
Best music download site overall
- Large music selection
- Unlimited downloads
- Good range of radio stations
- Not the lowest-cost service
- Software compatibility issues
- Digital Rights Management
We found some excellent, detailed professional reviews of Napster at CNet.com and PC Magazine. Both articles are geared toward a technology-friendly audience. CNet.com has the most detailed coverage plus a helpful ratings breakdown. Which? is a U.K.-based consumer advocacy service; editors review a wide variety of consumer products and services. Its music download service ratings compare eight sites for ease of use, speed, flexibility, range and music quality. TopTenReviews.com has a useful side-by-side comparison of several music download services along with a detailed review of Napster. There's also a nice write-up by site guide Mark Harris at About.com.
With a huge catalogue of over six million songs, Napster has become the reviewer favorite among music download sites. Along with the large library, there's a good selection of radio stations. Reviewers say sound quality is excellent and hardware compatibility is broad -- Napster's WMA files work on everything but iPods, but the service is working on building a selection of MP3 music, which are playable on any music player, including iPods. You can also get unlimited streaming for a monthly subscription fee. iTunes (*est. 99¢ per track) is the only other site with a superior music selection, but it doesn't have any subscription options. If your tastes run more to the independent labels, eMusic (*est. $10 per month and up) doesn't use Digital Rights Management, meaning terms of use and access are much less restrictive.
Our Sources
1. CNET
The best professional review of Napster comes from CNet.com. There's an overall rating plus a detailed breakdown of categories like set-up, features and interface. The overall assessment is that "Napster often leads the field in new features and now offers a welcome free streaming plan--but it doesn't lead on price."
Review: Napster, John Frederick Moore and Troy Dreier, May 2006
PC Magazine has a full-length review of Napster 4.0. Rick Broida's coverage is balanced; his overall assessment is that it's a good, but not outstanding, service.
Review: Napster 4.0 Review, Rick Broida, Oct. 2007
3. Which? (UK)Details/Subscribe
Which? is the British equivalent of Consumer Reports, with a similar reputation for consumer advocacy and impartial reviews. For its report on music download sites, editors assess Napster and seven others for ease of use, speed, flexibility, range and music quality.
Review: Music download sites, Editors of Which?, Nov. 2006
Music Downloads Runners Up:
5 picks by top review sites.
2 picks including: About.com, PC World…
