Toilet Reviews

Editor's Note:
In 2016, Colorado and Georgia joined California and Texas in requiring "low-flow" toilets that use no more than 1.28 gallons per flush. That requires new technology to effectively clean the bowl. The good news is that manufacturers are rising to the challenge, with powerful flushing technology that uses air and suction to maximize the smaller flow of water.
 
Toto Drake CST744S
Specs that Matter
Gallons per flush - 1.6Bowl height - 14.6"Bowl shape - Elongated
Best Reviewed
Best standard toilet
Toto Drake CST744S

Reviewers say the Toto Drake CST744S practically cleans itself, allowing owners to tackle that chore less often than with other toilets. It removes a hefty 1,000 grams of solid waste or more with a single flush, using only 1.6 gallons of water. The CST744S is reported as very easy to install and it comes in five attractive colors.
See our full review »

image
TOTO Drake Elongated Bowl and Tank, Cotton White
Buy from Amazon.com
from Amazon.com
New: $211.69
Average Customer Review:  
American Standard Cadet 3
Specs that Matter
Gallons per flush - 1.6Bowl height - 16.1"Bowl shape - Round
Runner Up
Corner toilet
American Standard Cadet 3

If your bathroom is cramped, or if you'd just like to have something a bit different, you may want to consider the American Standard Cadet 3 corner toilet. Owners say it's a great option in a small space, is easy to install, and does a great job of bowl cleaning with one flush. However, that's because it uses 1.6 gallons per flush (gpf), which means it's not WaterSense certified, so can't be sold in California, Colorado,Georgia or Texas.

Toto Drake II CST454CEFG
Specs that Matter
Gallons per flush - 1.28Bowl Height - 16"Bowl shape - Elongated
Best Reviewed
Best low-flow toilet
Toto Drake II CST454CEFG

When it comes to conserving water, few models are more efficient than the Toto Drake II CST454CEFG toilet. It uses just 1.28 gallons of water per flush, but owners say you'd never know that you're saving water because of its very powerful flushing action. The Drake's Double Cyclone flushing technology and Cefionect glazing prevent bacteria buildup, making this toilet one of the easiest to keep clean, too. The 16-inch seat is ADA compliant.
See our full review »

Astor Bidet Fresh Water Spray
Runner Up
Bidet toilet seat attachment
Astor Bidet Fresh Water Spray

The Astor Bidet Fresh Water Spray toilet seat attachment is a great starting point for anyone who would love to try a bidet, but doesn't want to make too large of an investment in time or money. The Astor Bidet attaches quickly and easily to any toilet seat, and owners say it's exceptionally durable. Users like that they can cut down on the amount of toilet paper used, and feel like a bidet is a step up in personal cleanliness.

Toto Aquia CST416M
Specs that Matter
Gallons per flush - .9 liquids; 1.6 solidsBowl height - 15.3"Bowl shape - Elongated
Best Reviewed
Best dual-flush toilet
Toto Aquia CST416M

Dual-flush toilets are becoming increasingly popular for their water-saving features, and reviewers say that the Toto Aquia CST416M performs better than most. It gets high marks in professional testing for bowl cleaning and is reported as very quiet. Owners love having the dual flush option -- a particularly popular feature for those who are trying to be more conscientious about their water consumption. The Toto Aquia CST416M is available in five colors.
See our full review »

Toto Aquia Wall-Hung Dual-Flush Toilet
Specs that Matter
Gallons per flush - 1.0 liquids; 1.6 solids Bowl height - Depends on installBowl shape - Elongated
Runner Up
Wall-mounted toilet
Toto Aquia Wall-Hung Dual-Flush Toilet

Wall-mounted toilets are very popular in Europe, but more Americans are buying into their stylish, modern, easy-to-clean vibe. And no model gets better reviews than the Toto Aquia Wall-Hung Dual-Flush Toilet. This wall-mounted toilet comes in two colors, white and beige. Owners rave about its performance, saying it thoroughly flushes away waste, but they adore its trendy appearance. The Aquia Wall-Hung toilet is WaterSense certified.

Types of Toilets
Single Flush

This is the most common type of toilet and they get the best reviews for flushing performance, which includes bowl cleaning and solid waste removal. However, that's because most standard, single flush toilets use 1.6 gallons of water per flush (gpf) and are not WaterSense certified. That means they don't meet the low-flow requirements that are in place in California, Colorado, Georgia and Texas, and they don't qualify for rebates. While most online retailers won't ship a non-compliant toilet to those four states, others will. Keep in mind, though, that your state or community may have penalties in place for those who purchase and install non-compliant toilets; such as withholding inspections, denying permits or leveeing fines.

Corner

While corner toilets are relatively rare -- and are pricier than traditional toilets -- people love them for their small footprint and for offering the option of a different look in their bathroom. Corner toilets are particularly good for small spaces or for renovation projects that turn, say, a storage area into an extra bathroom.

Low-Flow

Low-flow toilets, which use 1.28 gpf or less, are the wave of the future and are the only type that meet regulations in place in California, Colorado, Georgia and Texas. Low-flow toilets are also often referred to as High Efficiency Toilets, abbreviated as HET. The challenge of the low-flow toilet is to use as little water as possible, while still offering good bowl cleaning performance and solid waste removal. Manufacturers have risen to this challenge by developing technologies that combine various types of pressure to move the water more powerfully. These toilets qualify for WaterSense certification and may be eligible for a rebate from your local water provider. You can check to see if your provider offers rebates for WaterSense toilets at the <a href="http://epa.gov/watersense/rebate_finder_saving_money_water.html" target="new"><u>EPA website</u></a>. Rebates are sometimes substantial -- up to $100 or so -- and, in some cases, could cover the cost of your new toilet.

Bidet Attachments

These are becoming increasingly popular in the U.S. People fall in love with bidets while traveling overseas, or just like the idea of a more thorough cleaning after doing their business. They can also help cut down on the amount of toilet paper used -- and they're definitely a better alternative than toilet wipes, which can wreak havoc on your plumbing. Bidet toilet attachments are highly affordable, super easy to install, and fit most toilet seats.

Dual Flush

Dual flush technology solves some of the problems inherent in both single flush toilets (using too much water) and low-flow toilets (too little water for effective bowl cleaning). Dual-flush toilets have one button for an effective 1.6-gallon flush for solid waste, and a second button for liquid waste that typically uses .9 gpf, although that can vary from .8 gpf to 1.1 gpf and still be considered "water saving." The combination of the lower and higher flushes averages out to the HET requirement of 1.28 gpf. Like low-flow toilets, these WaterSense toilets may qualify for a rebate.

Wall-Mounted

There's no cooler-looking toilet than the wall-mounted toilet. Although they are traditional, gravity-fed, tank toilets, the tank is hidden in the wall and the toilet is just a seat attached to the wall. Without a tank, bolts, or a skirt, these toilets are super easy to clean -- and makes cleaning the bathroom floor a lot simpler as well. And did we mention how cool they look? Because they are seriously stylish. However, they're pricey, and installing that hidden tank isn't for the faint of heart. But if you can afford it, we say go for it!

Aesthetics are important too.

Even if you can't afford a wall-mounted toilet, you still want your fixtures to be as nice-looking as possible. Most toilets are still either white or beige, but some come in several neutral shades, plus an occasional black toilet (usually with a higher price tag). Toilet designs can vary from the standard, curved design to skirted designs that are easier to clean.

Number one or number two?

Sorry, we couldn't resist. All standard toilets come in one or two-piece designs, with two-piece toilets by far the most common. These have a separate tank and bowl; you install the bowl first, then bolt the tank to the bowl. A one-piece toilet integrates the tank and bowl. One-piece toilets are easier to clean, and many owners prefer the way they look in a bathroom, but they're also heavier and can be more difficult to install. They also cost more than two-piece toilets.

Don't forget you need a seat!

Very few toilets come with a seat, and those that do are often panned for the cheapness of the included seat. The majority of the toilets in this report don't come with a seat. The advantage to buying a toilet without a seat is that you can choose the type of seat you prefer, whether that be plastic, wood, heated, or padded. Also, while we include each toilet's height measurement in this report, that's the height of the bowl without the toilet seat, a seat will add two or three -- or more -- inches.

Finding The Best Toilets
Our Sources1. ConsumerReports.org
Toilet Ratings2. Maximum Performance
Toilet Performance Testing3. TerryLove.com
Terry Love's Consumer Toilet ReportsSee All

One important factor in whether or not a toilet can do its job in a single flush is its Maximum Performance (MaP) rating. MaP is an independent testing organization that assesses hundreds of toilets using a paste made of soybean and rice to simulate human waste, as well as wads of toilet paper. Each toilet must pass at least four out of five separate flush tests. The minimum standard is 250 grams of solid waste, which is average for an adult, and toilets are tested up to 1,000 grams. Manufacturers voluntarily submit products for testing and pay a fee, and MaP scores have become a gold standard for evaluating flush performance.

In addition to reviewing the results of each toilet's MaP test, we evaluated the results of professional tests of toilets conducted by editors of ConsumerReports.org, as well as recommendations by plumber Terry Love, who runs a popular website devoted to plumbing supplies. Even more importantly, we reviewed the input of hundreds, sometimes thousands, of customers who have actually bought and used those recommended toilets to see how they performed in real world use. We used all of that information to find and recommend the best toilets for any bathroom or lifestyle.