2009 Jaguar XF

Base MSRP: $49,200 to $63,700
Reviewed
September 2009
Email
2009 Jaguar XF

Pros
  • Strong acceleration
  • Powerful V8 performance
  • Potent supercharged model
  • Interior material quality
  • Comfortable cockpit
  • Lots of standard technology
  • High-tech, stylish dash
  • Respectable fuel economy for the segment
Cons
  • Cramped rear seats
  • 20-inch wheels compromise ride quality
  • Ergonomic quirks
  • Overassisted steering
  • Slow, unremarkable navigation
  • No all-wheel-drive option
  • Rear visibility issues

The 2009 Jaguar XF elicits strong opinions from reviewers, ranging from deep admiration and delight, to a smattering of disappointment. Quality craftsmanship, swift acceleration and graceful driving dynamics rank highest on the list of what auto writers like, while a space-challenged rear seat and lack of an all-wheel-drive option are among reviewers' dislikes.

The Jaguar XF earns a Popular Mechanics Automotive Excellence Award, is among Car and Driver's 10Best cars and is one of Consumer Guide's recommended picks. It also offers better fuel economy than many of its competitors. The base and premium models achieve 16 mpg city and 25 mpg highway, besting the V8-powered 2009 BMW 550i (Base MSRP: $60,400) and 2009 Mercedes-Benz E550 (Base MSRP: $61,700).

"It's a whole new type of cat… and we like it," writes Basem Wasef for Popular Mechanics. Citing the two 4.2 liter V8 power plants -- the standard 300-horsepower version, and the gutsier supercharged 420-horsepower engine -- he says the base engine offers strong, smooth acceleration, hitting 60 mph in a 6.2 seconds. But the supercharged 4.2 is "the born entertainer, and can do the task in 5.1 ticks."

Reviewer Wayne Cunningham, writing for CNET, says "The 2009 Jaguar XF offers a lot of luxury for the money with many unique high-tech touches and an exceptional audio system." Yet, citing run-of-the-mill suspension and navigation systems, he says the car "doesn't always deliver on its apparent promise."

Other reviewers including Edmunds.com's James Riswick, say the suspension turns bumpy over gnarled asphalt and concrete, but is otherwise well-tuned, achieving excellent balance between ride and handling. He's also one of several reviewers who believe the Jaguar XF's steering is on the light side for a performance car.

"The XF's handling felt controlled at low speeds and stable at high speeds," says Wasef, "and braking power is impressive in both models, with larger rotors in the Supercharged version offering increased stopping power."

Overall, testers heartily approve of the Jaguar XF's exterior styling. Reviewers at SeriousWheels.com say, "The defining element of the new XF as a true sporting Jaguar is its visual strength…the XF builds on already high standards of craftsmanship, quality and dynamic refinement."

Motor Trend's Arthur St. Antoine writes, "Make no styling judgments until you've seen the XF in person…. it radiates a modernity and sexiness that don't translate to the printed page."

Some testers feel the Jaguar XF has its drawbacks, like the rake of the rear glass, which tightens rear headroom. However, the Jaguar XF's trunk is larger than its competitors, and a folding rear seat further expands capacity.

"It's the fit between the human software and the machine-made hardware that makes the Jaguar XF so unique," writes Michael Jordan, executive editor of Edmunds Inside Line. "The XF invites you to be a part of the experience." He says this is evidenced in the red glow of the engine start button that pulses with a heartbeat-like rhythm upon entering the car, and in the intuitive spun-nickel rotary JaguarDrive Selector dial (in place of a traditional shifter) that rises out of the center console when the Jaguar XF engine comes to life.

"The cabin is full of grace notes," writes Dan Neil in his review for the Los Angeles Times. He adds, "Jag designers went with a broad, textured aluminum fascia across the dash, and wood paneling on the central console. Meanwhile, all instruments and satiny-silver controls are traced with a blue neon glow, like the keypad of a mobile phone."

Reviewers say the front seats support occupants like fine armchairs, while the wood trim accents are designed to appear "as structural elements of the car rather than glued-on bits of tree." Neil says, "Even the plastic pieces inside have a rich, latex-like feel. It's as inviting a design as any car in its class." He also agrees with fellow testers who find the rear seats cramped.

The Jaguar XF is offered in three trim levels, the normally aspirated (i.e. non-supercharged) XF and XF Premium including additional standard features such as leather, a "smart key" system with keyless entry, ventilated heated/cooled front seats, side mounted sensors with blind spot alert, a front parking aid, rear camera and bi-xenon headlamps. The Portfolio Package adds unique trim colors, a suede headliner, deep pile carpet and 15/12-way climate controlled seats. The XF Supercharged includes the 4.2-liter supercharged V8 with an active rear differential, computer-controlled suspension, quad exhaust pipes, Bowers & Wilkes 440-watt sound system, 16/12-way active ventilated seats, wood veneers and 20-inch wheels.

XF options include an unremarkable DVD-based navigation system, rear parking camera, radar-based blind-spot monitors and a 440-watt, 13-speaker Bowers and Wilkins audio system with Dolby surround sound (all standard on the XF Supercharged).

Standard safety equipment on all trim levels includes a full complement of airbags, plus a front-seat anti-whiplash system and "soft-landing" seatbelt retraction technology. A new Pedestrian Contact Sensing System helps mitigate pedestrian injury In the event of a collision.

expand
collapse
Where To Buy
 
 
CarsDirect.com

 
 
 

Our Sources

1. PopularMechanics.com

Popular Mechanics provides a thoughtful look at the Jaguar driving experience, features and powertrain. Wasef says the XF's qualities "should attract enthusiastic drivers who crave a luxurious sedan with a sporty personality."

Review: Jaguar XF Test Drive: Swift Kitty, Basem Wasef, Dec. 18, 2007

2. Motor Trend

This review starts with sliding into the cockpit, and continues with a thorough inside and out assessment of the Jaguar XF Supercharged.

Review: First Drive: Jaguar XF Supercharged, Arthur St. Antoine, Dec. 13, 2007

3. Edmunds Inside Line

Reviewer Michael Jordan says that next to the 2009 Jaguar XF, "any other sedan looks as cold and abstract as a lump of coal" in comparison to Audi, BMW, Cadillac and Lexus. Jordan also offers his perspective on the XF trims, powertrains and new supercharger.

Review: First Drive: 2009 Jaguar XF, Michael Jordan, Dec. 12, 2007

4. Los Angeles Times

Noting that the XF is a "very fine motorcar in a market segment that demands utter perfection," reviewer Dan Neil delivers a comprehensive and objective look at the car's nuances, as well as its shortcomings.

Review: 2009 Jaguar XF, Dan Neil, April 9, 2008

5. CNET

CNET's bottom line is that the Jaguar XF offers lots of luxury for the money, but doesn't always deliver on its apparent promise (i.e., run-of-the-mill suspension and navigation systems). Editors give the car a 3.5-star "very good" rating, while providing an enlightening account of their Jaguar XF road test.

Review: 2009 Jaguar XF, Wayne Cunningham, Aug. 6, 2008

6. Edmunds.com

This review concentrates on the new supercharged XF including an in-depth analysis of performance, comfort, design, fit and finish. The Edmunds Automotive Editor also does a good job of comparing the new Jag to its main competitors. Riswick says the car should appeal to "luxury car buyers who find German and Japanese entries to austere or soulless."

Review: Test Drive: 2009 Jaguar XF Supercharged, James Riswick

7. AOL Autos

This site provides an all-inclusive overview of the Jaguar XF including trim levels, the new styling, cabin appointments Also covered in detail are the modernized design, interior materials, ergonomics, performance and driving dynamics.

Review: 2009 Jaguar XF Overview, Editors of AOL Autos

8. TheCarConnection.com

Editors of TheCarConnection.com offer a thorough, if not exhausting, overview of the Jaguar XF that provides nuggets of information from the auto press, addressing performance, comfort and quality, safety and features.

Review: 2009 Jaguar XF, Marty Padgett

9. The Truth About Cars

While providing a good amount of solid information about the 2009 Jaguar XF, this reviewer plays devil's advocate more often than not; good information for buyers who want to be talked out of the Jaguar.

Review: 2009 Jaguar XF, Justin Berkowitz, March 7, 2008

Sports Sedans Runners Up:

2011 BMW 5 Series sedan Base MSRP: $45,050 to $62,500

6 picks including: FuelEconomy.gov, Car and Driver…

2011 Infiniti G Sedan Base MSRP: $32,000 to $41,550

6 picks including: FuelEconomy.gov, Edmunds.com…

2012 Audi A4 Base MSRP: $32,500 to $33,300

5 picks by top review sites.

2012 Audi A6 Base MSRP: $41,700 to $49,900

5 picks by top review sites.

2011 Cadillac CTS-V sedan Base MSRP: $62,360

3 picks including: FuelEconomy.gov, Insurance Institute for Highway Safety…

2011 Buick Regal Base MSRP: $26,360 to $28,860

3 picks including: Car and Driver, Cars.com…

2012 Audi A7 Base MSRP: $59,250

2 picks by top review sites.

Back to top