2012 Toyota 4Runner

The Toyota 4Runner is renowned for its all-terrain prowess and rock-solid reliability, and remains an excellent choice if you need a midsize SUV that can take you off road. Most reviewers agree, however, that the 2012 Jeep Grand Cherokee (Base MSRP: $26,995 to $54,470), is better on the pavement and benefits from a more modern car-like design.

The 4Runner is an old-fashioned truck-based SUV, as opposed to most new midsize SUVs and crossovers. While this rugged construction is good for off-road applications and towing, it ultimately compromises on-road handling. Experts note that it's a bit clumsier on-road than much of the competition, with Edmunds.com editors stating that it "lacks the comfort, utility, and general convenience" you're bound to find in most family-friendly crossovers.

With a 270-horsepower 4.0-liter V6 and technology like hill descent control, available center and/or rear locking differentials and advanced traction control, the 4Runner is eminently capable when the going gets rough. Reviewers note that it accommodates a decent amount of cargo (90 cu. ft.) and that the option of a third-row seat is nice, even though space for rearmost passengers is relatively limited. A five-speed automatic transmission is standard, and non-4-by-4 4Runners have rear-wheel drive.

Most critics correctly point out that the majority of drivers are better suited with an all-wheel-drive crossover that offers better road manners, as most shoppers will never need the 4Runner's genuine off-road capability.

EPA Fuel Economy Estimates

V6 2WD: 17 mpg city / 23 mpg highway /19 mpg combined

V6 4WD: 17 mpg city / 22 mpg highway /19 mpg combined

Fuel economy estimates assume the use of regular-grade gasoline.

NHTSA Safety Ratings:

Front Impact: 4 stars

Side Impact: 5 stars

Rollover Resistance: 4 stars

Overall: 4 stars

IIHS Safety Ratings:

Front Offset Impact: Good

Side Impact: Good

Roof Strength: Acceptable

For additional details, see our 2010 review

The 4Runner hasn't changed much the last couple of years. For a deeper look at what reviewers have to say about it, read our report on the 2010 Toyota 4Runner.