I just received my H Duo-I tonight, and I'm beyond impressed. I'll update this review after a few months, but felt compelled to rate this incredible product right now. I'm not getting into technical… details, because many have done that already. I will, however, tell you why I chose the Boston device over the others.
1) SOUND: I took my iPod Nano with me to several chain retail stores when shopping for my alarm clock/iPod system, plugged it in those systems, listened to several songs in various genres to test them out. I highly recommend doing this; it gives you a sense of how (crappy) the others compare to this system. I'd say the Altec Lansing M402SR Moondance Glow Speaker System with Clock Radio, Snooze Remote, and iPod Dock (Black) was the only device remotely close at this price point --and by "remotely," I mean it was barely in the same galaxy. The Lansing had a tinnier sound. The Boston has a rich, full sound and is very customizable. I tune mine to 0 bass and 0 treble (range is -5 to 5), which is perfect (has some serious kick at these settings, trust me!).
2) AESTHETICS: The Lansing, which I'll use for comparison again, wasn't nearly as nice-looking. I loved having the choice of a white finish, which is what I purchased. And I can still get another grill color (the array is pretty extensive; see BA's site) for around $15, if I wish. The blue-background, white-character display looks better than the drab black-background, orange-character display, in my opinion. It's less 'geeky,' softer, more sophisticated. The knobs look old-school, but trust me, it's worth the aesthetic sacrifice. Personally, I think it adds a bit of retro to the room, and retro happens to be considered the new 'modern.' ;-) My home is designed 'modernly,' so it fits in perfectly. The device is relatively large, but EASILY fits on a nightstand with a lamp. For the record, I have room for a book on the nightstand.
3) FUNCTIONALITY: The controls on the Lansing were more difficult to navigate than the Boston. They're more separated, disjointed, maybe? Back to the big retro knobs: They serve a functional purpose that you'll appreciate. Simply put, they make navigation intuitive; you'll learn how to navigate the device in ten or less minutes. The left knob does pretty much everything: just turn it and navigate, and then push to select. You'll get used to it very quickly. The remote is limited in functionality, but if you use it just to flip through songs and from iPod to FM/AM radio, then it's sufficient. The remote has a pretty good range, too, from 10 feet at least when pointing right at the device.
The snooze functionality (10 minute increments) for the alarm is fantastic, just be very careful not to tap the snooze bar (which is very sensitive and wraps around the entire system's perimeter) twice quickly in succession. This will increase the amount of snooze time. Also, if you turn a knob while in snooze mode, it appears to shut snooze off entirely. The intent is to tap once to snooze, tap again (not immediately in succession!) within the snooze duration to see how much time is left, or increase the snooze duration by tapping at least twice quickly in succession. I've tested it and I think I'll be fine, but I'm setting my phone alarm just to make sure (just like I would with any new alarm clock, to be honest).
I'd love to see the artist/track name on the display, but I can live without it. Maybe in a future version you can see this information, and even flip through artists and albums instead of merely tracks.
4) SMELL, HEAT, ETC.: There was a faint, very faint, plasticky smell to my unit. It reminds me vaguely of chlorine and is only noticeable up close. Did I mention the smell is VERY FAINT? ;-) There is a warm --not hot-- spot in the center of the device, like touching the forehead of someone with the flu. Others have mentioned this heat, and it's true, it does exist, like anything else that emits power. Note that I've had the device playing for around 3 hours straight, and I can still hold it on the palm of a hand without burning --not even close to burning, per se, more of a warm feeling. I don't expect it to damage my nightstand, but I'll revisit this in a few months in my update.
I'm not a Boston Acoustics sales tool. See some of my other reviews and you'll see that I'm a relatively normal human being.
10/7/2009 UPDATE:
I've had this puppy playing for about 5 hours now, and the heat on the bottom is definitely noticeable --certainly above 'warm'. I've had the bass tuned to the minimum -5 level. It's still able to be held in my palm for a considerable duration without pain, but it's definitely tending toward the hot side of 'warm.' I still don't think it's nearly enough to ever damage the surface of my nightstand, but we'll see...
expand
collapse