Page: 5 of 5
Slow Cookers: Ratings of Sources
Total of 15 Sources

For an explanation of how we rank reviews, see our ratings criteria page.

1. ConsumerReports.org
Dec. 2008
Slow Cookers
by Editors of Consumer Reports
Our Assessment Editors of Consumer Reports test and rank 15 slow cookers, all with six- to seven-quart capacity. They test the same four recipes in each one to ensure that results reflect the true capabilities of each cooker. Slow cookers priced from $40 to $250 are tested, and editors find price is not necessarily a predictor of performance. The article also offers tips for selecting a slow cooker.
2. Cook's Illustrated
Aug. 2007
Expensive Slow Cookers
by Editors of Cook's Illustrated
Our Assessment

This review focuses on advanced models. Editors put seven slow cookers through their paces, cooking pot roast on both "high" and "low" settings and chili and beans on "high." Using remote temperature probes, testers check the internal temperature of the roasts and evaluate total water loss after three hours of covered cooking on high. All the slow cookers did a good job, but editors deem certain features even more important than performance. These include a timer that automatically shifts to a "keep warm" setting at the end of timed cooking, a clear lid, an "on" indicator light and an insert with handles for easier removal. Pros and cons are listed for each slow cooker, and several are recommended.

expand

collapse

3. Slate.com
Feb. 9, 2005
What a Crock -- Which Slow Cooker Is Best?
by Jill Hunter Pellettieri
Our Assessment

Jill Pellettieri tests and rates eight slow cookers. She also provides a brief history of slow-cooker technology. She prepares 15 dishes, ranging from pot roast to rice pudding, and awards points for performance, ease of use, design, flavor of the finished dish and value. The Cuisinart CSC-650 earns her top rating, followed by the Rival 3040TCC and Rival 38651-C. She disliked the West Bend 6-Quart Crockery Cooker, which frequently boiled over.

expand

collapse

The Best Slow Cookers
by Editors of Real Simple
Our Assessment

The editors at Real Simple test a dozen slow cookers. This article lists the three top performers and some of their features, as well as links to websites where they may be purchased. We wish there were more details regarding the testing process used to rate these slow cookers. Favorites include Rival's Smart-Pot Programmable Crock-Pot SCVC550, Cuisinart's 6.5-quart model and All-Clad's 99009 slow cooker.

expand

collapse

5. About.com
As of Dec. 2008
Top 10 Guide Picks – Slow Cookers and Crock Pots
by Diana Rattray
Our Assessment

As an About.com guide for more than 10 years, Diana Rattray has established herself as an expert on Southern food. Here she lists her favorite 10 slow cookers, including the All-Clad 99009, KitchenAid's 7-quart slow cooker and Cuisinart's 6.5-quart model. There is little indication here that she has actually tested these cookers herself, however. (Note: ConsumerSearch is owned by About.com, but the two don't share an editorial affiliation.)

expand

collapse

The Best Slow Cookers
by Editors of Good Housekeeping
Our Assessment

Experts at Good Housekeeping test 16 slow cookers, identifying four favorites. While these four are not ranked in order, they offer a variety of features and a range of prices. We wish there were more information about testing methodologies, but the article is helpful nonetheless. Favorites include Rival's Smart-Set Slow Cooker and Buffet Slow Cooker, as well as West Bend's Versatility and Cuisinart's 4-quart slow cooker.

expand

collapse

7. Woman's Day
Oct. 23, 2008
State-of-the-Art Slow Cookers
by Stephanie Lee
Our Assessment

While the staff-tested slow cookers in this article are not ranked best-to-worst, seven top picks are mentioned. Each slow cooker is given a label, such as "Easier than Ever" for the Cuisinart 4-quart or "Table Ready" for the All-Clad 6.5-quart slow cookers. The article also lists the features and price of each cooker. Although this article is helpful, we wish they had included more information regarding the testing process and procedures.

expand

collapse

8. Which? magazine
As of Dec. 2008
Slow Cookers
by Editors of Which?
Our Assessment

Which? magazine, a U.K.-based publication, is similar to Consumer Reports. More than a dozen slow cookers are tested for safety and cooking performance and then subjected to a "user trial" for more than two weeks. The "Best Buy" Cuisinart 6.5-quart slow cooker is the earlier model CSC650U. The Rival VersaWare Crock Pot is given a poor score for cooking, although editors like the fact that it is fridge-, freezer-, oven- and stovetop-safe. None of these models are currently available here in the U.S.

expand

collapse

9. Amazon.com
As of Dec. 2008
Slow Cookers
by Contributors to Amazon.com
Our Assessment We read dozens of owner-written slow cooker reviews at Amazon.com. The Hamilton Beach 4-Quart 33141 is currently the most popular, with a rating of four out of five stars from over 70 reviewers. Users generally have no complaints about the way this model cooks, but many say that the control knob broke.
10. Epinions.com
As of Dec. 2008
Slow Cookers
by Contributors to Epinions.com
Our Assessment Owners are invited to rate their slow cookers at Epinions.com. Many discontinued models are included, which makes this site less helpful than Amazon.com. Among slow cookers currently on the market, the Hamilton Beach Stay-or-Go 33162 and the Hamilton Beach 33675 Meal Maker slow cookers are the only ones we found that receive an average rating of 4.5 stars with more than 10 reviews.
11. Cooking.com
As of Dec. 2008
Slow Cooker Reviews
by Contributors to Cooking.com
Our Assessment Owner-written reviews at Cooking.com are not as critical as those at Amazon.com, and most write-ups are brief. Several models reviewed elsewhere are not reviewed on this site, making it less helpful than some other sites. However, the site is easy to navigate. The top-rated slow cooker here is the All-Clad 99009 6.5-quart, while the six-quart Hamilton Beach Stay-or-Go is listed as a bestseller.
12. Target.com
As of Dec. 2008
Slow Cookers
by Contributors to Target.com
Our Assessment Target is an increasingly good place to find owner-written reviews of kitchen appliances, including slow cookers. It's not easy to compare models, but once you have your choice narrowed, Target.com is worth a visit. The Rival Crock-Pot 4-quart Oval Slow Cooker is the best-reviewed slow cooker on this site, with 4.5 stars out of five from over 20 reviewers.
13. Wize.com
As of Dec. 2008
Best Crock Pot and Slow Cooker Products
by Contributors to Wize.com
Our Assessment

Wize.com is a customer-review site that draws reviews from various websites -- such as Amazon.com, Target.com and Shopping.com -- and compiles the reviews into a single score. Individual reviews are also listed and can be read in detail. Based on consumer reviews, Wize.com makes product recommendations. There is no testing involved, but Wize.com is a good clearinghouse for customer opinion from a variety of sites. Favorite slow cookers include the Hamilton Beach 33163 Stay-or-Go and the All-Clad 99009 6.5-quart.

expand

collapse

14. Southern Living
Feb. 2005
What's New in Slow Cookers
by Shirley Harrington
Our Assessment

In this article, which also includes recipes, editors highlight the new Rival Crock-Pots. The Rival VersaWare Slow Cooker's insert can be used on the stovetop before being placed in the crock pot. The Rival Smart-Pot automatically switches to "keep warm" mode after cooking food for four, six, eight or 10 hours. The Rival Recipe Smart-Pot can be programmed in 30-minute increments and comes with 200 recipes. None of these models appears to have been tested.

expand

collapse

15. ConsumerGuide.com
As of Dec. 2008
Slow Cookers/Crock Pots
by Editors of ConsumerGuide.com
Our Assessment ConsumerGuide.com lists 149 slow cookers, but only 11 of them have been reviewed by the site's editors. Two, the Hamilton Beach Set 'n Forget 33966 and the Hamilton Beach Stay-or-Go 33613, are listed as Best Buy products, while two others, the Hamilton Beach 33141 and Proctor-Silex 33015, are designated Budget Buy models. However, there is no evidence that any of these units were tested.

Back to top