Here's what the experts say about buying a toaster oven.

  • Consider the alternatives. The most credible reviews say that if all you want is evenly browned toast, you're better off buying a toaster and using your full-size oven for tasks like roasting chicken or toasting nuts. See our toasters report for further information. Note that you can buy single-slot toasters that accommodate long slices of artisan-style bread.
  • Measure your counter space. Toaster ovens usually require three or four inches of clearance in the back for heat dispersal. Some have crumb trays that must be emptied from the back, requiring even more square footage.
  • Decide whether you need a broil setting. You'll generally find this in mid-range and premium toaster ovens, but not in less expensive models. Of the models included in ConsumerSearch Best Reviewed section, the Sanyo Toasty and Sanyo SK-VF7S lack a broil function.
  • Removable (rather than hinged) crumb trays are easier to clean. Crumb trays that can be removed from the front are more convenient than those that must be removed from the back. All four models in ConsumerSearch Best Reviewed have removable crumb trays.
  • A nonstick or continuous-clean interior also speeds cleanup. Some models have a self-cleaning interior, which causes food particles to disintegrate.
  • Look for safety features. These include auto shutoff and a timer that shuts the oven off when timed cooking ends (and not just after a certain number of hours).
  • You can find a decent microwave oven for about the same price as a mid-range toaster oven. Microwaves, of course, are not adept at toasting and browning, though they do heat leftovers more quickly. See our report on microwavesfor more information.
  • Speed cookers combine microwave and toaster oven functionality and are more adept at roasting and browning. You can also bake in these models (though some reviewers say the results are not as appetizing as foods conventionally baked). Speed cookers are expensive; most cost upwards of $500. You can read more about them in our report on microwaves.
Sponsored Links

Back to top