Granite Ware 19-Inch Covered Oval Roaster

Reviewers agree that the Granite Ware 19-Inch Covered Oval Roaster is an unbeatable value. One foodie magazine recommends the Granite Ware roaster for browning meat and potatoes in the oven. However, its thin steel bottom doesn't conduct heat well enough to prepare gravy or sauces on the stovetop. Another review warns that using the lid causes turkey and other meats to steam rather than roast, and it inhibits browning.

Owners who have posted reviews at Cooking.com are generally happy with this roaster. Some complain about the pan's light weight, but others say it's easier to maneuver when full. The bottom of the pan has ridges, since it doesn't include a rack, which keeps the meat raised, but owners say the uneven bottom is harder to clean. Granite Ware also sells smaller oval roasters as well as a 21-inch rectangular roaster. If you want a roasting pan that's easier to clean, reviews recommend the Calphalon Contemporary Nonstick Roaster Set (*Est. $80).

We found the most comprehensive review of the Granite Ware 19-Inch Covered Oval Roaster at Cook's Illustrated magazine, where it's compared to seven stainless-steel pans. We turn to Cooking.com and Amazon.com for insightful owner-written reviews on this inexpensive roasting pan.