Muffin pans are typically made from silicone or metal, especially aluminum, steel and cast iron. Aluminum is lightweight, inexpensive and conducts heat well, so it bakes muffins evenly. Some aluminum pans are put through an electrochemical process known as anodizing, which makes them harder as well as resistant to stains and sticking. The anodizing process also makes pans darker in color, so they absorb more heat than lighter pans and consequently tend to brown foods faster.

Steel is strong and durable, although it tends to cost more than aluminum. Stainless steel -- a category that consists of steel alloys -- is typically coated or layered with another metal, such as aluminum, tin or copper, to improve heat conductivity. Cast-iron muffin pans are a traditional choice, but cast iron is heavy and can be expensive. It also needs to be cared for carefully, to prevent it from rusting.

In tests of muffin tins and pans, experts say your best choice is a sturdy pan that's not too heavy nor too flimsy, with a dark exterior finish and handles (to help get pans in and out of the oven).

Silicone is a relatively new bakeware material. It is light, flexible, easy to clean and colorful. But experts say that silicone muffin pans don't offer an advantage over metal pans, and because they are floppy, they can be harder to use than metal pans. Some bakers complain that silicone pans do not brown muffins as well as metal pans do. And though manufacturers say silicone pans are nonstick, user reviews are mixed and many say they still need to use nonstick cooking spray.

A word about nonstick coatings

The most frequently recommended metal muffin pans have a nonstick coating, which eliminates the need to grease the pan to prevent sticking. You should be aware that most nonstick coatings are made of Teflon or similar chemicals that are controversial. We address this issue at length in our report on cookware.  

Whether or not these chemicals pose long-term health risks is open to debate; nevertheless, experts say that when using nonstick cookware of any kind, you should keep the oven temperature at 500 degrees Fahrenheit or lower, never heat an empty nonstick pan and throw out pans that are nicked or chipped.

You can find muffin pans in four common configurations: 6-cup giant muffin pans, 6-cup muffin-top muffin pans, 12-cup regular muffin pans and 24-cup mini-muffin pans. Here's what else experts say about muffin pans:

  • Handles are helpful. Muffin pans with cups that are close to the edges can be difficult to grasp without sticking your fingers into the batter. It's relatively easy to find standard 12-cup muffin pans with handles, but specialty pans with handles are harder to find.
  • Dark finishes are better for browning. In one comparison review, pans with shiny, light-colored finishes delivered overdone tops and underdone bottoms.
  • Pick a pan that's neither too light nor too heavy. Experts at Cook's Illustrated say you can skip heavy professional-style muffin pans, which didn't perform any better than standard pans in their tests.
  • Think twice about silicone. Owners say silicone is easy to clean, but report that it's not as nonstick as it promises to be, plus its floppiness makes it harder to use. One trick is to place a cookie sheet under your silicone muffin pan. Baking times might also need to be adjusted.
  • Don't bother with paper liners. While paper muffin-cup liners have their advantages – they're colorful, they keep fingers off the food and they let you get away without greasing – experts say they can stick to the muffin and make a mess when you start to eat. Some cooks say using nonstick cookware or a nonstick spray produces better results than using paper liners since the tasty brown crust stays on the muffin instead of being thrown away on the paper.
  • Be careful with metal utensils. Not only can sharp knives slice through silicone bakeware; they can also scratch metal surfaces and coatings. If you need to nudge a stubborn muffin or cupcake from its pan, one trick is to use a plastic knife instead.

Muffin Pans Runners Up:

Baker's Secret Basics Nonstick 12-Cup Muffin Pan *Est. $10

1 pick including:, Cook's Illustrated Magazine…

Baker's Secret Basics Nonstick 12-Cup Muffin Pan
Buy from
New: $9.99 $4.01   
In Stock.
Average Customer Review:  

Back to top