Satellite Radio: Reviews

Updated September 2008
Satellite radio offers variety you just can't get from local broadcasters -- static free and often commercial free. ConsumerSearch looks at the hardware that makes that happen, and the service that makes it go, and makes recommendations for enjoying satellite radio in your car, in your home, or on the go based on expert opinions and feedback from users.
 

Satellite radio service

XM Satellite Radio *Est. $13 per month Learn More

The Wall Street Journal: Five WSJ employees review XM and Sirius radio, comparing them favorably with commercial radio and portable MP3 players.

ConsumerReports.org: This report offers a quick look at the two satellite radio services, as well as the hardware needed to receive it, but doesn’t provide ratings or recommendations.

Satellite radio service

Sirius Satellite Radio *Est. $13 per month Learn More

The Wall Street Journal: This comparative review looks at the pros and cons of XM and Sirius radio, and compares them with other options, such as terrestrial radios and portable MP3 players.

ConsumerReports.org: While most of the reports produced by Consumer Reports can be accessed by subscribers only, this recent update on satellite radio is free for all.

XM receiver for home or car

Delphi XpressRC *Est. $120 Compare Prices

CNET: CNet.com's Don Reisinger gives a favorable review of the Delphi XpressRC, though he notes that he's not a big fan of satellite radio.

Amazon.com: The Delphi Xpress RC receives a rating of 4.5 out of five stars based on about 40 owner reviews, with well over half awarding it a perfect score.

Crutchfield.com: Here the Delphi XpressRC again gets 4.5 out of five stars, this time with about a dozen owner reviews.

Portable XM receiver and MP3 player

Pioneer Inno2BK *Est. $200 Compare Prices

CNET: The original Pioneer Inno gets 3.5 stars out of five here, with Dreier noting his likes (its portability, size, attractive interface and recording capability) and dislikes (battery life, storage capacity, inability to pause or skip backward).

PCMag.com: This review gives the Inno 4.5 stars out of five and names it an Editor's Choice.

Sound & Vision Magazine: John Sciacca likes the Inno's (now shipping as the Inno2BK) versatility and portability (in spite of some reception problems), but feels the price relative to other portable units is the Inno's biggest drawback.

DigitalTrends.com: Digital Trends' Rebecca Day likes the Pioneer Inno's ergonomics and sound quality (in that order), but would prefer longer battery life.

Crutchfield.com: Crutchfield also lets its customers post reviews of products that they own.

Sirius receiver for home or car

Sirius Starmate 4 *Est. $90 Compare Prices

Amazon.com: Over 30 people have posted reports here.

Crutchfield.com: A small handful of users post comments to this site, and several of them note a weak FM modulator and having to buy an FM antenna to increase signal strength.

Portable Sirius radio and MP3 player

Sirius Stiletto 2 *Est. $275 Compare Prices

SiriusBuzz.com: Though this review carries a byline, it is actually authored by a contributor to the site.

Amazon.com: Amazon.com users post ratings and comments of the Stiletto 2, which receives a four-star average rating.

Satellite Radio Runners Up:

Delphi SkyFi3 (XM) *Est. $80

2 picks by top review sites.

Sirius Sportster 5 (Sirius) *Est. $150

2 picks by top review sites.

     
 
image
Delphi SkyFi3 XM Satellite Radio with Car Kit
In Stock.
Average Customer Review:  
 
 
 
 
     
 
image
SIRIUS Sportster 5 Satellite Radio Receiver with Vehicle Kit
In Stock.
Average Customer Review:  
 
 
 
 

Back to top