Page: 7 of 7
Headphones: Ratings of Sources
Total of 21 Sources
1. CNET
April 10, 2009
Best 5 Headphones
by Jasmine France
Our Assessment

CNET's Jasmine France lists her five top choices of headphones of various types; the list hasn't changed much since it was last updated in fall 2008. Reviews on CNET have good uniformity of testing, with comparisons often made with other models. Bose QuietComfort 3 are the top noise-canceling choice. Koss PortaPro headphones are a reasonably priced portable set. Separate lists are maintained for top choices among various types of headphones, including full-size headphones, noise-canceling headphones and more.

expand

collapse

2. Which? (UK)
Headphones
by Editors of Which?
Our Assessment This British consumer advocacy magazine and website rates 79 sets of headphones, choosing 12 as Best Buys. Its listening panel rates sound quality, sound leakage, comfort, fit, ease of use and noise-canceling abilities (if applicable). Bose QuietComfort 2 and Denon AH-D1001 headphones both get high scores.
How to Buy the Right Headphones
by Tim Gideon
Our Assessment

This buying guide describes different types of headphones and earphones and offers general advice; links to individual reviews are included. Review quality has improved over the years, and most reviews from the last few years compare models with others. The Sennheiser HD 650 headphones win the Editors' Choice award for full-size headphones. For noise-canceling headphones, the Bose QuietComfort 2 and Creative Aurvana X-Fi are Editors' Choice recipients.

expand

collapse

4. GoodGearGuide.com
Mar. 18, 2009
Top 5 Headphones
by David Ramli
Our Assessment

Good Gear Guide lists its top five headphones by category, with links to full reviews. The AKG K701 headphones are named best open headphones; the Sony MDR NC500D, the best noise-canceling headphones; the AKG K272HD, the best closed headphones; and the very expensive Sennheiser HD 800 the best overall. Not included in this roundup is a top-rated model, the Koss KSC75, which gets five stars elsewhere on the site for "jaw dropping sound for the price" and comfort.

expand

collapse

iPod Guide -- Headphones
by Dan Frakes
Our Assessment Macworld keeps a running list of headphones, with ratings and links to full reviews. Comparisons are frequently made, but sometimes you have to search to find the Editors' Choice picks as they're not marked on the ratings page. The Grado SR60 headphones outperform other full-size headphones. The site could be more up to date, as the latest review is from mid-2008.
Reviews: Headphones and earphones
by Editors of iLounge.com
Our Assessment

iLounge.com reviews iPod and iPhone accessories, including headphones and earphones. Write-ups done by Editor-in-Chief Jeremy Horwitz are detailed, though some older reviews are less so, and site navigation is tedious at times. It's especially difficult to find the most recent reviews by category. Reviewers take looks and sound quality into consideration. Several models get an "A" rating, including the AKG K701 for sound quality and comfort.

expand

collapse

Headphones Reviews and Headphone Best Buys
by Editors of What Hi-Fi?
Our Assessment British audio enthusiast magazine What Hi-Fi? has up-to-date reviews of many types of audio equipment, including headphones. Reviews are of varying length but are generally brief and undated. A Best Buys section lists top models in various categories of headphones, although little evidence aside from star ratings is given for why the recommended models are the best.
Headphone Reviews
by Editors of Laptop magazine
Our Assessment Review quality on this site, which specializes in mobile devices, is uneven. Reviews prior to 2007 aren't given the same full treatment as newer reviews. The headphone reviews category lists only 13 models, but you'll find older reviews if you search by model name. The Bose QuietComfort 2 gets an Editors' Choice award for comfort, clear sound and ability to actively block out ambient noise.
9. Choice.com.au
May 2008
Test: Noise Canceling Headphones
by Editors of Choice
Our Assessment

Similar to ConsumerReports.org in the U.S., this Australian site rigorously tests 15 noise-canceling headphones. Editors give scores for comfort, ease of use, passive and active noise cancelation, and sound quality. Unfortunately, the editors' two top choices have been discontinued, but both the Bose QuietComfort 2 and QuietComfort 3 are comfortable and perform well with active noise reduction. Testers frown on their prices, though.

expand

collapse

10. Consumer magazine
Feb. 1, 2009
Noise Canceling Headphones
by Editors of Consumer magazine
Our Assessment

This New Zealand-based consumer site tests 12 noise-canceling headphones under controlled conditions. Editors evaluate noise-cancelation ability, sound quality, comfort and ease of use. Testing is well documented, and there is a helpful description of how noise-canceling technology works; reviews are brief. The Bose QuietComfort 3 and QuietComfort 2 come in first and second place and are praised for their active noise reduction and audio quality, compared with models from Panasonic, Philips, Sennheiser and Sony. But Consumer doesn't like the Bose headphones' high prices.

expand

collapse

11. Amazon.com
As of May 2009
Over-the-Head Headphones
by Contributors to Amazon.com
Our Assessment Headphones are a popular item, and some models get hundreds of user reviews on Amazon.com. However, with so many headphone options and so many given top ratings, it's hard to say which set rises to the top. Still, this is a great place to spot complaints, such as persistent issues with comfort or build quality. It's also a good place to look for reviews on products with a lot of press hype.
Headphones
by Contributors to AudioReview.com
Our Assessment This website, which is popular among audiophiles, invites user ratings. Older headphone models receive more reviews, but top picks change frequently here as more reviews are added. Some reviews are more helpful than others, especially those that include comparisons with other models. Users here often echo pros and cons discussed at Amazon.com.
13. Tech2.com
April 17, 2008
Sennheiser vs. Bose: War of the Gods
by Siddharth Bhatia and Laiq Qureshi
Our Assessment

This Indian technology news and reviews site compares two popular noise-canceling headphones, the Sennheiser PXC 350 and the Bose QuietComfort 3. The reviewers prefer the Sennheiser for comfort, and they're impressed with its passive noise-isolating abilities, although active noise cancelation exerted pressure that felt "weird." They admit that the QuietComfort 3 headphones give good, though not perfect, noise cancelation.

expand

collapse

Review of the 10 Best Headphones
by Editors of HiFi Headphones
Our Assessment British headphones sellers HiFi Headphones list its top 10 in-ear, on-ear and hi-fi (audiophile) headphones, with three or four models recommended in each category. Reviews of each model are only a few paragraphs, but they situate each model well with respect to the competition.
15. ConsumerReports.org
Headphones
by Editors of ConsumerReports.org
Our Assessment ConsumerReports.org covers headphones in two categories, stereo headphones and noise-canceling headphones, though some earphones are mixed in too. Ratings evaluate sound quality, sensitivity, and, in the case of noise-canceling models, isolation. There's scant explanation of the headphone models themselves.
Headphone Reviews
by Editors of OnHeadphones.com
Our Assessment

This online magazine gives ratings with pros, cons and a bottom line. Editors' Choice designations don't appear on summary pages; you have to pull up the full review to know if a model got picked. Editors are impressed with the AKG K701's level of detail and the Sennheiser HD 650's bass response. They love the Grado SR60 for its value. The site does not seem to have been updated since December 2007.

expand

collapse

Headphone Recommendations
by Bill Keyser
Our Assessment

Bill Keyser sells headphones and has a clear bias toward the Grado brand. However, he provides multiple comparisons, which can be helpful when choosing between models. The Grado SR60 and SR80 are touted all over the site as his favorite value headphones, though he prefers the SR80 for its stronger bass response. For budget portables, Koss PortaPro headphones are recommended over the Sennheiser PX 100, mainly because of comfort. It doesn't appear that new reviews have been added since our last update.

expand

collapse

Headphone Recommendations
by Users of HeadphoneReviews.org
Our Assessment HeadphoneReviews.org is an audiophile review site, with users submitting write-ups and ratings on a scale of one to 10 in various categories. Recommendations are given for each category of headphones, but these are sometimes based on just one review, and without more comparative testing, it is difficult to tell which models are better despite the rankings.
19. HeadRoom
HeadRoom's Top Ten Headphones
by Editors of HeadRoom
Our Assessment

Although HeadRoom only rates headphones it sells, editors give useful overviews based on technical testing (though they tend to push other products they sell like amplifiers and cables). They're impressed with the detail of the new AKG K702 headphones and the Denon AH-D1001K and AH-D2000, though the Sennheiser HD 650 also gets a five-star rating for sound quality. The Sennheiser PX 100 and Grado SR60i are also recommended because they offer great value for quality listening.

expand

collapse

20. Head-Fi.org
Feb. 18, 2009
Intro and Compare/Contrast to the Grado SR60i and Denon AHD1001
by "fjrabon"
Our Assessment Head-Fi has forums where users can post their opinions of headphones. Here, user "fjrabon" compares the Grado SR60is with Denon's AHD1001 closed-style headphones. While he likes both models, he prefers the Grados, finding that listening to them is a "jaw-dropping experience."
21. PC Today
May 2008
Less Noise, More Solitude: Travel-friendly Earbuds and Headphones
by Blaine Flamig
Our Assessment This article focuses on travel-friendly headphones and covers five models. Unfortunately, Flamig doesn't pick a favorite and simply highlights the headphones' strong and weak points. Four of the five models are earbuds; only the Yamaha RH10MS is a full-size set of over-the-ear headphones.

Back to top