Amys Organic Family Marinara

*Est. $6 for 24.5 ounces
Email
Amys Organic Family Marinara

Best organic pasta sauce

Pros
  • Thick texture
  • Organic ingredients
  • Not too sweet
Cons
  • Herbs can be overwhelming

We found the best review of Amy's Organic Family Marinara at the San Francisco Chronicle, which asked five food professionals to taste 11 organic sauces. This is the only publication we found that tests solely organic pasta sauce. Amy's pasta sauce is also included in a roundup of sauces at Health magazine, where it competes against non-organic varieties.

Among organic pasta sauces, Amy's Organic Family Marinara receives the most positive mentions; the consensus is that this sauce is thick, tastes good and is not too sweet (many mainstream jarred sauces are laden with corn syrup). There's some disagreement over spiciness – some tasters say Amy's has a mild flavor, but others say the manufacturer should ease up on the herbs. If you aren't concerned about buying organic, reviewers say Rao's Homemade Marinara Sauce (*est. $8 for 24 ounces) and Barilla Basilico Tomato & Basil Sauce (*est. $3 for 26 ounces) are also good choices.

Where To Buy
 
 
Amy'S Kitchen Organic Marinara Sauce ( 6x24.5 OZ)

 (1 reviews)
Buy new: $60.41 $58.98   4 New from $49.09

In Stock.

 
 
 
 
 
Featured StoresStore RatingNotesTotal Price
VitaCost.comVitaCost.com rated 3.36 (344 reviews)344 store reviewsIn Stock. Free Shipping Offer!$7.44
iHerb.comiHerb.com rated 4.57 (431 reviews)431 store reviewsIn Stock. Free Shipping For Orders Over $40 No Taxes Fast Same Day Shipping$7.40
Abe's MarketAbe's Market has not yet been reviewed0 store reviewsIn Stock. $4.99 Shipping for Your Whole Order, Price Guarantee, Easy Returns$8.54
 
 
 

Our Sources

1. San Francisco Chronicle

This newspaper asks five food professionals to taste 11 organic jarred sauces, with Amy's placing fifth (the winner is Italy's Starletta). The review says Amy's is "mild" but has an "overpowering herb flavor."

Review: Pasta Sauce Taste-off Yields Hall-of-Famer, Carol Ness, Feb. 15, 2006

2. Health Magazine

Health magazine says it tested 15 brands of jarred past sauce but lists just four of them, naming Amy's Premium Organic Tomato Basil Pasta Sauce the winner. Odd for a health magazine, there's no mention of these sauces' nutritional value.

Review: Taste Test: The Marinara Showdown, Alisa Blackwood, Jan. 2006

3. Chowhound.com

Chowhound is a foodie forum; in this thread on pasta sauce, Amy's gets a mention from a couple of fans, but overall, participants seem to favor gourmet brands like Rao's.

Review: What's a Good Store-Bought Pasta Sauce?, Contributors to Chowhound.com

Pasta Sauce Runners Up:

Back to top