Page: 8 of 8
Table Saws: Ratings of Sources
Total of 20 Sources
1. Fine Woodworking Tools & Shops 2008
Dec. 2007
Hybrid Tablesaws
by Tom Begnal
Our Assessment

Ten hybrid table saws are tested here, on wood as thick as 2.75-inch maple. Each saw is also tested for arbor flange runout, rip-fence deflection and blade-to-slot parallelism. The Woodtek 148-271 gets top ranking not only as a best value, but also for capacity and overall performance. The Grizzly G0478 hybrid table saw ranks at the top for needing no adjustment at all in blade-to-slot parallelism; all the table saws are rated for ease of adjustment. A brief review in the April 2008 issue of Fine Woodworking recommends the new Bosch 4100DG-09 portable table saw. An earlier review praises the SawStop cabinet saw.

expand

collapse

2. Popular Woodworking
Nov. 2007
Hybrid Saws
by Troy Sexton
Our Assessment

This detailed review compares six hybrid saws -- starting with their assembly, then running them through tests of power, vibration and accuracy. Each saw is also evaluated for ease of use, including blade guards, fences and dust collection. A July 2007 article praises the safety features on the new Bosch 4100 and DeWalt portable table saws, and an August 2007 review praises the blade guard on the new Bosch. A special issue on table saws compares the two top cabinet saws, the SawStop and the Powermatic PM2000, and an article in the July 2007 issue compares new table saw safety systems and also previews the new SawStop contractor saw.

expand

collapse

3. Taunton's 2008 Tool Guide
Sept. 2007
10-in. Cabinet Saws
by Roland Johnson and Taunton Press Editors
Our Assessment

In addition to summarizing the results of a June 2006 review of cabinet table saws in Fine Woodworking, this review also reports on the results from a survey of over 9,000 readers of Fine Woodworking and Fine Homebuilding magazines. A separate brief review recommends the DeWalt DW745 jobsite table saw when equipped with a better blade. A later review in the July 2008 issue of Fine Homebuilding tests the new SawStop contractor saw, and the earlier 2007 Tool Guide covers portable table saws and reviews the Hitachi C10LA hybrid saw. The 2006 Tool Guide reviews nine mid-sized contractor and hybrid table saws. A 2005 review in Fine Woodworking compares seven ten-inch portable table saws that come with folding stands and extension tables.

expand

collapse

4. ConsumerReports.org
June 2007
Miter & Table Saws
by Editors of Consumer Reports
Our Assessment

This review ranks ten portable table saws, picking one as the best buy. Based on objective tests, each table saw gets ratings for accuracy, speed, ease of use (including blade changes), rip precision and edge finish (cutting crown molding). The portable table saw that rates highest for rip precision isn't the same model that scores highest for crosscut accuracy, and the only saw that gets the highest rating for both features loses points for edge finish on molding. In other words, none of these portable saws will perform with excellence on every task. A separate review in the June 2007 issue does test the SawStop cabinet saw to see if its safety features work as promised.

expand

collapse

5. Tools of the Trade
Nov. 2006
Hybrid Table Saws
by Sean Martin
Our Assessment This review compares eight hybrid table saws (with ten-inch blades) from assembly through tests that rip stacks of lumber in a snowboard shop. Evaluations are detailed, covering assembly time, features, accessories, precision, power, dust collection and safety. A 2005 review here compares six 10-inch, 3-hp cabinet table saws, and a 2008 Editors' Choice award goes to the new SawStop contractor saw.
6. Workbench Magazine
June 2006
Table Saw Shootout!
by Bill Link
Our Assessment

Based on in-depth testing and evaluation of parts, this review compares ten 3-hp, left-tilt cabinet saws equipped with T-square-style fences. The review is notable for its clear explanations of important factors in performance, including the type of belt, shape of gear teeth and of course, the rip fence -- finding that some fences are now better than the Biesemeyer. In Feb. 2006, Workbench editors named The Powermatic PM2000 one of the top ten innovative tools for 2006, for its riving knife and integral retracting castors. A June 2006 review covers the Metabo TS250 portable table saw.

expand

collapse

7. Woodworker's Journal
Oct. 2005
Tool Review: Raising the Bar on Contractor's Saws
by Rob Johnstone
Our Assessment

Tests of eight contractor saws (including a preproduction SawStop) lead to the conclusion that all these saws are much better for woodworking than the contractor saws available earlier. Only small differences distinguish the best from the worst, and all perform well overall. In the June 2008 issue, George Vondriska gives the SawStop cabinet saw a long, detailed review based on extensive tests plus interviews with users, and an online Dec. 2007 review by Michael Dresdner covers the JET Deluxe Xacta cabinet saw. An earlier April 2005 review compares five benchtop table saws that come with rolling stands.

expand

collapse

8. Kevin Kelley Cool Tools
June 22, 2006
SawStop Table Saw
by Ben Bishop
Our Assessment

This review of the SawStop cabinet saw goes beyond detailed coverage of the safety features (riving knife, well-placed shut-off paddle switch, convenient blade guard and -- of course -- the unique sensor that stops the blade if it encounters flesh). Woodworker Ben Bishop also praises the SawStop's performance and ease of use. He finds cuts even with the stock blade to be "smoother than what I get from my surface planer," and he adds that all adjustments are easy to make and to repeat. Dust collection is also very good.

expand

collapse

9. Benchmark
As of Sept. 2008
Table Saw Reviews
by Phil Bumbalough
Our Assessment

Professional woodworker Phil Bumbalough reviews table saws of various types and price ranges here. He uses the $7,000 European Hammer B3 cabinet saw as his reference point, though he judges its fences to be inferior and even unsafe. He likes the Ridgid TS3650 contractor saw as a budget choice, because of its mobile base and high-end features for the money. The right-tilt Ryobi BT3100 (now the Craftsman 21829 Professional) is another good budget choice.

expand

collapse

10. Wood Magazine
Oct. 2007
The Best Tool I Ever Bought
by Bill Krier, Editor-in-Chief and other Editors and Contributors
Our Assessment Wood Magazine's editor-in-chief names the Powermatic 66 cabinet saw as the best tool investment he ever made, because it added so much more accuracy and ease of use to his woodworking after he moved up to it from a contractor table saw.
11. Just4Fun.org
2005
Tool Reviews: SawStop Cabinet Saw
by Editor of Just4Fun.org
Our Assessment

An engineer and hobbyist woodworker reviews the 5-hp SawStop table saw in detail, based on his own experience with it. The review includes some comparisons with the 3-hp Delta 36-842 UniSaw, and it covers SawStop pros and cons well. The author also praises SawStop customer support as outstanding. Drawbacks include lack of a mobile base and collecting dust at the blade -- which the author finds doesn't work as well as collecting it at the bottom.

expand

collapse

12. The Woodshop
Not Dated
Grizzly 1023S Table Saw Review
by Jack Loganbill
Our Assessment

Woodworker Jack Loganbill compares the Grizzly 1023S cabinet saw with the Powermatic 66, based on his own testing and use. If you're considering the Grizzly table saw, this is an excellent review to read because it's so detailed and well illustrated, delineating all the pros and cons. Loganbill concludes that although the Powermatic table saw is superior in casting, wiring, trunnions -- in every way, really -- it doesn't make any significant difference in the quality of the woodworking you can achieve with it. Hence, the Grizzly table saw is an excellent buy.

expand

collapse

13. Amazon.com
As of Sept. 2008
Table Saw Reviews
by Contributors to Amazon.com
Our Assessment Owner-written ratings of table saws are especially easy to browse here, since the list of models shows not only the average rating, but the number of reviews on which it's based. You can also sort the whole list to put the highest-rated models at the top, and there's a good mix of portable, contractor and cabinet saws here.
14. HomeDepot.com
As of Sept. 2008
Table Saws
by Contributors to HomeDepot.com
Our Assessment Most of the table saws sold here get reviews and ratings from owners, with the less expensive saws accumulating the most reviews. Owners provide useful comments.
15. Lowes.com
As of Sept. 2008
Table Saws
by Contributors to Lowes.com
Our Assessment Lowe's publishes owners' ratings of table saws (on a five-point scale), plus more specific ratings for features, value, design, quality and ease of use -- but without any comments. Not surprisingly, ratings for quality drop sharply for the portable table saws priced under $300, but two Firestorm budget table saws rank slightly above the Task Force model.
16. Sears.com
As of Sept. 2008
Table Saws
by Contributors to Sears.com
Our Assessment Quite a few Craftsman table saws have accumulated enough owner-written reviews to make the average ratings useful, but the more expensive Craftsman Pro, Bosch, Makita and Jet table saws have not.
17. ToolCrib.com
July 2008
Contractor Saw Face Off: Rigid 3650 vs. Delta 36-979
by Editors and contributors to ToolCrib.com
Our Assessment This brief comparison review of two of the leading contractor saws is based on comments from readers at the Woodnet forum, but adds useful summaries and links to more information. A similar review at this site in April 2008 compares the SawStop and Powermatic 2000 cabinet saws. Both reviews just summarize woodworkers' preferences, without any testing.
18. OnlineTips.org
Not Dated
Makita Table Saw Review
by Carlo Morelli
Our Assessment This Canadian review covers three Makita table saw models, noting that the miter gauge on the Makita 2703 is its weak point, while the Makita 2704 (the one designed to rip 4X lumber in one pass) makes much more accurate cuts. Some testing is documented, but no comparisons are made with other brands.
19. Wood Central
As of Sept. 2008
Table Saw reviews
by Contributors to WoodCentral.com
Our Assessment

Wood Central lists a number of in-depth reviews of table saws by readers, including an early review of the SawStop cabinet saw, but there's no overall scoring or rating system. Still, if you have your choice narrowed down, these reviews are thorough and insightful, and often well illustrated with photos of details hard to find anywhere else. Table saw fences and other accessories are also well covered at this site.

expand

collapse

20. New Woodworker
As of Sept. 2008
Table Saw Reviews
by Tom Hintz
Our Assessment Professional woodworker Tom Hintz provides well-illustrated, detailed reviews of nine table saws based on his own tests and use, with some comparison among them. Most reviews offer few criticisms, so the reviews seem to lack objectivity.

Back to top