Page: 9 of 9
LCD Monitors: Ratings of Sources
Total of 32 Sources

For an explanation of how we rank reviews, see our ratings criteria page.

1. TFT Central
As of Dec. 2008
TFT Central Reviews
by Simon Baker
Our Assessment

TFT Central is a British website with excellent professional reviews of monitors and display accessories. Testing and documentation are exceptional but could be a little too technical for some readers. All aspects of usage are evaluated, including office use, which few other reviewers adequately address. Balance and objectivity are very good. TFT Central does not rank or rate monitors, but a TFT selector wizard somewhat accomplishes that purpose and guides consumers to the best product based on their needs, using simple terminology. The best monitors for gaming, professional use, general use and value are reasonably easy to identify. One negative is that not all of the monitors covered are available in the U.S.

expand

collapse

Bigger, Better, Cheaper
by John Breeden
Our Assessment

GCN's John Breeden reviews seven LCD monitors of various sizes. Testing is objective and more relevant than any other review source except TFT Central. Thorough testing of text quality is unmatched, and Breeden looks at multiple fonts. Brightness uniformity is also a focus. Ratings are comparative in every regard. The Dell UltraSharp 2408WFP and Eizo FlexScan SX3031W are top-rated. Breeden also reports that monitors have improved in the year since the magazine's previous roundup.

expand

collapse

3. XBitLabs.com
Oct. 22, 2008
22" Monitors Roundup. Part III
by Oleg Artamonov
Our Assessment

X-bit, a prolific review site focusing on PC hardware, offers unmatched lab testing as well as thorough documentation of its testing processes. The results can be challenging to decipher, though, because of awkward English (the editors are from Russia), overly technical description and use of advanced terminology. In this roundup, five 22-inch widescreen monitors are directly compared. This article follows two previous roundups of LCD monitors that compared 12 and seven monitors, respectively. The Samsung SyncMaster 225MW and Samsung SyncMaster 2243BW are top-rated in this article.

expand

collapse

4. XBitLabs.com
July 15, 2008
19" LCD Monitors Roundup. Part X: Widescreen Models
by Aleksey Meyev
Our Assessment

X-bit Labs reviews more 19-inch monitors than anyone else. Ten widescreen LCD monitors are compared here, and there are two other roundups covering regular and budget models (see below). Previous articles published within the past 18 months cover an additional 42 monitors. In general, Meyev is most impressed with Samsung LCD monitors. He says that the few 19-inch monitors with some type of PVA display are definitely better than the TN-based models but are more expensive. One weakness is that the best LCD monitors in each roundup aren't compared with those from previous roundups.

expand

collapse

5. XBitLabs.com
Aug. 12, 2008
19" LCD Monitors Roundup. Part XI
by Aleksey Meyev
Our Assessment Eight 19-inch LCD monitors are compared in this X-bit Labs roundup. Meyev singles out the Viewsonic VX1940W for its resolution and response-time compensation. He recommends the NEC MultiSync for work and the LG Flatron models for gamers.
6. XBitLabs.com
Aug. 26, 2008
19" LCD Monitors Roundup. Part XII: Budget Models
by Aleksey Meyev
Our Assessment

X-bit Labs reviews nine inexpensive LCD monitors in this article. Aleksey Meyev recommends the Samsung SyncMaster 943N as a good choice for home or office. He also notes that models from Asus -- the VW198S and VW195U -- are good products. Curiously, Meyev finds budget monitors by ViewSonic and LG unsatisfactory here, although the companies' other models fared well in X-bit Labs' 19-inch LCD roundups listed above.

expand

collapse

7. XBitLabs.com
June 13, 2008
20" LCD Monitors Roundup. Part VI
by Oleg Artamonov
Our Assessment

X-bit Labs compares nine conventional and widescreen monitors in its most recent 20-inch monitor roundup. Artamonov's previous roundup, published in December 2007, is still valid and helpful. It covers nine additional monitors that are still available. Artamonov is indecisive in this latest review, although he singles out monitors from Samsung for praise and those from NEC and ViewSonic for rebuke.

expand

collapse

8. PC World
Jan. 3, 2008
Top 5 20- and 22-Inch Wide-Screen Monitors
by Danny Allen
Our Assessment Five LCD displays are ranked by PC World editors, with links to individual reviews and lab test information for each model. Comparisons in the chart are based on testing scores, as no mention of competing models is made in the reviews themselves.
9. PC World
June 4, 2008
Top 5 23- and 24-Inch Wide-Screen Monitors
by Greg Adler
Our Assessment Five midsized LCD displays are ranked by PC World editors, with links to individual reviews and lab test information for each model. Monitors from Gateway, Dell and Samsung top the chart.
10. XBitLabs.com
Apr. 28, 2008
24" LCD Monitors Roundup. Part II
by Oleg Artamonov
Our Assessment

X-bit Labs tests six 24-inch monitors in this roundup. Eight additional 23- and 24-inch monitors were tested for Part I, which was published in October 2007. As is the case with other size monitors, models with S-IPS or PVA displays outperform those with TN displays. Though explicit recommendations are not made, specific monitors emerge as equally worth buying, and Artamonov explains the disadvantages of each in ways that should make one model stand out based on a consumer's specific needs. As always, X-bit Labs' measurements of response time, color accuracy, viewing angles and contrast ratio are exceptional.

expand

collapse

11. Bit-tech.net
As of Dec. 2008
Hardware -- Monitors
by Editors of Bit-Tech.net
Our Assessment

U.K. hardware-review and PC-modification site Bit-Tech.net provides excellent reviews with one significant weakness: The site is oriented to gamers (as are ratings), and text quality is largely ignored. Otherwise, LCD monitor reviews are exceptionally substantive. Testing is terrific and visual documentation is revealing, although the conversational tone and Britishisms occasionally mar the clarity of reviews.

expand

collapse

12. PC World
Dec. 31, 2007
The Wide World of Monitors
by Danny Allen
Our Assessment

For this older feature, PC World brought in a panel of independent viewers to compare 17 LCD monitors side-by-side with brand names obscured. Each monitor is tested and ranked in a comparison chart with others that have the same resolution. One monitor in each size group is selected as a Best Buy. Testing is not comprehensive, but the blind test procedure is impeccable. In the test reports, each LCD monitor receives scores for text quality and graphics quality.

expand

collapse

13. PCMag.com
As of Dec. 2008
Liquid Crystal Displays Reviews
by John Delaney
Our Assessment PC Magazine is a prolific reviewer of LCD monitors, but the reviews concentrate on entertainment performance and features. Unlike the best reviewers, PC Magazine doesn't reveal the actual panel model or even the type of panel used. Otherwise, the LCD monitor reviews are very good and based on sufficient testing. The Dell UltraSharp 2408 WFP and Lenovo ThinkVision L220x are recent Editors' Choices.
14. Which? magazine
Feb. 2008
PC monitors
by Editors of Which?
Our Assessment

British consumer magazine Which? independently reviews and compares 30 LCD monitors. Some are not available in the U.S., however. Four models are honored as Best Buys, including two sold in the U.S. Ratings charts for each monitor include subcategory ratings for picture quality, screen speed, viewing angle, ease of use, versatility and environmental considerations. Image quality is underrated in the overall scores, and no delineation is made between text and video quality.

expand

collapse

15. MaximumPC.com
Sept. 5, 2008
The New Wave of LCDs
by David Murphy
Our Assessment Maximum PC regularly reviews LCD monitors, and in this article, Murphy goes over the intricacies of LCD technology and reviews 10 monitors. Reviews are short and mainly focused on features but are supported by testing and are well-balanced with occasional comparisons. This enthusiast magazine reviews several brands that are rarely covered elsewhere, such as Hanns-G and Planar.
16. HotHardware.com
As of Dec. 2008
Video Category Reviews
by Editors of HotHardware.com
Our Assessment HotHardware's reviews are among the best but suffer a few flaws. Testing is comprehensive and subjective analysis includes gaming, movies and general usage. The major limitations are the relatively small number of monitors covered, all of which are of 22 inches or larger. In addition, the quality of the reviews is inconsistent, and LCD monitor reviews are mixed in with other hardware.
17. Anandtech.com
May 1, 2008
24" LCD Roundup
by Jarre Walton
Our Assessment

AnandTech doesn't review a lot of LCD monitors, and it only reviews those with 22-inch and larger screen sizes. Given those limitations, however, the reviews are excellent and critical. This roundup concentrates solely on 24-inch LCDs, and it points out the difficulty of acquiring a wide range of models for testing even within such a relatively narrow category. The Dell 2408WFP is given overall high marks, while the Samsung 2493HM and Gateway FHD2400 are recommended for gamers.

expand

collapse

18. ConsumerReports.org
June 2008
Monitors
by Editors of Consumer Reports
Our Assessment Consumer Reports evaluates and rates 28 monitors ranging in size from 19 to 24 inches. A whopping 13 of them are selected as Quick Picks, which greatly waters down the recommendations. All but three models are rated to have very good image quality. The implication that all monitors are just about the same coupled with no explanation limits the value of this roundup review.
19. TrustedReviews.com
As of Dec. 2008
Display Reviews
by Riyad Emeran, Benny Har-Even, Ardjuna Seghers
Our Assessment

Reviews here are similar to PC Magazine's reviews, but there is less comparison. Testing and description are comprehensive, except too little attention is paid to text quality. Monitors are rated on a scale of one to 10 with subcategory ratings for design and features, image quality and value. Oversize LCD monitors receive the most review attention. Many of the reviewed monitors aren't sold in the U.S.

expand

collapse

20. Techtree.com
As of Dec. 2008
Monitor Reviews
by Unauthor
Our Assessment TechTree.com, an Indian site, regularly reviews monitors, most of which are available in the U.S. Reviews are comparative, balanced and supported by standard testing. Review conclusions and ratings make helpful distinctions between LCD monitors and guide readers to appropriate products, but text quality isn't adequately addressed.
21. Computer Shopper
As of Dec. 2008
LCD Monitors Reviews
by Les Shu, Bill O'Brien
Our Assessment Computer Shopper's strength is reviewing budget products that get too little attention elsewhere. Consumers who want a larger or better monitor will be better served by more substantive reviews from other sources.
22. ExtremeTech.com
As of Dec. 2008
22-inch LCD Monitor Roundup
by John Delaney
Our Assessment ExtremeTech reviews a handful of high-end monitors for gamers in its video section. This roundup is a rare comparative review of seven recent LCD models. Samsung scores well.
23. PCPro.co.uk
As of Dec. 2008
TFT Monitor Reviews
by Unauthor
Our Assessment PC Pro has regular reviews of LCD monitors. Reviews are relatively short and not comparative, although models are put in context with their competitors. Ratings are given on a scale of one to six.
24. Techgage.com
As of Dec. 2008
LCD Monitor Reviews
by Rob Williams, Matt Serrano
Our Assessment

Techgage has begun regularly reviewing monitors recently. The reviews, written by tech enthusiasts, attempt to be professional but fall short in too many regards. For example, no testing data is provided. And the site no longer assigns ratings to their display reviews, stating that some products "proved too difficult to be handed a simple score." In addition, it's difficult at first glance to distinguish some of the ads from editorial. Still, the reviews do have some significant virtues including good product comparisons and a non-technical writing style.

expand

collapse

25. CNet.com
As of Dec. 2008
LCD Monitor Reviews
by Editors of CNet.com
Our Assessment

CNet reviews an average of about one monitor per month. Published DisplayMate test results show other LCD monitors for comparison, but not all are direct competitors or even the same size. Lori Grunin says of the Dell 2707WFP, "Extended viewing may leave you feeling a bit woozy, as it did me." Yet the monitor is rated very good overall. The reviews are easy to read, but we didn't find them as useful as those from other reviewers.

expand

collapse

26. NewEgg.com
As of Dec. 2008
LCD Monitor Reviews
by Contributors to NewEgg.com
Our Assessment NewEgg.com lets customers post opinions about the monitors that they have purchased. The Hanns-G HW-191DPB has the most reviews and the highest average rating among the many monitors with hundreds of reviews. The Acer AL2223Wd and Samsung 2253BW top the 22-inch LCD monitors. Viewsonic is also a popular brand among Newegg users.
27. I4U News.com
As of Dec. 2008
Monitor Reviews
by Mark Raby, Shane McGlaun
Our Assessment I4UNews reviews tech products in a number of different categories. Here the editors report on five large monitors, but the reviews are short and relatively superficial. Testing is entirely subjective, although the real-world testing is more thorough than some others conduct. Because all the LCD monitors get similar high ratings, it's hard to tell which are considered to be best.
28. Tweaknews.net
As of Dec. 2008
Computer Monitor & Display Reviews
by Nathan Glentworth
Our Assessment

TweakNews only reviews Samsung and ViewSonic LCD monitors, which limits this site's usefulness. The reviews are well-intentioned and based on experience with LCD monitors, but Glentworth doesn't provide enough substantive information. Still, if you have settled on a Samsung or ViewSonic LCD monitor, this site is definitely worth checking as it contains a lot of product images and specification info.

expand

collapse

29. CircuitCity.com
As of Dec. 2008
Monitors: Flat-panel LCD Reviews
by Contributors to CircuitCity.com
Our Assessment

Monitors are one of the few technology products where customer impressions formed from use over time can be as valid as professional reviews. In general, it's worth checking CircuitCity.com once you've narrowed down your options. Top vendors are well represented, and visitors to the site can sort products by customer rating. The HP W1907 19-inch widescreen monitor has an average rating of 4.6 out of five based on 160 reviews, while the Samsung SyncMaster 2253BW has a 4.6 rating based on about 45 reviews.

expand

collapse

30. ConsumerGuide.com
As of Dec. 2008
Computer Monitor Reviews and Prices
by Editors of ConsumerGuide.com
Our Assessment ConsumerGuide reviews an average of about one monitor per month, but all get similar ratings. No formal testing is referenced, although image quality is usually briefly addressed.
31. Amazon.com
As of Dec. 2008
LCD -- Monitors & Projectors
by Contributors to Amazon.com
Our Assessment Amazon.com is a good source for customer reviews of many products -- but not of LCD monitors. Only a few LCD monitors receive more than 20 reviews, and average ratings are mostly similar. We found no consistency among user complaints with any monitor.
32. CADalyst.com
Apr. 1, 2008
Thin Is In (Cadalyst Labs Review)
by Ron LaFon
Our Assessment Cadalyst invited all the leading manufacturers to submit models, and three companies complied. But none of the models receive lower than a grade of "A," so there's no clear winner.

Back to top