Page: 7 of 7
Teeth Whitening: Ratings of Sources
Total of 30 Sources
Home-Based Chemically-Induced Whitening of Teeth in Adults
by H. Hasson, et al.
Our Assessment

The authors seek to determine whether whitening is effective and safe according to 25 studies published in scientific journals. The conclusion is that whitening products work. Differences in efficacy between the products are mainly due to the levels of the active ingredients, hydrogen peroxide and carbamide peroxide. Tooth sensitivity and gum irritation are the most common side effects. The products with high concentrations of hydrogen peroxide are associated with greater tooth sensitivity. It's noted that all of the trials were sponsored by the manufacturers of tooth whitening products.

expand

collapse

Natural Beauty -- Worry-Free Tooth-whitening
by Editors of Alternative Medicine Magazine
Our Assessment

The unidentified writer reviews two professional treatments: whitening gel activated by laser, heat-light or "blue" light and custom-fitted dental trays with whitening gels. The custom-fitted trays are preferred for their lower cost. The over-the-counter products tried were gels with trays, painted-on gels and strips. Testers prefer the painted-on gel. The dentist states that these approaches are time consuming and require patients to "follow-through," but that their cost savings could be an advantage.

expand

collapse

3. National Public Radio
Apr. 10, 2008
A Simple Formula for Whitening Teeth
by Allison Aubrey
Our Assessment Light activated bleach treatments are discussed at length in this article. Experts are at odds as to whether the light in these systems makes a significant difference to the whitening process. One dentist points out that results can vary greatly from one patient to the next. He recommends custom-fit dental trays first because they provide predictable results.
Tooth Whitening Leads in Cosmetic Dentistry
by Matthew Shulman
Our Assessment

The author of this article points out that teeth whitening is the number one procedure performed by cosmetic dentists today. Tooth discoloration occurs for several reasons and there are various treatment options available. Each treatment is discussed and although they are not ranked, the author points out that dentist-supervised "at-home" treatments provide similar results to those performed in the dentist's office, for a much more affordable price. He says that over-the-counter products are good for touch-ups.

expand

collapse

5. CBSNews.com
May 25, 2007
Tooth Whiteners: Something for Everyone
by Julie Chen reporting for The Early Show
Our Assessment

Dentist Nancy Rosen discusses five over-the-counter tooth-whitening approaches: strips, ampoules, gel trays, paint-on gels and pens and toothpastes. Dr. Rosen states that the whitening treatments administered by dentists, "tend to be stronger and work more quickly," but she does offer praise for some over-the-counter approaches. Dr. Rosen has highest marks for Go Smile Advanced Formula B1. Dr. Rosen does not recommend store-bought gel tray systems. The trays are not custom-fit and often have too much gel, which can bleach teeth unevenly and irritate gums.

expand

collapse

6. 85th General Session of the IADR
Presented Mar. 2007
In-Office Bleaching vs. Combined Bleaching: An Evaluation Clinical
by L.C. Vergara, et al.
Our Assessment This study compares the effectiveness of in-office bleaching with combined bleaching in ten subjects. The in-office technique is a product with 35% hydrogen peroxide (Whiteness HP). The combined technique utilizes a product with 10% carbamide peroxide (Nite White ACP). Both techniques whiten teeth, with no significant differences between them.
We Test Five Tooth Whiteners, From Gel to the Dentist's Chair
by Elena De Lisser
Our Assessment

This roundup of five tooth-whitening methods finds the Zoom! Chairside Whitening System at the dentist's office the most effective. Colgate Simply White's paint-on formula (no longer available) comes out ahead of Crest Whitestrips in this review because testers don't like the drool factor of the Whitestrips. Swabplus Advanced Dental Whitening System and Rembrandt Plus Superior Bleaching Kit (no longer available) are rated far behind, producing zero and one shade improvement, respectively. Unfortunately, this review is now very out of date.

expand

collapse

8. TeethWhiteningReviews.com
As of Aug. 2008
Teeth Whitening Product Reviews and Ratings
by Contributors to TeethWhiteningReviews.com
Our Assessment

This website is dedicated to teeth whitening products. No products are sold here, but the owner posts reviews of several popular teeth whitening treatments. Consumers rate and review these products, as well. There are not a lot of user reviews posted, but it is notable that the two products with the highest number of reviews, Aquafresh White Trays and Celebrity Sexy Teeth, both receive low ratings. Celebrity Sexy Teeth is also labeled as a "scam."

expand

collapse

Best of Beauty 2007
by Editors of Allure
Our Assessment Allure editors, along with cosmetics chemists and dermatologists, test nearly 2,000 products and choose 187 as the best in their categories. Listerine Whitening Quick Dissolving Strips are listed under "Quick Fixes" and the Rembrandt Whitening Touch Up Pen is listed under "First Aid."
10. Drugstore.com
As of Aug. 2008
Teeth-whitening
by Contributors to Drugstore.com
Our Assessment There are many recent reviews at Drugstore.com for teeth-whitening products and, in general, the comments here mirror those at Amazon.com, with Crest Whitestrip products the clear standout. Aquafresh White Trays have more positive reviews here than on Amazon.com, but they still garner complaints of pain.
11. Amazon.com
As of Aug. 2008
Teeth whiteners
by Contributors to Amazon.com
Our Assessment

Whitening products inspire impassioned reviews at Amazon.com. The Crest Whitestrips products receive the most reviews, many of which are positive. Amazon also has reviews of lesser known products, such as Nite White ACP 22% and Opalescence PF 20%. Most of the product reviews appraise the change in whiteness, the ease of use and any associated pain. Aquafresh White Trays have many reviews that describe intense tooth and gum pain.

expand

collapse

12. Redbook
Dec. 2007
The Best Beauty Booty of 2007 - MVP Beauty Awards
by Krista Bennett, Cheryl Kramer Kaye, Crystal Martin
Our Assessment

In this article, Redbook lists the 45 best beauty products of the year, categorizing them by colors with green for eco-friendly, pink for "girly, gotta-have-it," gold for luxury and black for basic, everyday products. Crest Whitestrips Daily Multicare makes the black list because it produces the same results as earlier whiteners in less time. Products listed are not rated or compared to any others.

expand

collapse

13. Redbook
Oct. 2007
Cheryl Checks it Out: Teeth Whiteners
by Cheryl Kramer Kaye
Our Assessment Staff members of Redbook magazine test several teeth whitening products, including gum, mouthwash and even a lip gloss. Each staffer shares her experience, but products are not rated or compared.
14. Seattle Post-Intelligencer
Dec. 20, 2005
Whitening: How our lab rats fared
by Susan Phinney
Our Assessment Five volunteers each test one at-home whitening product. The Rembrandt 2-Hour Whitener lightens the tester's teeth "about two shades." The tester for Go Smile Advance Formula B1 says she saw results after four days. The volunteer who tried Crest Whitestrips calls them "disgusting" and quit before the test was over. Each tester's experience is noted, but products are not ranked in this article.
15. 85th General Session of the IADR
Presented Mar. 24, 2007
Safety and Efficacy Results of Whole Mouth Tooth-whitening Treatments
by L.A. Stockert, et al.
Our Assessment

In this blind trial, 114 testers were randomized to Crest Whitestrips Classic, Crest Whitestrips Premium or an experimental product consisting of a 10% hydrogen peroxide gel in a flexible tray. The three products all produced statistically significant tooth shade reductions compared to baseline and after five and seven days of treatment. All three had similar adverse events (not listed). This study was sponsored by GlaxoSmithKline.

expand

collapse

16. 85th General Session of the IADR
Presented Mar. 22, 2007
Safety and Efficacy of Two Tooth-whitening Regimens in Teenagers
by K.J. Donly, et al
Our Assessment

Crest Whitestrips Professional 6.5% are tested against an unnamed 6.0% hydrogen peroxide strip, with 45 adolescents ages 12 to 18. The Crest Whitestrips Professional are used for 30 minutes per application, and the 6.0 hydrogen strips are used for five minutes per application. Whitening occurs in both groups, but it was greater in the 30-minute application group. The most common adverse events were tooth sensitivity and oral irritation, which occurs more often with the 30-minute application. This study was sponsored by Procter & Gamble, which makes the Crest product.

expand

collapse

17. Good Housekeeping
Mar. 2006
Skip These Whiteners
by Editors of Good Housekeeping
Our Assessment

Good Housekeeping tests two over-the-counter whitening products for efficacy. The group of testers is far too small to be considered scientific, but the results are still interesting. The White Light System lightened teeth by approximately one shade for all three testers who used it, but results faded back to the original color after one week for two of the testers. KlearAction Whitening Light System produced results for only one tester. Editors recommend Crest Whitestrips Classic, which they say can lighten teeth up to three shades.

expand

collapse

18. Psychology Today
May/June 2007
Beauty Beat: Brighter Teeth, Better Lifer?
by Marissa Kristal
Our Assessment Researchers at the University of Michigan review studies measuring the efficacy and safety of teeth whitening treatments. They conclude that the treatments are safe and effective, but point out that the studies reviewed only lasted two weeks and any potential long-term effects are still unknown. Several products are recommended, but it is not clear whether they were tested.
19. Prevention.com
Aug. 2007
Get Healthy Teeth for Life
by No author listed
Our Assessment

This article discusses oral hygiene concerns for people ages 50 and older. The article ends with a list of four tooth whitening products that exemplify the descriptions of "easy," "portable," "fast" and "comfortable." Surprisingly, their pick for "comfortable" is Aquafresh White Trays, which are more frequently noted for their discomfort. It's not clear how much testing was conducted for this article.

expand

collapse

The Best Teeth Whiteners
by Editors of Real Simple
Our Assessment This article lists the best over-the-counter tooth-whitening products in four categories: toothpaste, ampoules (swabs), strips and trays. The article makes mention of a few likes and dislikes of testers, but it's not clear exactly how many people tested these, or in what manner, so it's hard to put too much faith in these findings.
The New Ways to Whiten Teeth
by No author listed
Our Assessment Dentist Louis Siegelman evaluates over-the-counter whitening products. He discusses four products, which are tops in the following categories: Dramatic Whitening, Fast & Easy, No Privacy Required and Hall of Fame. It's not clear if these products are subjected to any testing at all.
22. Redbook
June 2007
Gotta Get It: White Teeth
by Editors of Redbook
Our Assessment

Editors of Redbook magazine list three options for a brighter smile. Crest Whitestrips Daily Multicare are recommended, as is QuickWhite, an in-office treatment that uses diamond dust and a special light to whiten teeth. A lip gloss that uses specialized pigments to counteract yellow tones in teeth is listed as "the cheap fix." Products are not ranked or compared to others and it is not clear whether they were tested.

expand

collapse

23. People
June/July 2007
Beauty Q&A
by Editors of People Magazine
Our Assessment Editors of People magazine claim that new over-the-counter whitening products work just as effectively as older versions, but are "quicker and easier to use." Both Crest Whitestrips Daily Multicare and Aquafresh White Trays are suggested, but it is not clear whether any actual testing was performed. No other products are compared or mentioned.
Tooth Whiteners Weaken Enamel
by B. Halford
Our Assessment

Michelle E. Dickinson, a staff scientist with Minneapolis-based instrument maker Hysitron, tests the effects of a 10% carbamide peroxide treatment and a 35% carbamide peroxide solution on extracted human teeth. She found that both products have a negative effect on tooth enamel. The 10% solution decreased tooth hardness by 22% on both regions of the tooth. The 35% solution decreased the hardness of the tooth's chewing surface by 82%.

expand

collapse

25. The Wall Street Journal
Jan. 11, 2005
Avoiding the Dentist's Chair: Examining Claims of Over-the-Counter Whiteners
by Tara Parker-Pope
Our Assessment

Health reporter Tara Parker-Pope does a thorough job explaining how various teeth-whitening options work and what several studies and dentists say about them. Parker-Pope says that the best results still appear to come from using peroxide gels in custom-made dental trays. With over-the-counter products, she suggests whitening your top teeth first so you can judge the results against your unwhitened lower teeth.

expand

collapse

Teeth Whitening: Customize Your Bright, White Smile
by Linda Dyett
Our Assessment The author of this informative article claims that teeth whitening works, though at varying degrees depending on the individual and the type of treatment used. The different types of tooth staining are discussed along with various causes and treatment options. Specific products are not mentioned.
27. ConsumerReports.org
Feb. 2008
Wise Choices in the Dentist's Office
by Editors of Consumer Reports
Our Assessment Consumer Reports discusses common dental treatments and various options for each. Editors explain that all teeth whitening products use bleach to lighten teeth. They warn that any of the available treatments can cause temporary sensitivity and that results are temporary. Specific products are not discussed or recommended.
28. WebMD.com
June 2008
Can Teeth-whitening Become an Addiction?
by L. Johnston
Our Assessment

The author interviews dentists to investigate whether extended use of whitening products can become dangerous. In rare cases, teeth can become transparent. The experts say that pain can act as a guide as to when a product should be removed. According to a dentist who works at Procter & Gamble, "there has been no evidence of any large-scale abuse or negative effects from people doing at-home teeth-whitening."

expand

collapse

29. WebMD.com
Oct. 2007
Dental Health: Teeth-whitening
by No author listed
Our Assessment This article provides an review of teeth-whitening options. No specific brands or products are discussed, but the general information is interesting.
30. CosmeticsCop.com
Not Dated
Whiter Teeth
by Paula Begoun
Our Assessment Beauty specialist, Paula Begoun discusses some of the causes of discolored teeth, along with various solutions. Begoun suggests that bleaching the teeth is best for serious stains, but may not be effective for everyone. She claims that no whitening system is very effective for grayed or completely yellowed teeth. No products are specifically rated.

Back to top