Home > Health & Beauty > Razors > Razors Sources

Razors : Ratings of Sources

By: Tara Tuckwiller on March 30, 2017

In this report

Best Razors Our Sources

Razors: Ratings of Sources

Dan Koeppel, Updated Aug. 4, 2015
Credibility:

TheSweethome.com conducts the granddaddy of all men's razor tests. Dan Koeppel tries 100 razors, asks 30 barbers for their recommendations and has 10 men test three finalists. Koeppel explains the testing process and results at length. He names one best razor (a popular refillable drugstore model), a disposable pick and an old-fashioned safety razor pick.

Mark Herro, Updated February 2017
Credibility:

Mark Herro, a retired Texas A&M University telecommunications manager, became a widely known shaving guru after posting YouTube instructional videos on how to shave the old-fashioned way, with a straight or safety razor. Here, he gives a great primer on double-edge (DE) safety razors and names his favorites (and honorable mentions) in several categories.

Mark Herro, Nov. 20, 2013
Credibility:

While Herro prefers straight or safety razors, he notes in this article that "modern cartridge razors have their place." He evaluates seven less expensive alternatives to the popular Gillette Fusion ProGlide. He talks about "our testers'" experiences with the razors, but he doesn't say he tested them himself. Herro says all seven work well.

David Alexander, Updated Aug. 29, 2016
Credibility:

David Alexander, About.com's men's hair expert, regularly tests all kinds of razors -- major-brand razors, cheap razors, upscale razors, subscription-club razors. Many get a one-page review, where Alexander describes his shaving experience and rates the razor on a 5-star scale. Alexander's five favorites are named on this page.

Alan Henry and Contributors to Lifehacker.com, July 14, 2013
Credibility:

Lifehacker.com polls its readers to find out which razor they like best. With more than 10,000 votes cast, five razors rise to the top: two Gillette refillables and three old-fashioned safety razors. Alan Henry describes each razor and explains why readers say they like it. He says he also kept an eye out for corporate vote-rigging, but he didn't find any.

Contributors to Amazon.com, As of March 2017
Credibility:

Amazon.com is an excellent source for owner reviews of men's shaving razors. Standout razors earn at least a 4.5-out-of-5-star rating after 100 or more user reviews. Safety razors earn the highest reviews, but there are a few top-rated refillable and disposable razors, too.

Contributors to Target.com, As of March 2017
Credibility:

Retail websites, including Target.com mostly reprint reviews from razor manufacturers' websites (Gillette.com, Schick.com) and from people who got free razors in exchange for their reviews. These owner reviews aren't nearly as objective -- or critical -- as those at Amazon.com.

Contributors to Walmart.com, As of March 2016
Credibility:

This is another site where you can see lots of user reviews of razors and blades. Most razors earn modest numbers of reviews, others can see feedback numbering into the thousands. Users can leave brief remarks and say whether or not they would recommend a razor to a friend.

Mark Ellwood, Sept. 29, 2015
Credibility:

To find the best subscription shaving products, Mark Ellwood says he "actually tried them all." He gets advice from Sharpologist blogger Mark Herro and celebrity groomer Joanna Pensinger, too. He names a winner and runner-up in four categories, ranging from no-nonsense to super-pampering. He bases his picks not only on the quality of the razor, but also the shaving creams, etc. included in the box.

Mark Doliner, Dec. 10, 2013
Credibility:

On his personal blog, clean-shaven computer software engineer Mark Doliner tests six razors from Gillette and Schick (including the vaunted Gillette Fusion ProGlide Power) for a few months. He prefers one of the Gillette razors. He concludes that more blades aren't always better, and most blades last equally long.

Kevin Roose, April 18, 2014
Credibility:

The Gillette Fusion ProGlide FlexBall "is a bad idea," Kevin Roose argues. It's just a "dumb novelty" that isn't really any sort of shaving innovation, not worthy of Procter & Gamble's multi-billion-dollar R&D budget. Roose says the "cheapo razors" he buys online (he links to Dorco's website) are just as good as Gillette's pricier razors.

Sue Byrne, April 25, 2016
Credibility:

ConsumerReports.org tests four razors from three shave clubs: Dollar Shave Club, Gillette Shave Club and Harry's. Eight male staffers shave their faces daily with the razors for eight days. They and ConsumerReports.org's sensory experts judge the closeness of each razor's shave after the first day and the last day. ConsumerReports.org then ranks the razors from best to worst.

Brady Dale, Aug. 30, 2016
Credibility:

Brady Dale, a four-year Dollar Shave Club subscriber, pits that company's subscription razors against Harry's and Gillette's. He says Dollar Shave Club "clearly wins" on price and service, but the pricier Gillette Fusion ProGlide FlexBall subscription razor delivers the best shave.

Elsewhere In This Report
Recently Updated
Razors buying guide

What every best Razors has:

  • A substantial, grippy handle.
  • A close, comfortable shave.
  • An affordable price.

Read More »

Learn More »