Staples Mailmate M3 12-Sheet Shredder

Discontinued
Reviewed
January 2009
Email

Pros
  • Shreds CDs as well as paper
  • Powerful enough to shred unopened, full envelopes
  • Small -- fits on a desktop
Cons
  • Mouth too narrow for regular-sized sheets of paper
  • Scattered reports of jams
  • No safety shutoff
  • Frequent reports of breakdowns
 
 
Where to Buy
 
 
 

The past year has seen an onslaught of negative reviews for the Staples Mailmate M3 12-Sheet Shredder, primarily due to complaints of units that stop working after a few weeks or months. The Staples Mailmate is basically a single-purpose shredder. Its feed slot is only six inches wide, so it's built for envelopes, not copy paper or bank statements. It's unique in that respect: We couldn't find any other shredder specifically designed for junk mail. Reviewers like that this unit is small enough to fit on a desktop. This machine is also built to handle credit cards, CDs and DVDs, although -- like other moderately priced shredders -- it isn't powerful enough to consume a steady digital diet. The Mailmate is a crosscut shredder that comes with a 1.8-gallon basket and nonskid rubber feet.

Laura Moser at Slate.com reviews the Staples Mailmate M3 in a comparison test of six home-use paper shredders. We also found reviews of a smaller model on Amazon.com.

Our Sources

1. Slate.com

Laura Moser rates the capacity, design and efficiency of six home-use paper shredders from Staples, Fellowes, OfficeMax and Royal. The best shredder in this test is the mid-priced Staples Mailmate M3 12-Sheet Shredder, which Moser likes for its 12-sheet capacity and small size.

Review: Home Slice, Laura Moser, Sept. 30, 2008

2. Amazon.com

We were surprised to see a Staples shredder reviewed on Amazon.com but were glad we checked: the 35 reviews here raise some doubts about this smaller model, earning it an average two-star rating. More than half say their machines broke down.

Review: Staples Mailmate Junk Mail Shredder, Contributors to Amazon.com

3. Viewpoints.com

A few write-ups here give the smaller Mailmate a mixed review. It shreds well but can't handle large quantities, owners say. This machine stops working in a few months for several reviewers.

Review: Staples Mailmate(TM) Shredder Reviews, Contributors to Viewpoints.com

Paper Shredders Runners Up:

Fellowes Intellishred PS-79Ci *Est. $200

5 picks including: Amazon.com, The New York Times…

Fellowes Powershred DS-1 *Est. $135

2 picks including: Amazon.com, Which.co.uk…

Staples Mailmate M5 Shredder *Est. $80

2 picks including: The New York Times, Staples.com…

     
   
 
 
 
     
   
 
 
 
     
 
image
OfficeMax 8-Sheet Micro-Cut Shredder
Average Customer Review:  
 
 
 
 

Back to top