Search Engines: Reviews

Updated July 2011
The web is increasingly clogged with unreliable information and spam, making it more and more difficult to find relevant results. To find out how to improve the web search experience we turned to a number of sources, including librarians (and who knows more about research than they do?). ConsumerSearch editors discovered that when Google doesn't meet your needs, there are several less well known, but useful alternatives that aggressively block spam and offer enhanced privacy.
 

Best search engine overall

University of California, Berkeley Library: Librarians recommend Google as the best search engine for most purposes.

Network World.com: Google was handling 70 percent of the searches in the United States when this was written.

CrowdFlower.com: Bloggers tested Google in 2008, making this review a bit dated, but their results are consistent with more recent reviews.

Viewpoints.com: Most users consider Google the place to go for the quickest and most relevant search results.

Time magazine: Google strives to stay ahead its competition with new innovations, but Harry McCracken, a technology columnist and blogger, worries that the search engine could lose some of its simplicity.

ListOfSearchEngines.info: Google ranks number one in searches with 150 million users every month at the time of this report.

AppAppeal.com: Google gets a perfect 5 stars out of 5 and is the top search engine pick of an editor who says it can be used to find just about anything.

CNET: Reviewer Jay Greene tests the new Google Voice Search feature and is able to get relevant results searching the hard-to-pronounce name Zbigniew Brzezinski.

Alternative search engine

PC World: This slideshow compares searches and related services by Bing, Google and Yahoo!

The Daily Beast: In a comparative test against Blekko and Google, Bing wins in some areas, including recipe search, based on 100 real-world search queries.

Network World.com: In this comparative review, editors note that features like tabs and an answer box are helping Bing distinguish its search results from Google's.

About.com: This About.com page doesn't make a definitive pick, but it does provide useful descriptions of the top 10 search engines as chosen by readers.

Viewpoints.com: Viewpoints offers five user reviews for Bing and rates the search engine at 4.2 out of 5 stars.

Library Journal: Posted shortly after Bing's debut, this article describes Microsoft's effort to unseat Yahoo!

CNET: The article reports that Bing has taken a chunk of Google's market share in the last year, increasing its share by 75 percent between May 2010 and May 2011.

TechnologyReview.com: Continuing to look for an edge against Google, Bing now features social searching, which checks recommendations from a user's Facebook friends for more refined, personalized results.

PCMag.com: PCMag's lead software analyst Michael Muchmore gives Bing a positive review (4.5 out of 5 stars) for its "appealing design," and its ability to answer some queries without sending users to another website.

AppAppeal.com: Bing is useful for finding some information, like airline flight data, editors say, but Microsoft's search engine isn't likely to unseat Google at the top spot.

Search engine for private browsing

About.com: DuckDuckGo makes this list of About's 10 best search engines as chosen by readers, though the list is not ranked in any particular order.

BusinessWorld: Editor Tushar Kanwar likes DuckDuckGo because it looks like Google, but doesn't track history and has less spam in its results.

Wired: Ryan Singel states that DuckDuckGo leads the Web in privacy protection and tools for serious techies.

About.com: DuckDuckGo is the About.com Readers' Choice for the Best Search Engine of 2011 with 48 percent of the vote.

SearchEngineLand.com: Chris Sherman is skeptical of DuckDuckGo until he starts using it.

TimeTechland: DuckDuckGo reminds the reviewer of an older, more stripped down version of Google.

AppAppeal.com: This single-product review gives DuckDuckGo 4 stars out of 5 and discusses some of its features.

Back to top