Luggage Reviews

Editor's note:
If you have to go, you need to check out TravelPro. As this year's update makes clear, no other bag can match the proprietary "Magna" wheel technology on our two top carry-on picks. Best of all, the Platinum Magna line comes in a variety of sizes, so you can choose a suitcase for any need.
 
Travelpro Platinum Magna 21-Inch Expandable Spinner Suiter
Specs that Matter
Weight - 7.9 lbs. Capacity - 1,660 cu inSize (H,W,D) - 21" x 14" x 9"
Best Reviewed
Best carry-on spinner bag
Travelpro Platinum Magna 21-Inch Expandable Spinner Suiter

Experts say that Travelpro's "Magna" wheel technology has revolutionized spinner wheels. The proprietary magnetic wheel system keeps the spinner wheels aligned whether you're pushing, pulling or gliding the suitcase along beside you. Experts and users also praise the comfortable, contour grip handle and durable construction. There are six pieces in the Magna collection, but if your focus is on a top carry-on, reviewers say to go for the 21-inch Expandable Spinner Suiter. Best of all, the wheels can be easily replaced.
See our full review »

Travelpro Luggage Platinum Magna 22-Inch Expandable Rollaboard Suiter
Specs that Matter
Weight - 7.7 lbs. Capacity - 1,850 cu inSize (H,W,D) - 22" x 14" x 9"
Runner Up
Best rolling carry-on bag
Travelpro Luggage Platinum Magna 22-Inch Expandable Rollaboard Suiter

Many travelers prefer rolling bags with two fixed wheels. For them, experts recommend the Travelpro Platinum Magna 22 Inch Expandable Rollaboard Suiter. It's part of the same line as our Best Spinner Luggage selection, but with two sturdy wheels and a slightly larger capacity. These bags are reported as durable, well-balanced and comfortable to pull, and the 22-inch bag will fit in most overhead bins. As with its spinner sister, the wheels are easily replaceable, and the collection includes a wide range of sizes.

The North Face Base Camp Duffel
Specs that Matter
Weight - Varies by sizeCapacity - Varies by sizeSize - from XS to XXL
Best Reviewed
Best duffel bag
The North Face Base Camp Duffel

Durable and versatile, The North Face Base Camp Duffel is a standout choice in this category, whether you're jetting off for a weekend getaway at a spa, or going out backcountry camping for weeks on end. It comes in sizes ranging from extra-small to XXL, and a wide variety of colors -- from basic black to bright pink. It's virtually indestructible, experts and owners say, and easy to pack, carry and stow. The padded straps also earn raves for comfort.
See our full review »

image
The North Face Base Camp Duffel Bag TNF Black Size Large
Buy from Amazon.com
from Amazon.com
New: $144.95 $109.86   
In Stock.
Average Customer Review:  
SkyRoll Garment Bag
Specs that Matter
Weight - 5 lbs. Capacity - N/ASize (L,W) - 45" x 22" (unfolded)
Best Reviewed
Best garment bag
SkyRoll Garment Bag

Praised for its clever design and extreme portability, the SkyRoll Garment Bag promises to deliver your suit to your destination without a wrinkle or crease. You literally roll the SkyRoll into a tube and it holds a suit (or two), plus toiletries and other items. Rolled, it measures about 24 inches long, but fits into most overhead bins. Expert reviewers say it works well and is very easy to use, carry and stow. Business travelers are particularly enamored of this handy bag.
See our full review »

American Tourister Luggage Fieldbrook II 4 Piece Set
Specs that Matter
Weight - Varies by pieceCapacity - Varies by pieceSize - Varies by piece
Best Reviewed
Best luggage set
American Tourister Luggage Fieldbrook II 4 Piece Set

A great luggage set should include the essentials for any travel need, and the American Tourister Luggage Fieldbrook II 4 Piece Set does just that. It includes an under seat boarding bag, a 21-inch suitcase that will fit in most overhead compartments, a 23-inch wheeled duffel, and a larger, 25-inch bag to check for longer trips. Owners say this set features plenty of organizational options; although the bags are on the small side. This set also comes in a variety of color options.
See our full review »

Types of Luggage
Spinner Luggage

This is by far the most popular type. These wheels can spin 360 degrees, so bags can be smoothly scooted along beside you (as well as pulled behind you or pushed in front of you), which makes it easier to transport two suitcases. Spinner wheels used to get panned for durability as they had an annoying tendency to buckle and/or snap off, but manufacturers are solving that problem and spinner wheels are lighter and more durable than in the past.

Rolling Luggage

The original rolling luggage featured inline-skate-type wheels, also called fixed wheels or roller wheels. Many frequent fliers prefer these fixed wheels to spinner wheels, saying they're more stable, and make a suitcase lighter, roomier and easier to pull. This type of wheel also tends to be more durable.

Duffel Bags

These are a very popular option for travel -- and not just for outdoor adventurers. Many people love the roomy yet minimalist packing style that duffle bags allow, and appreciate the durability and the softer construction that helps them to fit in places where a traditional suitcase won't. We found duffel bags that are stylish and chic, as well as top choices for the backcountry hiker that will last a lifetime.

Garment Bags

Our increasingly casual world has made garment bags less common than they used to be, but there are still plenty of people -- male and female -- who need to take a suit or dress with them when they travel. While many suitcases have built-in options for handling dressy clothes without wrinkling or creasing them, none do it quite as well as a dedicated garment bag.

Luggage Sets

While many hard-core travelers eschew luggage sets, preferring instead to own a specific selection of bags for their various travel needs, luggage sets are still a great choice for those who either need to pack a lot of stuff and want their bags to match, or for less-frequent travelers who want to own a good variety of bags -- and want the discount that usually comes with buying them as a set.

A word about carry-on bags

The luggage world is pretty much divided into "carry-on" and "checked" bags. The reason is clear: many airlines charge $25 per bag and up (and way up in some cases for a second or, especially, third bag) to check it, so you can save some money if your bag fits into the overhead bin. "If" being the operative word. However, some airlines now even charge for carry-on bags, so you may not be able to avoid baggage fees unless you sign up for a dedicated travel card, which we cover in more detail in our buying guide.

In general, a carry-on bag should be no longer than about 21 or 22 inches; although a very few airlines will allow a bag as large as 24 inches in an overhead bin -- usually on longer flights with larger planes. Check the airlines' website for their carry-on size restrictions. And be aware that their "official" guideline may not apply to your particular flight. Study your ticket carefully, if it says your flight is "operated by" another airline that is "doing business as" (DBA) your airline, that means you are likely to be flying on a regional jet and your otherwise "regulation" bag may not fit in the overhead bin. If that's the case, the airline will generally gate-check it at no charge and you can pick it up in the jetway after you deplane.

What else you need to know about the world of luggage

Luggage is frequently discontinued and updated, almost as often as electronics are, but there are still names that are standouts in any iteration: Samsonite, Travelpro, Briggs & Riley, Victorinox, Delsey, The North Face, and American Tourister, to name just a few. Although we focus mostly on specific, individual bags in this report, keep in mind that all of these bags come in smaller and larger sizes as well, and have the same quality as the size we recommend. Don't hesitate to choose the size that best fits your needs. Just be aware that the bigger the bag, the less likely it can be used as a carry on.

We also have some bad news: If you travel frequently you will probably need to replace your luggage frequently. Travel is tough on your bags and even the best bags will fray, get beat up, the wheels will wear out and the zippers will stick or split. Even the cheapest suitcases usually come with a 10-year limited warranty, but good luck getting anything out of it. The list of restrictions is longer than a security line during the holidays. They don't cover normal wear and tear (and who defines "normal" anyway?), damage caused by the airlines (which is the cause of most luggage breakage), or most anything else that actually damages your bag. The only thing most do cover is manufacturing defects, but most warranties don't specify what that means. Also, the comments we see from those who do try to get their bags repaired is that it's a huge hassle. There are exceptions to this -- most notably Briggs & Riley who even cover damage caused by the airline -- but not many. Also, you'll need to hang on to your receipt. Many luggage manufacturers won't even talk to you about your broken bag without it.

You'll notice that we don't make any specific recommendations for "lightweight" luggage. That's because virtually all luggage made today is lightweight. Still, it's easy to make some mistakes when looking for bags that shave their weight down to the bare minimum, so be sure to take a look at what we have to say about that in our detailed discussion of lightweight luggage elsewhere in this report.

Finding The Best Luggage
Our Sources1. TheWirecutter.com
The Best Carry-On Luggage2. OutdoorGearLab.com
The Best Carry-On Luggage 3. Fodors.com
Fodor's Approved: Best Checked Luggage for 2015See All

The editors of ConsumerSearch are very experienced travelers, so we drew on our own knowledge to explain how airlines deal with baggage and offer some tips for how to avoid baggage fees. Then, for our specific luggage picks, we turned to the professional testers at sites like TheWirecutter.com, Fodor's, GoodHousekeeping.com and OutdoorGearLab.com. They put bags through their paces, sometimes for weeks, then report on durability and convenience. We also looked at roundups by travel experts at places like Forbes.com and SmarterTravel.com. They don't always test the bags, but they're knowledgeable about travel and the needs of various types of travelers. We also combed through hundreds of owner reviews at sites like Amazon.com and eBags.com to find out how all of these bags hold up under real world use.