Skippy Super Chunk Peanut Butter 18-ounce jar

We found the best review for Skippy Super Chunky at Newsday, which asked eleven children ages 8 to 13 to taste-test eight chunky peanut butters. The traditional Skippy Super Chunk finished third. We found fewer reviews of chunky peanut butter in general, but Skippy Creamy also does well in reviews.

Skippy Super Chunky is less pureed than Skippy Creamy, but it still is a processed peanut butter with hydrogenated fat, sugar and salt added. "Natural" and "low-fat" versions of Skippy Chunky also fare well in reviews. Skippy Super Chunk is a familiar flavor to many, and even in a blind taste there is little need for savoring the salty, sweet flavors for tasters to give it a thumbs-up. In a Washington Post review, Skippy Super Chunk placed second to the more expensive Arrowhead Mills Certified Organic Crunchy (*est. $5.80 for 16 ounces). We also found a blurb in Cook's Illustrated magazine that picked Skippy's low-fat chunky product over two rivals but noted that it preferred the regular Skippy Super Chunk. Of course Skippy Super Chunk is not a low-fat product, and there's more salt and sugar than in some "natural" peanut butters.