Page: 5 of 5
Long Distance Phone Service: Ratings of Sources
Total of 13 Sources

For an explanation of how we rank reviews, see our ratings criteria page.

1. SaveOnPhone.com
As of Feb. 2009
Long Distance Rate Comparison Chart
by Editors of SaveOnPhone.com
Our Assessment SaveOnPhone.com's editors continuously research long-distance plans in order to offer ratings of the best plans. At our last check, the rate-comparison chart featured nearly 30 plans. The top five include ECG, Pioneer, 3U, TCI and Covista. 3U is recommended for international callers, and it gives you a special access number so you can get low international rates from your cell phone.
2. TollChaser.com
As of Feb. 2009
Continental State-to-State Long Distance Phone Rate Comparison Chart
by Editors of TollChaser.com
Our Assessment

Another online rate-comparison site, TollChaser offers a number of tools to analyze your phone bill, resolve a dispute and find the cheapest plans for your usage. This is the first site we saw that adds USF fees into the per-minute rate. For example, AireSpring Global Fibernet's advertised 2.85 cents per minute plan actually costs 3.23 cents per minute when fees are figured into the price. ECG's 2.5-cents-per-minute plan comes out to 2.77 cents when the monthly recovery fee is figured in. Plans from ECG, Pioneer and Unitel are top-rated here.

expand

collapse

3. Telcompare.com
As of Feb. 2009
Residential Long Distance
by Editors of Telcompare.com
Our Assessment Telcompare.com is similar to SaveOnPhone.com. However, while there are details about rates and fees for most companies, the ratings appear to be in no particular order. Some plans get a detailed review, while only basic information is given for others.
4. LongDistanceSmart.com
As of Feb. 2009
Best Residential Plans
by Editors of LongDistanceSmart.com
Our Assessment Like the other sites, LongDistanceSmart.com lists the cheapest plans by state. You can also filter results by entering your usage estimates. We appreciate the fact that in-state rates are easy to find. ECG, Pioneer and CogniState are often the top plans here.
5. PhoneRateFinder.com
As of Feb. 2009
Rate Comparison for State-to-State Calls
by Editors of PhoneRateFinder.com
Our Assessment

Yet another rate-comparison site, this one allows you to compare over 200 different plans including interstate, in-state, international and calling cards. There's also a calculator for researching in-state versus state-to-state call rates. We would have thought that all these sites would have similar charts. It's interesting when they don't really correspond. While most of these sites have similar entries, the order varies a lot. Several CogniState, CogniPhone, PNG and Covista plans occupy top spots here, along with Unitel and AmeriCom's Simplicity. Also included, for comparison sake, are mainstream plans from MCI, Verizon and AT&T. The site also offers to analyze your phone bill free of charge.

expand

collapse

6. Phonedog.com
As of Feb. 2009
Long Distance Plans
by Editors of Phonedog.com
Our Assessment

Phonedog.com's phone-service information site includes long-distance service comparisons. By entering your phone number, a list of long-distance providers and the best deals for your area code will appear with all the details such as fees, rates and savings. The site gives you the option to rank carriers by lowest in-state rate, lowest state-to-state rate or biggest yearly savings. Along with plan details and a brief editorial review, each plan is accompanied by extensive user ratings and comments.

expand

collapse

7. CyberScans.com
As of Feb. 2009
1 Plus Long Distance Services
by Editors of CyberScans.com
Our Assessment CogniState, Accxx Long Distance, Opex and Covista captured the top four "one-plus" slots as of our last visit. Providers are given ratings from one to five stars. Since there are no negative comments here, though, it's hard to tell whether these picks represent editors' recommendations, or are the result of paid product placement.
8. My Rate Plan
As of Feb. 2009
Long Distance
by Editors of MyRatePlan.com
Our Assessment

Editors of MyRatePlan.com suggest that if you are paying more than 4 cents per minute for long distance, you should do a little investigating. Rates can be calculated by entering the state, monthly usage in minutes and percentage of calls made in state. Pioneer, ECG and Big Red Wire were the best plans for several states. The site also includes discussions of long-distance options, the pros and cons of going wireless, etc.

expand

collapse

9. 1+ Call Saver
As of Feb. 2009
Best Bets: Residential
by Editors of 1+ Call Saver
Our Assessment

This site runs a regularly updated list of the top 32 residential long-distance plans. It seems to favor plans with no or very low monthly fees, even if the per-minute charges are a bit higher than other plans. ECG is in the top spot with its 2.75 cents plan (including fees). CogniState, TCI, Voice Revolution and 3U hold other top ratings on the chart. The site receives commissions from some of the companies listed but claims to be unbiased.

expand

collapse

10. The Digest
As of Feb. 2009
Long Distance Deals & Discounts
by Editors of TheDigest.com
Our Assessment

The Digest is a good source for telephone industry news and views. It also provides this chart of long-distance services that provides information on per-minute charges, minimum charges, fees, billing increments and billing methods. The chart requires you to enter your home state and the country you dial most often to get recommendations. Users can provide their own ratings, but at the time of our visit, most companies had not received much feedback.

expand

collapse

11. Calling-Plans.com
As of Feb. 2009
Top Ten Long Distance Calling Plans
by Editors of Calling-Plans.com
Our Assessment Based on 11 years of telecom experience, Calling-Plans.com lists their top plans by price per minute. The top ten all are less than 4 cents per minute. Billing increments, minimums and other fees are noted but not added into the calculations. The site also has a rate calculator to refine options.
12. Better Telephone Rates.com
As of Feb. 2009
Top Long Distance Plans
by Editors of BetterTelephoneRates.com
Our Assessment BetterTelephoneRates.com lists ECG, Pioneer, Covista and OPEX as their top four. Selections are based solely on interstate rate, monthly fee and billing increments of each company.
13. ConsumerReports.org
Apr. 2008
Phone Service: 5 Ways to Cut Bills
by Editors of Consumer Reports
Our Assessment This article doesn't rate phone companies in any way. Instead, it offers general advice about cutting costs, including bundling local and long-distance service, switching to a smaller carrier, using phone cards for long-distance calls and switching to VoIP. The pros and cons of various options are considered.

Back to top