Toaster Ovens: Expert and User Reviews

In this report

Toaster Ovens: Ratings of Sources

1. ConsumerReports.org Toaster Oven Ratings, ConsumerReports.org
Credibility:
Editors of ConsumerReports.org test a wide variety of toaster ovens for baking, broiling, ease of use and cleaning, color range, full batch and successive batch performance, and the ability to evenly toast one slice of bread. There are quite a few consumer reviews on toaster ovens as well, but editors do not take them into account. Products are rated on a scale up to 100 and are ranked against each other as well.
2. Cook's Illustrated Toaster Ovens, Cook's Illustrated, July 2014
Credibility:
This test was originally published in Cook's Illustrated magazine in March of 2011, and was updated in July 2014. Eleven toaster ovens are tested by editors of Cook's Illustrated. The ovens are evaluated for cooking performance, accuracy, toasting and ease of use. Two are Highly Recommended, one is Recommended (and is designated as a Best Buy), four are Recommended with Reservations, and four are Not Recommended.
3. TheSweetHome.com The Best Toaster Oven, TheSweetHome.com, Sept. 29, 2015
Credibility:
In the latest update of TheSweetHome.com's toaster oven report, Brendan Nystedt adds 20 hours of additional testing on some new ovens; resulting in a shakeup of two of the top picks. All of these toaster ovens are tested by toasting breads, baking cookies and cooking pizza bites. The Panasonic Flash Xpress, Cuisinart TOB-260 and the Hamilton Beach 31230 ultimately come out on top.
4. CNET Don't call them toasters: We test out high-end toaster ovens, CNET, Sept. 8, 2013
Credibility:
Ry Crist and other CNET editors test four popular toaster ovens, including the Breville BOV800XL, the Panasonic Flash Xpress, the Frigidaire Professional 6-slice and the Cuisinart CSO-300. Each oven gets a thorough test and review, including pictures and comparisons to other tested ovens, and is given an up-to-5-star score.
5. Amazon.com Toaster Ovens, Amazon.com, As of November 2015
Credibility:
Amazon.com has hundreds of toaster ovens in all models and price ranges. It is an excellent source for real world reviews of toaster ovens over the long-term and to see how they hold up over time. It's also a great way to judge performance and ease-of-use from actual home cooks. The top-rated toaster ovens get hundreds, some thousands, of customer reviews.
6. Walmart.com Toaster Ovens, Walmart.com, As of November 2015
Credibility:
Toaster ovens are well-represented at Walmart.com, which is a particularly good resource for evaluating reviews of more affordable toaster ovens, such as Hamilton Beach and Black & Decker. Many of these appliances get hundreds of reviews, and tend to be higher-rated than the same item at other sites. Reviewers have the option of noting if they would recommend the toaster oven to a friend.
7. BestBuy.com Toaster Ovens, BestBuy.com, As of November 2015
Credibility:
Toaster ovens at BestBuy.com don't get quite as many reviews as at Amazon.com or Walmart.com, but some get several hundred. They also carry a very good selection, with quite a few having overall averages of more than 4 stars. Reviewers can also say if they would recommend the product to others.
8. BedBathAndBeyond.com Toaster Ovens, BedBathAndBeyond.com, As of November 2015
Credibility:
BedBathandBeyond.com again has fewer toaster ovens overall and they have fewer reviews, but it's still a good resource for some of the most popular products. Reviews are also broken down by both value and quality, and reviewers have the opportunity to indicate whether or not they would recommend the product to a friend.
9. Macys.com Toaster Ovens , Macys.com, As of November 2015
Credibility:
Macys.com carries a relatively scant number of some higher-end toaster ovens, although some have a decent number of reviews. Cuisinart, Breville and KitchenAid are the top-rated products here. Reviewers not only can recommend the product, they also often provide demographic information, like their level of cooking skill.
10. Good Housekeeping Toaster Oven Reviews, Good Housekeeping, September 2011
Credibility:
Testers at the Good Housekeeping Research Institute (GHRI) test 34 toaster ovens and give each a thorough overview. This is an older review and some of the toaster ovens are discontinued, but many are still readily available and are top-rated products elsewhere.