Page: 4 of 4
In this report

See Also

Smoke Detectors: Ratings of Sources
Total of 6 Sources

For an explanation of how we rank reviews, see our ratings criteria page.

1. Consumer magazine
May 31, 2006
Smoke Alarms
by Editors of Consumer magazine
4 stars Credibility Rating
Our Assessment

New Zealand publication Consumer magazine tests 21 smoke detectors in a mock hallway situation. Three of each product are evaluated for accuracy in high-flaming and smoky/smoldering fires. Editors test both… ionization and photoelectric and display the results in an easy-to-read rankings chart. Testing methodology is also clearly explained. Although several of the models covered here are not available in the U.S., many are, including the top overall pick. This magazine's test of smoke detectors is better than the most recent one conducted by ConsumerReports.org.

expand

collapse

2. Amazon.com
As of June 2009
Smoke Alarms
by Contributors to Amazon.com
4 stars Credibility Rating
Our Assessment

Amazon.com user reviews are a good place to gain insight on nagging problems that annoy owners. For instance, the otherwise highly rated First Alert SA302CN is sometimes criticized because its test function… can be triggered randomly by TV remote controls. The hardwired BRK 9120B is also criticized for constant chirping. The Kidde 900-0102 smoke/carbon monoxide detector has poor battery life, according to owners; in one case, it reportedly failed to detect a microwave fire that filled a house with smoke. The best-reviewed smoke detector at Amazon.com is the Kidde PI2000, a hardwired model.

expand

collapse

3. ConsumerReports.org
March 2007
Fire Safety for Your Home
by Editors of ConsumerReports.org
4 stars Credibility Rating
Our Assessment Although this article doesn't contain the results of tests or product comparisons, it does provide expert opinion on some top smoke detector picks. Both dual-sensor and hardwired favorites are identified, and information is provided on what sets these models apart from the rest. General fire safety tips are also covered.
4. ConsumerGuide.com
Not Dated
Smoke Detectors
by Editors of ConsumerGuide.com
3 stars Credibility Rating
Our Assessment Consumer Guide offers descriptions of individual smoke detectors, some of which are labeled as Best Buys. The ratings here contain descriptions of each model's features, but it doesn't appear as though these models were tested. Models are also not compared with one another; they are simply assigned "expert" ratings. A fairly helpful buying guide covering smoke alarm basics is included.
5. USA Today Magazine
Jan. 2003
Where There's Smoke… What's New?
by Editors of USA Today Magazine
2 stars Credibility Rating
Our Assessment Editors review the First Alert Ultimate Smoke Alarm, which is the SA302CN model included in ConsumerSearch's Best Reviewed models. USA Today Magazine tests this smoke detector and reports on its consumer-friendly features, but doesn't rate it against any other smoke alarm.
6. Pronto.com
Not Dated
Smoke Detector Buying Guide
by Editors of Pronto.com
2 stars Credibility Rating
Our Assessment This article offers a very helpful buying guide and a glossary of common smoke detector terms. It also offers an expert pick based on the opinions of outside experts, as well as information about new advances in the smoke detector field. It does not, however, offer any testing information or comparison reviews.

Useful Links

     
 

This is our assessment of the review’s relevance, clarity of testing and thoroughness.

Read more about our Ratings Criteria by clicking the link at the top of the page.
 
 
 
  

Back to top