Page: 6 of 6
Home Theater Systems: Ratings of Sources
Total of 14 Sources
1. CNET
Oct. 7, 2009
Best home theater systems
by John P. Falcone and Editors of CNET
Our Assessment

CNET is continually reviewing and rating home theater systems. In addition to an overall rating, subratings are provided for design, features and performance. Writeups are not particularly long but cover all the important points. The Onkyo HT-S9100THX is singled out for offering the best sound of any all-in-one system the site has tested. The Samsung HT-BD1250 is the best system with a built-in Blu-ray player. The Onkyo HT-S3200 lacks some features, but delivers solid sound quality at a bargain price.

expand

collapse

2. ConsumerReports.org
Not Dated
Home Theater Systems
by Editors of ConsumerReports.org
Our Assessment ConsumerReports.org rates 15 home theater systems. Systems with and without a DVD player are covered, as are systems that include a Blu-ray player. Testing is done, and ratings are clear and easy to understand, but discussion is too short to be satisfactory.
Home Theater in a Box Reviews
by Editors of Home Theater magazine
Our Assessment

Although Home Theater magazine defines home theater systems rather broadly, including a wide variety of Dolby 2.1, tabletop and virtual surround systems in its coverage, it also reports on more traditional setups. Among those, the Onkyo HT-S9100THX is singled out for Top Pick recognition for delivering sound that exceeds its price tag. The Yamaha YHT-591 gets a less enthusiastic recommendation, but it is said to deliver what's expected of it. Coverage is well-detailed and backed by extensive testing.

expand

collapse

4. Big Picture Big Sound.com
As of Oct. 2009
Home Theater in a Box Reviews
by Editors of BigPictureBigSound.com
Our Assessment Though the reviews here aren't quite as long as some at other sites, discussion is more than sufficient and testing is reasonable and well-explained. Though no "best" home theater system is named, a star rating is provided, and opinions are offered. Among current HTIBs, the Blu-ray-equipped Panasonic SC-BT200 is praised for its video and audio prowess.
5. HomeTheaterInABoxReview.com
As of Oct. 2009
Reviews
by "Thomas S"
Our Assessment

Despite this site's title, there aren't a ton of reviews of home theater in a box systems here, though the few that we found are a good read. No serious bench testing is done, but systems are put through their paces in a way that closely resembles what a user would experience. A star rating is provided, but it is fairly meaningless given the few reviews posted. One home theater system, the Yamaha YTH-591, is liked well enough to be named the site's Editor's Choice. for those on a tight budget, the JVC TH-G41 "easily outperforms generic units found at big box and department stores."

expand

collapse

Latest Tests & Reviews
by Editors of Sound & Vision magazine
Our Assessment

Sound & Vision offers balanced reviews backed by solid testing, but it rarely reports on complete home theater systems, preferring to focus on more upscale audio and video gear. Michael Trei is impressed with the Panasonic SC-BT300. He says that although music performance is not a strength, it is not terrible, and sound quality with movies is first rate. The Blu-ray player included in the system is also solid in most regards. Value, considering performance, is well complimented.

expand

collapse

7. What Hi-Fi?
As of Oct. 2009
Home Cinema in a Box
by Editors of What Hi-Fi
Our Assessment Reviews at this British site are not exceptionally detailed, but they leave no doubt about pluses and minuses. Ratings are provided, and there's enough spread among them to clearly spot editors' favorites. The Blu-ray equipped Panasonic SC-BT200 is singled out for providing "fantastic images and incredible sound."
8. G4tv.com
July 21, 2009
Sony HT-SS360 Home Theater System Review
by Moye Ishimoto
Our Assessment The Sony HT-SS360 is reviewed on G4's "Attack of the Show" TV program. Although no serious testing is done, the home theater system is put through it paces in this video review and pluses and minuses are fairly well-detailed. Overall, the HTIB gets a thumbs-up from the reviewer and receives a rating of 4.5 out of five "Seals of Approval."
9. AVSForum.com
As of Oct. 2009
Home Theater in a Box
by Contributors to AVSForum.com
Our Assessment Although the Home Theater in a Box subforum at AVSForum.com is not as busy as some, you'll still find lots of discussions about HTIB systems. Threads contain user-to-user help, specific recommendations and informal reviews.
10. BestBuy.com
As of Oct. 2009
Home Theater Systems
by Contributors to BestBuy.com
Our Assessment

BestBuy.com is a good destination to read user reviews of home theater systems. Though write ups aren't very long, we like the inclusion of a bottom-line opinion about whether or not the reviewer would recommend the system to a friend Although some home theater systems, such as Sony's DAV-HDX589W and HT-SS360, or LG's LHB953, accumulate enough reviews and a high enough rating to jump out as a favored choice by reviewers here, it is easier to spot some home theater receivers that have clearly disappointed their owners.

expand

collapse

11. About.com
Not Dated
Top 16 Home Theater-In-A-Box Systems
by Robert Silva
Our Assessment

The reviews here are a mixed bag. Some are no longer than a paragraph, and others offer a fair amount of detail. Most center on features and manufacturer-supplied data, but a few include some serious testing. If nothing else, this listing by Robert Silva, About.com's guide to home theater, is worth a look for an overview of available HTIBs, though some discontinued models are included. (Note that ConsumerSearch is owned by About.com, but the two don't share an editorial affiliation.)

expand

collapse

12. Amazon.com
As of Oct. 2009
Home Theater Reviews
by Contributors to Amazon.com
Our Assessment

Amazon.com lets customers report on their post-sale experiences with their home theater systems. The site has some unusual and useful tools, like a box comparing the most helpful positive and negative reviews. Although the number of reviews each HTIB has received is posted on the main landing page, many discontinued HTIBs are listed, as well as speaker systems without a receiver or DVD player, making it a chore to sort through all of the options.

expand

collapse

13. Walmart.com
As of Oct. 2009
Home Theater System Reviews
by Contributors to Walmart.com
Our Assessment

Walmart.com might not be the first place you think of when it comes to buying a home theater system, but the site lists more than 30 models, including more inexpensive ones than most other retailers. Bargain-basement HTIBs fare about as well as expected for the most part, drawing mixed to awful ratings after lots of reviews. One notable exception is the Philips HTS3011/37, an older but still available home theater system that does surprisingly well with its owners -- at least those who keep their expectations reasonable.

expand

collapse

14. Epinions.com
As of Oct. 2009
Home Theater Systems
by Contributors to Epinions.com
Our Assessment The consumer-written reviews at Epinions.com are often longer and more insightful than those at BestBuy.com and similar retailer sites. However, the Epinions.com gets far less traffic, and most current-model home theater systems have a handful or no reviews. As with Amazon.com, discontinued home theater in a box systems are mixed into the listings, making navigation tedious.

Back to top