from its previous Oct. 2008 ratings chart. Eleven hand vacuums are included along with some stick vacuums and small sweepers. Consumer Reports gets our top rating for its thorough and consistent product testing and its detailed breakdown of the results. Three hand vacuums are recommended overall.
2. Choice magazine
Feb. 2009
Review: Dyson Radix 6 handheld vacuum cleaner
by Editors of Choice
Our Assessment Choice, the Australian counterpart of Consumer Reports, bases its ratings on rigorous independent testing. While this 10-vacuum roundup includes many models not available in the U.S., some of the vacs that are earn top marks, like the Black & Decker Pivot 18 Volt handheld vacuum. The Dyson DC16 Motorhead, sold in the U.S. as the Dyson DC16 Root6 Animal, also performs very well here.
Video Abusive Lab Test: Handheld Vacuums
by Editors of Popular Mechanics
Our Assessment

This video by Popular Mechanics shows testers evaluating three handheld vacuums: the Dirt Devil KONE, the Black & Decker 18 Volt Pivot Vac and the Dyson DC16. Each vacuum is tested on its ability to suck up 32 ounces of pre-sifted flour and 12 ounces of wet kitty litter. The Black & Decker does slightly better than the Dyson, which sails through the flour test but has trouble with the litter. The KONE does poorly on both tests, blowing the flour around and barely picking up any kitty litter at all.

expand

collapse

4. The Wall Street Journal
Nov. 23, 2007
No Crumbs for Christmas
by Charles Passy
Our Assessment

While the testing for this article is informal -- a mixture including potato chip crumbs and wrapping paper bits is scattered and then vacuumed up with five popular hand vacuums -- the author does a good job of justifying his picks. Like other reviewers, he finds the Dirt Devil KURV to be more style than substance and the Dyson DC16 to be less effective than its high price would suggest. While the Black & Decker 18 Volt Pivot Vac does relatively well here, the top choice is the inexpensive Shark Cordless Hand Vac SV736.

expand

collapse

5. Amazon.com
Not Dated
Handheld Vacuums
by Contributors to Amazon.com
Our Assessment

Amazon.com is a good source of owner-written hand vacuum reviews. Dozens of models are reviewed here, and while a few have only one or two posts, most have enough to provide a useful picture of how the products stands up in real-world use. Black & Decker models do well on Amazon.com, but the top score on a current model goes to the Eureka QuickUp 71B corded hand vac, which has been reviewed more than 400 times.

expand

collapse

6. Which? magazine
Feb. 18, 2008
Dyson DC16
by Editors of Which? magazine
Our Assessment

Which? magazine is a consumer advocacy resource based in the U.K. Like Consumer Reports, it has an excellent reputation for comparative reviews of consumer products based on controlled independent testing. Coverage of handheld vacuums is limited, though; editors test only the Dyson DC16. Both the standard DC16 and the DC16 Issey Miyake Limited Edition perform well, but because there are no other handhelds to compare them with, editors have chosen not to include ratings in their review.

expand

collapse

Hand Vacs
by Editors of Good Housekeeping
Our Assessment In this short video report, editors identify three "standout" handheld vacuum cleaners. Unfortunately, editors fail to disclose how many other vacuums were tested. And since the report is not dated, it's impossible to tell whether editors considered any newer models before highlighting the Black & Decker Dustbuster Cordless, the Dirt Devil Scorpion and the Filter Queen Dirt Tamer wet/dry hand vac.
8. ConsumerGuide.com
Not Dated
Hand Vacuums Reviews and Prices
by Editors of ConsumerGuide.com
Our Assessment Consumer Guide has what it calls "expert reviews" for eight handheld vacuum cleaners. Reviews are fairly detailed but seem to be based more on features and product specs than any kind of testing or analysis. Most models reviewed are given a CG Best Buy rating, and five of those also get a five-star rating, but there's no real explanation of how or why these are chosen.
Hand Held Cordless Vacuum Cleaners
by Editors of AllergyBuyersClub.com
Our Assessment This online retailer is geared toward allergy sufferers and includes allergy information and product reviews. Although editors say they test everything they sell, there's no detailed breakdown of how vacuum cleaner testing is conducted or what differentiates models that make the cut from those that don't.
10. Wired.com
Jan. 23, 2007
Review: Dyson Root 6 Handheld Vacuum
by Danny Dumas and Erika Stalder
Our Assessment This short review of the Dyson Root 6 deems the popular hand vac "a serious sucking machine." Dumas liked the HEPA filter and dustbin, which were simple to keep clean, as well as the powerful suction. Cons include the power button that must be held down, the price and the "pathetic battery life." No other hand vacuums are tested.
11. SlipperyBrick.com
Nov. 20, 2007
Review: Kone & Kurv Dirt Devil Hand Vacs
by Conner Flynn
Our Assessment This review of Dirt Devil's KONE and KURV uses the author's informal testing as a basis of comparison. There's little indication of how testing was conducted, but it is interesting that the author finds the KURV to be far more effective than the KONE.
12. Epinions.com
Not Dated
Vacuums - Handheld
by Contributors to Epinions.com
Our Assessment

Epinions.com has the advantage of being primarily a user-review site rather than an online retailer, meaning there's potentially a wider range of products that can be reviewed. Despite their attempts to get more people posting, though, Epinions.com still doesn't come close to Amazon.com's coverage in most categories. Hand vacuums are no exception -- the vast majority of models have a single review, if any. Although posts here are often thorough and nicely detailed, that's not enough to make up for the lack of volume.

expand

collapse

13. Target.com
Not Dated
Hand Vacs
by Contributors to Target.com
Our Assessment

Target is another online retailer that allows owners to post product reviews. There are around 20 models reviewed here -- far fewer than on Amazon.com -- and most of these get only a handful of posts. Because there is some disparity between user ratings on different sites, it can be useful to check out Target before making a decision. The Dirt Devil KURV, for example, does surprisingly well on Amazon.com, but its very poor scores on Target are more in keeping with test results in professional reviews.

expand

collapse

14. Viewpoints.com
Not Dated
Vacuum Reviews
by Contributors to Viewpoints.com
Our Assessment

At Viewpoints.com, owners post reviews of products. There are a few reviews here for hand vacs and for the hand/stick vac the Electrolux Ergorapido in the stick vac category. It can be misleading to search by category, as a hand vac like the Bissell Pet Hair Eraser is listed under the general vacuums category and doesn't come up when you go to the hand vac category. You might wish to search by product name when looking for reviews on Viewpoints, and check it out when you already have an idea of which models you're considering.

expand

collapse

15. The Toronto Star
Jan. 7, 2008
Handheld Vacuum Cleans in Design Department
by Robert Cribb
Our Assessment In this short article, the author discusses the Dyson DC16 Issey Miyake. Testing is informal; the author compares the DC16 in use against his own Dustbuster. His verdict is that the DC16 works well, but probably not well enough to justify the large price difference between it and other handheld vacs.
16. Calgary Herald
Dec. 22, 2007
Mini Tried & Tested: The Dirt Devil Kurv
by Editors of Calgary Herald
Our Assessment Another short review of a single hand vac, this article focuses on the Dirt Devil KURV. While it's short on specifics and doesn't describe the testing process, it does come up with some pros and cons. The biggest con: Pet owners might need to look elsewhere for a hand vac that can tackle pet hair on carpet.
17. Apartment Therapy.com
Apr. 3, 2008
Best Product: Electrolux Ergorapido 2-in-1 Sweeper
by Gregory Han
Our Assessment

After three days of testing, this reviewer proclaims the Ergorapido "best hard floor vacuum for pet owners." He likes its ergonomic design, the cleverness of the hand vac that snaps into the stick, the rugged and tight finish and especially the excellent performance. He notes that it's for hard floors and low-pile carpet, and that although there's a HEPA filter, the unit itself leaks air considerably. No other handheld vacuums are rated or ranked.

expand

collapse

18. Housekeeping Channel.com
Not Dated
Review: Dyson DC16 Root 6
by HC Staff
Our Assessment Although testers here don't directly test the Dyson DC16 against other cordless vacs, they do test its performance, durability and ease of use and comment in detail on them. Like other reviews, they find the DC16's battery life to be pathetic. Editors give it praise for durability and performance.
19. Housekeeping Channel.com
Not Dated
Review: FilterStream DirtTamer Supreme V2400
by Theresa Peterson
Our Assessment Peterson, a professional housecleaner, reviews the DirtTamer, which has a HEPA filter and comes with three attachments. Pros include a 15-20 minute battery life, wet or dry pickup and powerful suction. The only negative noted is that the unit is a bit on the heavy side.
20. Apartment Therapy.com
Nov. 19, 2007
Dyson Root 6 in the Test Lab
by Editors of Apartment Therapy
Our Assessment This brief review of the Dyson DC16 doesn't go into detail about what type of testing was performed, but it does give a short list of pros and cons. Their final verdict: "People love or hate Dyson."

Back to top