
Satellite radio service
- Sound quality and signal strength
- Live concerts
- Exclusive coverage of Major League Baseball and NHL sporting events
- Expensive
- Web-streaming sound quality
Though XM and Sirius have merged to form Sirius XM Satellite Radio, each remains a separate service with distinct advantages and disadvantages. On the music front, while both services provide a wealth of channels to appeal to nearly any taste, only XM offers live concerts. For sports fans, XM carries exclusive rights to Major League Baseball, NHL hockey, PGA golf and the Indy Racing League. XM talk radio exclusives include "The Opie and Anthony Show" and "Oprah and Friends." Additionally, XM, like Sirius, has a wide selection of news, weather, politics and other talk radio channels. An online version of the service is free to subscribers, or can be subscribed to separately (*est. $13 per month), but the sound quality isn't terrific. Sirius (*est. $13 per month) is the other satellite radio service. Offerings are similar, except for sports (Sirius carries the NFL, but not baseball or hockey) and the selection of celebrity channels (Howard Stern on Sirius vs. Oprah on XM).
The Wall Street Journal offers the best comparative review of the XM and Sirius satellite radio services. Although some specifics are a little dated, the broad assessments are still valid and provide a useful impression of strengths and weaknesses. Consumer Reports has recently updated its coverage of satellite radio. No judgments are rendered as to which is best, but the overview provided is useful.
Our Sources
Five WSJ employees review XM and Sirius radio, comparing them favorably with commercial radio and portable MP3 players. They say "it's hard to beat satellite radio" in terms of its programming, although they experienced the signal cutting out frequently, both at home and in the car.
Review: Radio Daze, Sarah McBride, Aug. 24, 2006
2. ConsumerReports.orgDetails/Subscribe
This report offers a quick look at the two satellite radio services, as well as the hardware needed to receive it, but doesn't provide ratings or recommendations.
Review: Satellite Radio: Is It Worth the Money?, Editors of Consumer Reports, May 2008
Satellite Radio Runners Up:
2 picks by top review sites.
2 picks by top review sites.
|
Delphi SkyFi3 XM Satellite Radio with Car Kit
from Amazon.com New: $69.99 In Stock.
Average Customer Review: |
||
|
|
|
SIRIUS Sportster 5 Satellite Radio Receiver with Vehicle Kit
from Amazon.com New: $112.99 In Stock.
Average Customer Review: |
||
|
|


