Page: 7 of 7
Radar Detectors: Ratings of Sources
Total of 16 Sources

For an explanation of how we rank reviews, see our ratings criteria page.

1. SpeedZones
Fall 2008
Annual Radar Detector Test 2007-2008
by Editors of SpeedZones
Our Assessment

SpeedZones reports on field evaluations of radar detectors tested by Speed Measurement Laboratories. Testing is incredibly well documented and results are published, but no recommendations are made. All tested radar detectors managed to detect all types of radar, with the strongest signals provided by the Escort Passport 9500i, Valentine One, Whistler XTR-695 and Beltronics STi. The Valentine One and Beltronics STi had the most consistent success against POP radar guns. The Valentine One and Passport 9500i also enjoy a clear edge among laser detectors, being the only models to see all transmissions from all laser guns used in the site's tests. The Beltronics STi and Escort 9500ci are the only radar detectors that are completely invisible to all radar-detector detectors. The Escort Passport 9500i is a strong performer that incorporates GPS features.

expand

collapse

2. Guys of Lidar
Aug. 2007
Radar Detector Test
by Editors of Guys of Lidar
Our Assessment

The reviews conducted by Guys of Lidar are comparative and comprehensive. Most pit several models -- including retail and modified radar detectors -- against each other in trials designed to simulate real-world situations. No best detectors are named. Instead, complete results are published, leaving the reader to draw his or her own conclusions. The site is also packed with information on radar and laser detectors along with other countermeasures. An earlier review (March 2007) includes many of the same radar detectors but a somewhat different battery of tests, including a POP test and an RDD test.

expand

collapse

3. Guys of Lidar
July 25-27, 2008
2008 Laser Jammer Shootout
by Editors of Guys of Lidar
Our Assessment

In this review, Guys of Lidar subject eight different laser jammers to a comprehensive test. Each device is tested against every type of laser gun on the IACP (International Association of Chiefs of Police) approved list except for the new LTI TruSpeed (testers said it was too new to obtain). Two test runs are performed with the gun aimed at a headlight and three with it aimed at the license plate. An easy-to-read chart shows that the Laser Interceptor works best.

expand

collapse

4. Radar Detector Geeks
Not dated
Radar Detector Reviews
by Paul Graham and Gary Smith
Our Assessment

Radar detector "geeks" Paul Graham and Gary Smith own Graham Smith Motoring, a Kentucky auto gear shop they founded after speeding across the country in the notorious Cannonball Run race. In this online arm, Graham and Smith provide one-page reviews of 18 radar detectors from Escort, Beltronics, Whistler and Cobra. The detectors are not compared against each other, but each gets a numeric "cannonball rating," making it easy to see which ones rate best. However, testing methodology is not explained. Top-rated are the Escort 9500i and the Bel STi Driver.

expand

collapse

5. RadarBusters.com
Not Dated
Radar Roy's Badge Ratings
by Roy Reyer
Our Assessment

Former police officer and certified radar instructor Roy Reyer runs this site, which also sells radar detectors. Reyer was sentenced in 2001 for computer tampering in a satellite-TV fraud case. However, his radar-detector reviews appear credible -- unlike many retailer-written reviews, the testing methodology is clearly explained, and Reyer highly rates some detectors he does not carry, while downgrading some he does. Products are awarded from zero to five stars, and Reyer makes specific recommendations. While most of the products mentioned are current, this undated report does include a few discontinued radar detectors. Customer reviews posted here are also helpful, with several detectors amassing 50 or more reviews. Bel and Escort models are the winners here.

expand

collapse

6. Laserveil.com
Not Dated
Radar Detectors Buyer's Guide 2007-2008
by The Veil Guy
Our Assessment

If you can get by the numerous plugs for their own product (an automotive spray designed to absorb laser light in order to reduce a laser gun's targeting range), this site has a number of good single-product and comparative reviews. Unlike some higher-rated reviewers, reporting here is based on real-world driving experience rather than formal testing. Several high-end and budget-friendly detectors are identified as the best currently available in their classes, and subtle differences between them are explained.

expand

collapse

7. 007 Radardetectors.com
As of Oct. 2008
2008 Radar Detector Reviews & Tests
by Editors of 007 Radar Detectors
Our Assessment

This is another retailer site that tests the radar detectors they sell under "real-world" driving conditions. However, there is scant documentation about how they test, and there is little detailed discussion of individual models. Instead, each is given a rating for performance and additional considerations, such as features and build quality. No ratings are given for X-band, POP radar or laser performance.

expand

collapse

8. CNet.com
May 6, 2008
Beltronics Pro RX65
by Wayne Cunningham
Our Assessment CNet.com has reviewed only one radar detector, the Beltronics Pro RX65. Reviewer Wayne Cunningham does not test the RX65 against any other models. Cunningham's write-up is thorough and includes a score of "very good," but since no other radar detectors are reviewed, there's a lack of context.
CES: The 2007 PM Editor's Choice Awards
by Editors of Popular Mechanics
Our Assessment The editors of Popular Mechanics present Editor's Choice awards to their favorite new devices at the Consumer Electronics Show, the biggest trade show for personal gadgets. The Escort Passport 9500i is the only radar detector to earn a mention, thanks to its GPS smarts.
Escort Passport 9500ix Radar Detector Weeds Out False Alarms: Tech Test
by Glenn Derene
Our Assessment Popular Mechanics' Glenn Derene spends a week testing the Escort Passport 9500ix in speed-trap-rich southern Connecticut. He zeroes in on the 9500ix's auto-learn feature (which uses GPS to "learn" which repeated signals are false alarms). He does not test the 9500ix against any other radar detectors.
Cobra XRS 9950 Tells You When Big Brother Is Watching: Tech Test
by Glenn Derene
Our Assessment The Cobra XRS 9950 is the second of two radar detectors Popular Mechanics has tested this year. Reviewer Glenn Derene stops short of recommending the XRS 9950, due to a lot of false alarms.
12. RadarDetector.net
As of Oct. 2008
Radar Detector Jammer Forum
by Contributors to RadarDetector.net
Our Assessment This lively discussion site includes forums dedicated to most major brands of radar detectors, as well as general radar-detector discussions, polls and more. Like all user-to-user sites, the discussion can get heated, but there's lots of great information to be found (though it takes some time to weed through it all). The site is moderated by Roy Reyer of RadarBusters.com.
13. RadarTest.com
As of Oct.2008
Detector Review Index
by Craig Peterson
Our Assessment Reviewer Craig Peterson has long been acknowledged as a top radar-detector reviewer, but that reputation was called into question in 2007 by another review site (Guys of Lidar) that accused Peterson of sabotaging one of their tests. Peterson favors Beltronics and Escort models in all of his recent tests.
14. Laser Jammer Tests
As of Oct. 2008
Laser jammer reviews, tests and news
by Editors of LaserJammerTests.com
Our Assessment

The testers at Laser Jammer Tests identify themselves only as John and Chris, two laser-jammer enthusiasts. They say they don't accept freebies from companies, instead either buying the jammers they test or inviting readers who own jammers to have them tested. Testing methods are explained, but not in detail. Chris and John make no bones about which brands they hate, and some posters on car and laser-jammer forums say Laser Jammer Tests appears to be biased in favor of the LaserStar, a model that does not perform well in the respected Guys of Lidar tests.

expand

collapse

15. Epinions.com
As of Oct. 2008
Radar Detectors
by Contributors to Epinions
Our Assessment

Though Epinions sometimes lags behind retailer sites when it comes to review volume, radar detectors actually get a fair amount of feedback. Some of the reviews reflect months and sometimes a year or more of use, something few professional reviewers can do. Still, this is a better site to visit after you've narrowed your choices down somewhat, as many radar detectors rate similarly. In addition, many radar detectors remain listed long after they've been discontinued. Some models are clear favorites here. Four score at least 4.5 of five stars with at least nine reviews (some have far more): the Escort Passport 9500i, Valentine One, Escort Passport 8500 and Whistler DE-1730.

expand

collapse

16. Amazon.com
As of Oct. 2008
Radar Detectors
by Contributors to Amazon.com
Our Assessment

Amazon.com is another good spot to read owner-written reviews of radar detectors. Navigation is easy, since the landing page displays both average ratings and the number of reviews each product has received. Clicking through to the reviews themselves, Amazon.com displays the review breakdown (i.e. how many five-star reviews, how many four-star reviews, etc. the product has received), along with the most helpful positive and negative reviews based on reader feedback. Of course, review quality is variable -- some are just a line or two -- and some radar detectors have received only a few ratings.

expand

collapse

Back to top