Steak: Reviews

Updated July 2008
You can get pretty much anything by mail order these days. And around the holidays, those Omaha Steaks catalogs make it seem awfully tempting. How does mail-order meat compare to what you'll find at the supermarket or at the butcher counter? We compared taste tests to find out.
 

Best steak overall, but expensive

Lobel's *Est. $53/lb. for strip steak Learn More

Cook's Illustrated Magazine: Editors test nine tenderloins in this review.

Cook's Illustrated Magazine: Editors taste-test six dry-aged, prime porterhouse steaks.

The Wall Street Journal: Charles Passy orders fresh porterhouse steaks from seven companies.

ConsumerReports.org: Consumer Reports has a team of tasters sample eight filet mignon steaks.

Cook's Illustrated Magazine: Reviewers test eight strip steaks in order to answer the question, "Can you buy a better steak through the mail?" Two Lobel's products, the Boneless Strip Steak and the Wagyu (Kobe-Style) Boneless Strip Steak, are considered.

The Wall Street Journal: For this article, Passy ordered New York strip steaks from five companies.

Kiplinger.com: Editors pitted Lobel's of New York against Niman Ranch of California in a head-to-head taste test.

CNNMoney.com: The top finisher in this review with a single tester is Lobel's never-frozen beef, and its Kobe beef is "meltingly tender, with a distinctive meat tang."

SeriousEats.com: Veteran food writer Ed Levine recommends Lobel's and Peter Luger beef.

Best value, hormone-free steak

Coleman Natural *Est. $15/lb. for strip steak Learn More

Cook's Illustrated Magazine: Cook's Illustrated tests nine strip steaks in this review -- seven available via mail order and two found in the supermarket.

Cook's Illustrated Magazine: Editors pit six USDA Choice strip steaks against six similar steaks from Coleman Natural, which does not use hormones or antibiotics.

TheNibble.com: The Nibble tests five specialty skirt steaks.

Best grass-fed steak

Alderspring Ranch Grass-Fed Beef *Est. $23/lb. for strip steak Learn More

Slate.com: Grass-fed beef from Alderspring Ranch wins this tasting of five steaks of various types, from wet-aged to dry-aged to "natural." The grass-fed beef was the instant winner, with testers raving about its flavor "that bursts out on every bite."

Back to top