Skillet Reviews

By: Kelly Burgess on May 2016
It's one of the most versatile pieces of cookware in your kitchen, so your 12-inch skillet should be a reliable and high-quality piece of cookware. The best skillets heat quickly and evenly, and are durable enough hold up to frequent use. Experts say you should have several types of skillets for different cooking tasks, so we've found the top choices in cast iron, carbon steel, stainless steel and nonstick to make life in the kitchen just a bit easier.
 
Lodge 12-inch Cast Iron Skillet
Best cast iron skillet
Lodge 12-inch Cast Iron Skillet

Lodge is a top name in cast iron, and the Lodge 12-inch Cast Iron Skillet is very well reviewed by experts and owners alike for its superior performance -- and it only gets better with age and use. This versatile Lodge cast iron frying pan can go from stovetop to oven or broiler; be used on the grill, in a smoker, or over an open flame. The 12-inch skillet comes pre-seasoned, heats quickly and evenly, and is a great choice for one-pot meals.
See our full review »

image
Lodge L10SK3 Pre-Seasoned Skillet, 12-Inch
Buy from Amazon.com
from Amazon.com
New: $33.95 $19.00   
Average Customer Review:  
Le Creuset Enameled Cast-Iron 11-3/4-Inch Skillet
Enameled cast iron skillet
Le Creuset Enameled Cast-Iron 11-3/4-Inch Skillet

The Le Creuset Enameled Cast Iron Skillet has an enameled interior finish that doesn't require the seasoning that regular cast iron does. Owners say if you follow the manufacturer's instructions for preheating and proper cooking temperatures, it is very nonstick, but don't expect the extreme nonstick properties of coated pans -- those who do are disappointed. Le Creuset pans are among some of the most durable and attractive; this 11-3/4 inch skillet comes in six vibrant colors. Hand washing is recommended.

All-Clad Stainless Steel 12-inch Fry Pan with Lid
Best stainless steel skillet
All-Clad Stainless Steel 12-inch Fry Pan with Lid

Among stainless steel skillets, the All-Clad 12-Inch Fry Pan is the clear standout in both expert and user reviews. Its fully clad construction delivers even heat and great browning, making it a favorite of professional chefs. It's roomy enough to hold a chicken with room to spare and can go from stovetop to oven for one-pot efficiency. Reviewers also say it's durable and comfortable to use. This particular version includes a lid, which adds quite a bit of value.
See our full review »

Cuisinart MCP22-30HN MultiClad Pro Stainless 12-Inch Skillet
Cheap stainless steel skillet
Cuisinart MCP22-30HN MultiClad Pro Stainless 12-Inch Skillet

Reviewers agree: the Cuisinart MCP22-30HN MultiClad Pro Stainless 12-Inch Skillet performs almost as well as its pricier competitors, earning top marks for cooking, ease of handling and durability. As with any stainless steel skillet, there is a learning curve, but once that's mastered, owners say that this Cuisinart is a joy to use. The helper handle is particularly appreciated, and many say they bought this stainless steel skillet just for that feature. Cuisinart cookware comes with a lifetime warranty, but its customer service department gets mixed reviews.

image
Cuisinart MCP22-30HN MultiClad Pro Stainless 12-Inch Skillet with Helper
Buy from Amazon.com
from Amazon.com
New: $65.28
In Stock.
Average Customer Review:  
T-fal E93808 12-inch Fry Pan
Best nonstick skillet
T-fal E93808 12-inch Fry Pan

Experts say you should have at least one nonstick pan, and you can't do any better than the T-fal E93808 12.5-inch Fry Pan. For such an inexpensive skillet, it gets a lot of love from both experts and owners. The T-fal E93808 heats quickly, releases food easily, and is reported as surprisingly heavy and sturdy. It also uses a nonstick coating that's easy to clean and gets very few complaints of chipping or scratching. T-fal offers a lifetime warranty.
See our full review »

Scanpan Professional 12.5-Inch Fry Pan
Ceramic nonstick skillet
Scanpan Professional 12.5-Inch Fry Pan

While most ceramic cookware is "panned" by expert reviewers, the Scanpan Professional 12.5-Inch Fry Pan performs better in testing than most, and is a big hit with owners. Most users say it's just as nonstick as a traditional coated, nonstick pan. Like all ceramic cookware, it's not as durable as skillets made from other materials, so you'll need to handle it with care, and there are complaints of it becoming less nonstick after a few months of use.

image
Scanpan Professional 12.5-Inch Fry Pan
Buy from Amazon.com
from Amazon.com
New: $139.95
In Stock.
Average Customer Review:  

Every kitchen needs a great skillet

Skillets, also known as frying pans, are useful for many kitchen tasks, from frying a single egg to putting a sear on a large roast before finishing it off in the oven. Stovetop-to-oven skillets are also a great choice for one-pot meals, which are becoming increasingly popular with today's busy lifestyles.

We focus on 12-inch skillets in this report -- perfect for a larger family meal -- because they typically are not included in cookware sets. However, most of the skillets we recommend also come in smaller or larger sizes. If you're fine with a smaller skillet or two and would like matching pots as well, cookware sets, which we cover in a separate report, offer the best value. Cookware sets also include lids, which you often have to purchase separately when buying a skillet by itself.

One of the most important things to know about using a skillet is that there is a learning curve, just as there is with any new cookware. Cast iron and stainless steel are not nonstick, so it's worth taking the time to learn how to properly use them and what kinds of foods are best to cook in that type of pan. Even a nonstick frying pan won't be suitable for everything; for example, it's not always the best choice for putting a sear on a steak or preparing more complex dishes that can benefit from the browned bits (called "fond") that stick to a pan and flavor gravies and sauces. Nonstick skillets also usually have a lower oven-safe temperature and often aren't recommended for use under a broiler. That's why experts suggest keeping a couple of different types of skillets around, so you always have the right pan for the job.

The main types of skillets:

Cast iron skillets are a versatile, economical option. When broken in and treated properly, cast iron will serve you well for many years, and maybe your children and grandchildren as well. Although it takes longer to heat than other types of skillets, cast iron retains its heat very well and excels at browning, searing and baking. It also goes seamlessly from stovetop to oven, and can be used on the grill or over an open flame -- making it very popular with campers and tailgaters. Over time, cast iron will develop some natural nonstick properties, although it may never be nonstick enough for that perfect over-easy egg. Cast iron frying pans are inexpensive and are virtually indestructible, but they're heavy and can be unwieldy. They need some TLC, too, starting with seasoning the pan before the first use. We also cover carbon steel skillets in this section. They're fairly uncommon in American kitchens, but are getting a lot of buzz from experts as they have a lot of the good qualities of well-seasoned cast iron, with few of the downsides.

Stainless-steel skillets are the go-to pan for professional chefs. Also often referred to as "clad," stainless steel frying pans have a core of fast-heating aluminum sandwiched between two layers of heat-tempering stainless steel. This material heats evenly on gas or electric stovetops, and experts say it does a superior job of browning food. Stainless steel skillets with oven-safe handles can typically withstand temperatures of 500 degrees Fahrenheit in the oven or under the broiler. These pans are not inherently nonstick, and it may take some trial and error to figure out the correct sequence of heat + oil + added ingredients, but foodies say it's worth going through the learning curve.

Nonstick skillets are the best choice for some cooking tasks. Every kitchen should have at least one nonstick skillet. They excel at cooking delicate foods like fish, and this is the pan you need for the perfect, intact, runny-yoked egg. The best nonstick skillets heat quickly and evenly, and they tend to be lighter and easier to maneuver than either cast iron or stainless. They should be used at lower temperatures than stainless steel or cast iron.

Nonstick skillets have a reputation as being inherently unsafe due to volatile chemicals that might leach into food and the environment and cause all kinds of havoc. In fact, while there are some concerns about the coatings used in older products, Good Housekeeping research showed that even most of that was overstated. In addition, nonstick cookware has become increasingly safe in recent years, and virtually all are now free of PFOA and other chemicals that used to be the source of most of the worry. When used properly, these pans -- even older ones -- are extremely safe. However, if you're still concerned, yet love the convenience of nonstick, ceramic and other "green" skillets, while still fairly new to the market, are performing better than ever as that technology advances. We review a few of those in this report as well.

How we found the best skillets

There are a good number of professional organizations that test skillets, including Cook's Illustrated, ConsumerReports.org, and TheSweethome.com. Also helpful are articles and reviews from individuals who are knowledgeable about cookware and cooking, and we found several articles at Chowhound.com, FineCooking.com and the Wall Street Journal, to name just a few

Since durability can't always be evaluated in the test lab, we also consulted thousands of reviews from users at retail sites, such as Amazon.com, Walmart.com and BedBathandBeyond.com. This gives us a lot of insight into determining how skillets perform in real kitchens, helping us to make recommendations for the best skillets for your home kitchen.