Page: 5 of 5
SUV Tires - Light Truck Tires: Ratings of Sources
Total of 16 Sources

For an explanation of how we rank reviews, see our ratings criteria page.

1. ConsumerReports.org
Nov. 2008
All-Terrain Tires
by Editors of Consumer Reports
Our Assessment

Consumer Reports' editors test 14 all-terrain tires and find only two they can recommend. None of the tires tested is rated as "LT" or light-truck tires -- all carry a passenger-tire designation. The editors' rationale is that most people who buy these tires and vehicles rarely venture off-road, and thus these tires are adequate. Accordingly, Consumer Reports tests the tires only on pavement, with no off-road testing. For the first time, Consumer Reports tests treadwear this year, along with rolling resistance, comfort, noise and performance on dry, wet, snowy and icy roads.

expand

collapse

2. ConsumerReports.org
Nov. 2008
Ratings: All-season Light-truck Tires
by Editors of Consumer Reports
Our Assessment

In this report, Consumer Reports tests 20 all-season SUV and light-truck tires. For the first time, editors test treadwear. They find big differences between tires and sometimes, discrepancies with government treadwear ratings. The tires are also tested on wet, dry, snowy and icy roads, with editors judging their comfort and noise levels. Consumer Reports is one of the few sources that tests rolling resistance, which can be a factor in gas mileage.

expand

collapse

4x4 Truck Tires & Wheels
by Editors of Petersen's 4 Wheel & Off Road
Our Assessment

Testers here evaluate new off-road tires as they come on the market. In single-tire reviews, they thoroughly explain performance in mud, on rocks and on the highway. However, editors almost always find some reason to recommend each tire, and the reviews could be more critical. Editors do pit six monster tires against each other in one head-to-head test, and the Super Swamper LTB and Super Swamper Irok come out best overall.

expand

collapse

4. Four Wheeler
Not Dated
Off Road Tires & Wheels
by Editors of Four Wheeler
Our Assessment

Testers here try out tires in hub-deep mud pits and on the highway, as well as on rocky jaunts such as Utah's Wasatch-Cache National Forest. Dozens of tires get thorough write-ups, but these are uniformly complimentary and thus not particularly helpful for narrowing your choices. Testers do not usually rate tires against one another, except for one head-to-head test orchestrated by Hankook, which the Hankook tire wins.

expand

collapse

5. Tire Rack
As of Feb. 2009
Tire Survey
by Contributors to Tire Rack
Our Assessment

Tire Rack invites anyone to participate in its cumulative tire survey, which now boasts more than 140,000 contributions since 1997. Owners rate tires in up to 11 categories and are asked to rate their likelihood of purchasing the same tire again. Winners among all-season truck tires are the Goodyear Fortera SL Edition and General Grabber HTS. Among summer tires, the Continental ContiCrossContact UHP and Michelin XPS Rib are noted, and among all-terrain tires, the Michelin LTX A/T2 and Firestone Destination M/T get top billing.

expand

collapse

6. Tire Rack
Aug. 15, 2008
Sooner or Later You'll Own Generals -- Maybe Now Is the Time
by Editors of Tire Rack
Our Assessment Tire Rack regularly conducts expert tire tests. The most recent light-truck tire winner is the General Grabber HTS, which bests staffers' former favorite, the Pirelli Scorpion STR, in this head-to-head comparison of three all-season light truck/SUV tires (the Bridgestone Dueler H/L Alenza finishes third). Testers evaluate the tires on highways and back roads, as well as on wet and dry test tracks.
Tire Ratings
by Editors of NHTSA
Our Assessment

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration requires manufacturers to test their tires for treadwear, traction and heat resistance, and to label the tires with these ratings. Consumers can look up tire ratings, either by brand or by rating. NHTSA offers thorough explanations of the ratings, but it does not recommend any tire over another, and several light-truck tire lines are left out. Defect and recall alerts are also posted here.

expand

collapse

8. Off-Road.com
As of Feb. 2009
Reviews
by Editors of Off-Road.com
Our Assessment This website covers everything off-road: dirt bikes, snowmobiles and four-wheelers, along with 4x4 trucks and Jeeps. Reviews are posted for several off-road tires, but the site layout makes them hard to find. The reviews tab on the home page is a good starting point. Testers recommend tires from Pro Comp, Toyo, Hankook, Dunlop and Goodyear in single-product reviews.
9. Canadian Driver
July 19, 2007
Michelin LTX AT2 Light Truck Tire
by James Bergeron
Our Assessment

Canadian reviewer James Bergeron accepts an invitation to Michelin's Alabama launch of the new LTX A/T2 light-truck tire. He admits he is inexperienced with trucks and off-roading, and he relies heavily upon Michelin's corporate description of its tire in this review. He concludes, however, that the tire propels the test truck, a Ford F-150, nicely up and down extreme inclines, over rocks and through streams, while remaining as quiet and smooth on the pavement as a luxury touring tire.

expand

collapse

10. Canadian Driver
Apr. 18, 2006
Tire Test: Pirelli Scorpion ATR
by Jil McIntosh
Our Assessment

Reviewer Jil McIntosh travels to the Las Vegas Motor Speedway for the launch of Pirelli's Scorpion ATR tire, to see if it really is equally at home on and off the pavement. A freak hail-and-ice storm doesn't bother the Scorpion ATR on the test track, she reports. It has no problem holding a heavy Hummer on a muddy, nearly vertical slope. Although the trail test through Valley of Fire State Park never really strays from the gravel, McIntosh notes that the same can be said of most light truck and SUV drivers.

expand

collapse

11. Offroaders.com
As of Feb. 2009
Mud Terrain MT Tires
by Contributors to Offroaders.com
Our Assessment Readers post written reviews and numeric scores for off-road tires at Offroaders.com, and editors of the site compile them into average scores for each tire. When we checked, six currently available tires had achieved scores of at least nine out of 10, with at least 10 owner reviews (some boast nearly 80 reviews), including tires from Super Swamper, Dick Cepek, Kumho, Pit Bull and Firestone.
12. Offroaders.com
As of Feb. 2009
All Terrain AT Tires
by Contributors to Offroaders.com
Our Assessment All-terrain tires get fewer reviews than mud tires from users at Offroaders.com, but they do merit their own ratings chart. When we checked, only one tire had collected more than a few reviews: the BFGoodrich All Terrain T/A KO, which had more than 100 comments. Eighty-five percent of those reviewers said they would recommend this tire.
13. CarReview.com
As of Feb. 2009
Tires Top Picks
by Contributors to CarReview.com
Our Assessment CarReview.com collects user reviews of tires, with 486 models listed. Many of those have no reviews posted, however. Editors of the site have chosen six Top Picks, tires that have scored at least four out of five points with between five and 73 users reviewing them. One of these is a current light truck/SUV tire: the Goodyear Wrangler AT/S.
14. Epinions.com
As of Feb. 2009
Car Tires
by Contributors to Epinions.com
Our Assessment

Nearly 400 tire models have accumulated reviews from consumers who post at Epinions. Several tires have just a handful of reviews, which are dated in some cases. Different tire types are mixed together -- snow tires, big off-road truck tires and standard car tires -- but if you have a specific tire in mind, you can do a keyword search. Five currently available SUV/truck tires have achieved a rating of at least four out of five points with more than 10 reviews posted: Goodyear Wrangler MT/R, Michelin Cross Terrain SUV, Michelin LTX M/S, BFGoodrich Mud Terrain T/A KM and BFGoodrich All Terrain T/A KO.

expand

collapse

Goodyear Fortera SUV Tires
by Grant Davis
Our Assessment

Writer Grant Davis installs a set of brand-new Goodyear Fortera SUV tires on his Toyota 4Runner and quickly becomes enamored with them following a two-hour wet-driving adventure. A summer storm convinces Davis that the Fortera is a superior wet-performer that really resists hydroplaning. Davis notes that while other vehicles were stopped, he was able to continue driving the 4Runner at speeds up to 75 miles per hour. Although he appreciates the SilentArmor Kevlar layer, the wet performance of the tire is what immediately impresses him.

expand

collapse

Ampersand Extra
by Andrew Bornhop
Our Assessment In this test drive conducted at Goodyear's testing facility, reviewer Andrew Bornhop compares Goodyear's Fortera SilentArmor and the Michelin Cross Terrain SUV. Both are reasonably quiet, he writes, but adds that the Fortera outperforms the Michelin over bumps and in the wet, with a "noticeably better grip than the Michelin." No other light truck/SUV tires receive ratings here.

Back to top