For an explanation of how we rank reviews, see our ratings criteria page.
by Editors of PCMag.com
This portal page includes a short list of top-rated photo-editing software, plus a chart listing software titles along with editors' and readers' ratings on a 5-point scale, with links to full reviews. The… reviews are fairly long and detailed, certainly enough to give typical users a good handle on where a program does well, and where it can stand some improvement. Top programs are honored with Editors' Choice recognition. Among those are Adobe Photoshop Elements, which is hailed as top photo-editing choice for nonprofessional users, and Google Picassa, which earns kudos for its photo organization as well as its basic photo-editing features.
by Editors of Which? magazine
by Editors of PopPhoto.com
Adobe Photoshop wins the 2009 Editor's Choice award from American Photo (which shares this site with Popular Photography magazine). Editors applaud the program's revised interface and say that it makes the… "world's most powerful digital imaging program" faster and easier to use. The article also highlights four other imaging programs, but three are specialized programs that are either plug-ins to Photoshop or Apple's Aperture image-editing software. Apple's iPhoto, which is part of Apple's iLife suite, is also honored.
by Editors of PC World
PC World offers modestly detailed reviews of photo-editing software as part of its Multimedia reviews section. Testing is done and ratings are provided. Readers also have the opportunity to chime in with… their own ratings and reviews as well. Unified Color Technologies' HDR Photostudio -- a photo editor designed for working with high dynamic range (HDR) images -- receives a rating of 4.5 stars out of 5. Adobe Photoshop Elements 8 scores similarly, though a small handful of user reviewers are not as impressed.
by Editors of Macworld
Macworld looks at photo-editing software from the Mac user's point of view. Coverage is spotty at times. Some reports on major programs are of older versions that have long since been replaced or… significantly updated. On the other hand, Macworld looks at many lesser known image-editing utilities that don't get tons of coverage elsewhere. Reviews are relatively detailed, illustrated and include ratings along with lists of pros and cons.
by Editors of ArsTechnica.com
ArsTechnica.com is a well regarded technology news and review site that does a great job in keeping tabs on the latest developments in image-editing software. However, finding that information on this… blog-style site can be a challenge. The best approach is to use the search function to find what's been written about specific image-editing programs. Reviews are meaty for the most part, and comparisons are often made, however ratings are not provided and the overall best software is not explicitly named.
by Editors of PopPhoto.com
by Editors of ImagingInfo.com
by Editors of and contributors to Amazon.com
Owner reviews give prospective photo-editing software buyers good insight into how well a particular program performs in the real world and in everyday use. Most major programs get enough feedback for… ratings to be meaningful, and reading through the individual reports -- though tedious at times -- can give a good impression on where a program impresses, and where it disappoints. Some write ups are brief, but some go into great detail, even comparing software to competing choices. Among photo-editing software with lots of feedback, Adobe Photoshop Lightroom scores particularly well, with most owners granting it either 4 or 5 stars out of 5.
by Sue Chastain
Sue Chastain, the guide to graphics software at About.com, offers an informative article on what to look for in advanced, beginner, budget and free image-editing software. She then offers her… recommendations in each of these categories for both PCs and Macs. The reviews cover some but not all of the latest versions. Ranking is implied by the way the software is listed, but the ratings for the top picks are all the same. Not all the recommended software has been reviewed. In addition to this article, Adobe Photoshop Lightroom 2 gets a rave review. (Note: ConsumerSearch is owned by About.com, but the two don't share an editorial affiliation.)
by Editors of CNET
by Editors of Download.com
by Ken Rockwell
by Uwe Steinmueller
by Editors of TopTenReviews.com
This report rates 10 photo-editing software programs for beginner to semi-professional use, with separate reviews plus a comparison chart. Each program is given an overall rating based on scores in seven… categories including ease of use, importing, editing, organizing and sharing of photos. However, testing is not explained or documented, so this review is most useful for those who want to compare features between programs.
by Editors of DigitalPhotos101.com
This site reports on eight intermediate-level photo-editing programs. The single-product reviews vary in quality, though all seem to be based on features rather than testing or usage. The best include a… list of pluses and minuses, while the worst reviews are no more than a summary of features. A comparison chart puts features side-by-side for easy comparison, but isn't that detailed and omits some of the photo-editing software covered by the site.
|
This is our assessment of the review’s relevance, clarity of testing and thoroughness.
Read more about our Ratings Criteria by clicking the link at the top of the page.
|
||



