Olive Oil Reviews, Best Olive Oils

Best supermarket olive oil

*Est. $9 for 16.9-oz. bottle Compare Prices

It's not a unanimous favorite, and it doesn't hold up that well against premium olive oils in taste tests, but Colavita Extra Virgin is top-picked by reviewers more often than any other mid-priced nationally available… olive oil for its bold but well-balanced flavor. However, Colavita is more expensive than the well-regarded Whole Foods 365, and while it's much less expensive than imported brands like Columela, it also (according to reviewers) doesn't taste as good. If you mainly use olive oil for everyday sautéing and sauce-making, however, experts say Colavita is a good middle-of-the-road choice.

See more photos, specs, and reviews

expand

collapse

Expert & User Review Sources:

Cook's Illustrated Magazine: Cook's Illustrated's reviewers taste 11 extra-virgin olive oils readily available at supermarkets and discuss the sometimes ...

ConsumerReports.org: Consumer Reports pioneered laboratory testing for independent product reviews. Colavita is among 18 extra-virgin olive oils rated ...

Choice.com.au: Choice is sort of an Australian effort to do Consumer Reports-style product evaluations - no advertising, thus no commercial ...

Choice.com.au: Like Consumer Reports, Australia's Choice accepts no advertising, but you'll need a subscription to see this report. Editors rate ...

TheNibble.com: The Nibble tries to be unbiased, although it says some of the samples were provided by olive-oil companies. Still, that's a bit ...

Chowhound.com: Chowhound is a message board, so anyone can post whatever they want. However, Chowhound posters tend to be knowledgeable and ...

Where to buy:

See All Stores

Premium olive oil

Columela Extra Virgin Olive Oil

*Est. $16 for 17-oz. bottle Compare Prices

There are a huge number of premium olive oils on the market, most of which are imported from Italy, Greece, Spain or the Middle East, or grown by small producers in California. We've included Columela in ConsumerSearch… Fast Answers because it's the top pick of a reliable source, Cook's Illustrated, which recommends this Spanish import over comparably priced oils from Italy and Greece because of its "bold olive flavor" and "slightly fruity, medium-to-heavy texture." But Columela isn't your only choice among premium brands. Many experts recommend trying out premium oils yourself since taste is so subjective.

See more photos, specs, and reviews

expand

collapse

Expert & User Review Sources:

Cook's Illustrated Magazine: Cook's Illustrated's reviewers taste 11 extra-virgin olive oils readily available at supermarkets and discuss the sometimes ...

Cook's Illustrated Magazine: Cook's Illustrated editors taste 10 olive oils in this review, an update of an earlier report.

Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette used six tasters who sipped Spanish olive oils from small cups like wine tasters, although they did ...

TheNibble.com: The Nibble seems unbiased enough, although it says some of the samples were provided by olive-oil companies. Still, these oils ...

Chowhound.com: Chowhound.com posters tend to be serious about food and opinionated, and they'll generally correct the uninformed. Columela olive ...

Where to buy:

See All Stores

Amazon

for $38.33

Best budget olive oil

Whole Foods 365 Extra Virgin Olive Oil

*Est. $5 for 17.9-oz. bottle Compare Prices

The top-ranked source in our All Reviews chart, Good Housekeeping, praises this budget-priced olive oil for its "intensely robust olive taste," but notes that it's a bit peppery for many uses. Whole Foods 365 Extra Virgin… also attracts online praise from olive-oil enthusiasts, who say it tastes much better than its price would indicate. However, this olive oil is only available in Whole Foods stores.

See more photos, specs, and reviews

expand

collapse

Expert & User Review Sources:

ConsumerReports.org: Consumer Reports doesn't accept advertising, but you'll have to pay a subscription fee to read this report. CR rates 18 olive ...

Good Housekeeping: Good Housekeeping conducts a blind taste test with nine tasters, although it tests just 12 olive oils. It recommends three, ...

TheNibble.com: The Nibble is unbiased enough, although it says some of the samples were provided by olive-oil companies. But the 90 olive oils ...

Chowhound.com: Like any message board, anyone can post whatever they want on Chowhound.com and might not know their topic very well. But ...

Where to buy:

See All Stores

Olive Oil: Reviews

Best supermarket olive oil

Premium olive oil

Best budget olive oil

Olive Oil by Price Range